{ "study": { "id": "cosmetic-plastic-surgery-ai-visibility-four-platform-v1.0", "title": "Cosmetic Plastic Surgery AI Search Visibility Across Four Platforms", "url": "https://rotgar.com/medical/resources/cosmetic-plastic-surgery-ai-visibility-four-platform-study", "version": "1.0", "license": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/", "author": "Evgeniy Yudin", "authorOrcid": "https://orcid.org/0009-0007-8400-9561", "publisher": "Rotgar Research", "publicationDate": "2026-10-30", "fieldworkStart": "2026-10-30T14:08:10.698Z", "fieldworkEnd": "2026-10-30T15:08:51.169Z", "plannedRequests": 216, "queryCells": 18, "repeats": 3, "cities": [ "New York City", "Chicago", "Miami" ], "intents": [ { "key": "rhinoplasty", "label": "Rhinoplasty" }, { "key": "facelift", "label": "Facelift surgery" }, { "key": "breast_augmentation", "label": "Breast augmentation" } ], "collectionStatus": "COMPLETE", "protocolSha256": "86a567b0de7a7cc232238285d37874ba5309d55a0b1b35e2f2b6aca695bee5b4", "planSha256": "61188022d389c9b9a7a0ec0cdd2c37cb522125d82511f42b4d590d3c054e7351", "surfaceNotes": [ "US English; country-level location 2840; cities specified in the query; Google desktop/Windows settings.", "ChatGPT and Gemini collected with DataForSEO LLM Scraper, not direct model APIs; ChatGPT force_web_search enabled.", "AI Overviews collected from Google organic AI Overview items with asynchronous loading; AI Mode collected from its separate Google endpoint.", "Same-day sequential waves. Provider-side caching, signed-in personalization and physical city IP were not controlled.", "A missing AI answer is not evidence that a cosmetic surgery clinic was absent from an answer.", "Google Standard queue delivery at normal priority 1 was fixed prospectively from preflight onward. ChatGPT and Gemini used Live delivery. Per-observation timestamps and original/recovery statuses are retained." ], "models": { "chatgpt": [ "gpt-6" ], "gemini": [ "3.5 Flash-Lite" ], "ai_overviews": [], "ai_mode": [] }, "plannedObservations": 216, "preflightCellsExcluded": 4, "firstPassRequests": 216, "recoveryRequests": 0, "totalCoreRequests": 216, "firstPassFailures": 0, "recoveredCaptures": 0, "deliveryModes": { "chatgpt": { "live": 54, "standard_queue": 0 }, "gemini": { "live": 54, "standard_queue": 0 }, "ai_overviews": { "live": 0, "standard_queue": 54 }, "ai_mode": { "live": 0, "standard_queue": 54 } }, "preflightRequestsExcluded": 4, "diagnosticProbeRequestsExcluded": 0, "technicalRequestsExcluded": 4, "readOnlyRetrievalRequestsExcluded": 526 }, "platformSummary": [ { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "planned": 54, "completed": 54, "answers": 54, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 39, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 300, "uniqueUrls": 218, "uniqueDomains": 111, "withinPairs": 54, "plannedPairs": 54, "answerPairs": 54, "definedUrlPairs": 48, "definedDomainPairs": 48, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 30, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 18, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 6, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.04883886733393312, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.1129567481129981, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.07814218773429299, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.18073079698079697 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "planned": 54, "completed": 54, "answers": 54, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 54, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 398, "uniqueUrls": 184, "uniqueDomains": 114, "withinPairs": 54, "plannedPairs": 54, "answerPairs": 54, "definedUrlPairs": 54, "definedDomainPairs": 54, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 54, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.29291459569237344, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.36042578279420384, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.29291459569237344, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.36042578279420384 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "planned": 54, "completed": 54, "answers": 48, "noAnswer": 6, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 47, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 311, "uniqueUrls": 220, "uniqueDomains": 110, "withinPairs": 54, "plannedPairs": 54, "answerPairs": 42, "definedUrlPairs": 42, "definedDomainPairs": 42, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 40, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 2, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 12, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.2094904103832676, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.272327738399167, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.21996493090243097, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.2859441253191254 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "planned": 54, "completed": 54, "answers": 54, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 53, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 185, "uniqueUrls": 105, "uniqueDomains": 43, "withinPairs": 54, "plannedPairs": 54, "answerPairs": 54, "definedUrlPairs": 54, "definedDomainPairs": 54, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 52, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 2, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.13533950617283955, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.23611111111111105, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.14054487179487182, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.24519230769230763 } ], "intentSummary": [ { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "intentLabel": "Rhinoplasty", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 18, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 14, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 110, "uniqueUrls": 91, "uniqueDomains": 55, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 18, "definedUrlPairs": 17, "definedDomainPairs": 17, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 11, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 6, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 1, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.028431372549019607, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.07369493251846193, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.04393939393939394, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.11389216843762298 }, { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "intent": "facelift", "intentLabel": "Facelift surgery", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 18, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 10, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 80, "uniqueUrls": 61, "uniqueDomains": 41, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 18, "definedUrlPairs": 14, "definedDomainPairs": 14, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 6, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 8, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 4, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.08093149540517962, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.11518402232687948, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.1888401559454191, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.2687627187627188 }, { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "intentLabel": "Breast augmentation", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 18, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 15, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 110, "uniqueUrls": 93, "uniqueDomains": 47, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 18, "definedUrlPairs": 17, "definedDomainPairs": 17, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 13, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 4, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 1, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.04281713900134952, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.15038433788433792, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.055991643309457065, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.19665644184874956 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "intentLabel": "Rhinoplasty", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 18, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 18, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 137, "uniqueUrls": 71, "uniqueDomains": 54, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 18, "definedUrlPairs": 18, "definedDomainPairs": 18, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 18, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.2853999395666062, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.34470481597674574, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.2853999395666062, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.34470481597674574 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "intent": "facelift", "intentLabel": "Facelift surgery", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 18, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 18, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 135, "uniqueUrls": 73, "uniqueDomains": 56, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 18, "definedUrlPairs": 18, "definedDomainPairs": 18, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 18, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.2259698634698635, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.307979057979058, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.2259698634698635, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.307979057979058 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "intentLabel": "Breast augmentation", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 18, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 18, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 126, "uniqueUrls": 59, "uniqueDomains": 44, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 18, "definedUrlPairs": 18, "definedDomainPairs": 18, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 18, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.3673739840406507, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.42859347442680784, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.3673739840406507, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.42859347442680784 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "intentLabel": "Rhinoplasty", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 17, "noAnswer": 1, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 17, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 121, "uniqueUrls": 85, "uniqueDomains": 56, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 16, "definedUrlPairs": 16, "definedDomainPairs": 16, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 16, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 2, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.2151785714285714, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.2816541097791098, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.2151785714285714, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.2816541097791098 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "intent": "facelift", "intentLabel": "Facelift surgery", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 15, "noAnswer": 3, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 14, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 84, "uniqueUrls": 60, "uniqueDomains": 46, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 12, "definedUrlPairs": 12, "definedDomainPairs": 12, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 10, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 2, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 6, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.25606060606060604, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.3391203703703704, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.30727272727272725, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.40694444444444444 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "intentLabel": "Breast augmentation", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 16, "noAnswer": 2, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 16, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 106, "uniqueUrls": 80, "uniqueDomains": 57, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 14, "definedUrlPairs": 14, "definedDomainPairs": 14, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 14, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 4, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.16307234432234433, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.20441820084677229, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.16307234432234433, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.20441820084677229 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "intentLabel": "Rhinoplasty", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 18, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 18, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 60, "uniqueUrls": 42, "uniqueDomains": 23, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 18, "definedUrlPairs": 18, "definedDomainPairs": 18, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 18, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.13029100529100526, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.23796296296296301, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.13029100529100526, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.23796296296296301 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "intent": "facelift", "intentLabel": "Facelift surgery", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 18, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 17, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 69, "uniqueUrls": 41, "uniqueDomains": 14, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 18, "definedUrlPairs": 18, "definedDomainPairs": 18, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 16, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 2, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.1996693121693122, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.3092592592592593, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.22462797619047623, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.3479166666666667 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "intentLabel": "Breast augmentation", "planned": 18, "completed": 18, "answers": 18, "noAnswer": 0, "failed": 0, "notCollected": 0, "firstPassFailed": 0, "recoveryAttempts": 0, "recovered": 0, "sourceBearing": 18, "sourceUrlOccurrences": 56, "uniqueUrls": 42, "uniqueDomains": 23, "withinPairs": 18, "plannedPairs": 18, "answerPairs": 18, "definedUrlPairs": 18, "definedDomainPairs": 18, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 18, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.07605820105820106, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.1611111111111111, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.07605820105820106, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.1611111111111111 } ], "crossPlatformSummary": [ { "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "labelA": "ChatGPT", "labelB": "Gemini", "matchedPairs": 54, "plannedPairs": 54, "answerPairs": 54, "definedUrlPairs": 54, "definedDomainPairs": 54, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 39, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 15, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.023243327124654004, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.04243699817745226, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.032183068326444006, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.05875892055339543 }, { "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "labelA": "ChatGPT", "labelB": "Google AI Overviews", "matchedPairs": 54, "plannedPairs": 54, "answerPairs": 48, "definedUrlPairs": 47, "definedDomainPairs": 47, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 36, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 11, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 1, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 6, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.017910230542296367, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.03118508525266973, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.023382800985775814, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.040713861302096595 }, { "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "labelA": "ChatGPT", "labelB": "Google AI Mode", "matchedPairs": 54, "plannedPairs": 54, "answerPairs": 54, "definedUrlPairs": 54, "definedDomainPairs": 54, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 38, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 16, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.007051478669836158, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.02512333345666679, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.010020522320293487, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.03570157912263175 }, { "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "labelA": "Gemini", "labelB": "Google AI Overviews", "matchedPairs": 54, "plannedPairs": 54, "answerPairs": 48, "definedUrlPairs": 48, "definedDomainPairs": 48, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 47, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 1, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 6, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.05591098988157811, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.10895106051356047, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.05710058541097339, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.11126916818406177 }, { "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "labelA": "Gemini", "labelB": "Google AI Mode", "matchedPairs": 54, "plannedPairs": 54, "answerPairs": 54, "definedUrlPairs": 54, "definedDomainPairs": 54, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 53, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 1, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 0, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.040199152699152696, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.06058461248519729, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.04095762727838199, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.06172771838114441 }, { "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "labelA": "Google AI Overviews", "labelB": "Google AI Mode", "matchedPairs": 54, "plannedPairs": 54, "answerPairs": 48, "definedUrlPairs": 48, "definedDomainPairs": 48, "bothSourceNonemptyPairs": 46, "oneSourceEmptyPairs": 2, "bothSourceEmptyPairs": 0, "excludedNoAnswerPairs": 6, "excludedCollectionPairs": 0, "meanUrlJaccard": 0.03181991619491619, "meanDomainJaccard": 0.07243867243867243, "meanBothNonemptyUrlJaccard": 0.03320339081208646, "meanBothNonemptyDomainJaccard": 0.07558817993600601 } ], "sourceTypeSummary": [ { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "type": "homepage", "typeLabel": "Homepage", "count": 112, "denominator": 300, "share": 0.37333333333333335 }, { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "type": "treatment", "typeLabel": "Treatment / services path", "count": 59, "denominator": 300, "share": 0.19666666666666666 }, { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "type": "practitioner_team", "typeLabel": "Practitioner / team path", "count": 9, "denominator": 300, "share": 0.03 }, { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "type": "location", "typeLabel": "Location / contact path", "count": 5, "denominator": 300, "share": 0.016666666666666666 }, { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "type": "editorial", "typeLabel": "Editorial path", "count": 0, "denominator": 300, "share": 0 }, { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "type": "directory_social", "typeLabel": "Known directory / social host", "count": 30, "denominator": 300, "share": 0.1 }, { "platform": "chatgpt", "label": "ChatGPT", "type": "unclassified", "typeLabel": "Unclassified path", "count": 85, "denominator": 300, "share": 0.2833333333333333 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "type": "homepage", "typeLabel": "Homepage", "count": 135, "denominator": 398, "share": 0.3391959798994975 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "type": "treatment", "typeLabel": "Treatment / services path", "count": 148, "denominator": 398, "share": 0.37185929648241206 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "type": "practitioner_team", "typeLabel": "Practitioner / team path", "count": 6, "denominator": 398, "share": 0.01507537688442211 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "type": "location", "typeLabel": "Location / contact path", "count": 10, "denominator": 398, "share": 0.02512562814070352 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "type": "editorial", "typeLabel": "Editorial path", "count": 6, "denominator": 398, "share": 0.01507537688442211 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "type": "directory_social", "typeLabel": "Known directory / social host", "count": 49, "denominator": 398, "share": 0.12311557788944724 }, { "platform": "gemini", "label": "Gemini", "type": "unclassified", "typeLabel": "Unclassified path", "count": 44, "denominator": 398, "share": 0.11055276381909548 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "type": "homepage", "typeLabel": "Homepage", "count": 45, "denominator": 311, "share": 0.14469453376205788 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "type": "treatment", "typeLabel": "Treatment / services path", "count": 122, "denominator": 311, "share": 0.39228295819935693 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "type": "practitioner_team", "typeLabel": "Practitioner / team path", "count": 10, "denominator": 311, "share": 0.03215434083601286 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "type": "location", "typeLabel": "Location / contact path", "count": 3, "denominator": 311, "share": 0.00964630225080386 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "type": "editorial", "typeLabel": "Editorial path", "count": 8, "denominator": 311, "share": 0.02572347266881029 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "type": "directory_social", "typeLabel": "Known directory / social host", "count": 38, "denominator": 311, "share": 0.12218649517684887 }, { "platform": "ai_overviews", "label": "Google AI Overviews", "type": "unclassified", "typeLabel": "Unclassified path", "count": 85, "denominator": 311, "share": 0.2733118971061093 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "type": "homepage", "typeLabel": "Homepage", "count": 29, "denominator": 185, "share": 0.15675675675675677 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "type": "treatment", "typeLabel": "Treatment / services path", "count": 21, "denominator": 185, "share": 0.11351351351351352 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "type": "practitioner_team", "typeLabel": "Practitioner / team path", "count": 20, "denominator": 185, "share": 0.10810810810810811 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "type": "location", "typeLabel": "Location / contact path", "count": 7, "denominator": 185, "share": 0.03783783783783784 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "type": "editorial", "typeLabel": "Editorial path", "count": 2, "denominator": 185, "share": 0.010810810810810811 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "type": "directory_social", "typeLabel": "Known directory / social host", "count": 24, "denominator": 185, "share": 0.12972972972972974 }, { "platform": "ai_mode", "label": "Google AI Mode", "type": "unclassified", "typeLabel": "Unclassified path", "count": 82, "denominator": 185, "share": 0.44324324324324327 } ], "promptCells": [ { "cell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in New York City should I compare for rhinoplasty?" }, { "cell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in New York City offer rhinoplasty? Identify the surgeon and operating facility, and link to the evidence." }, { "cell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in New York City should I compare for facelift surgery?" }, { "cell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in New York City offer facelift surgery? Identify the surgeon and operating facility, and link to the evidence." }, { "cell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in New York City should I compare for breast augmentation?" }, { "cell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in New York City offer breast augmentation? Identify the surgeon and operating facility, and link to the evidence." }, { "cell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Chicago should I compare for rhinoplasty?" }, { "cell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Chicago offer rhinoplasty? Identify the surgeon and operating facility, and link to the evidence." }, { "cell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Chicago should I compare for facelift surgery?" }, { "cell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Chicago offer facelift surgery? Identify the surgeon and operating facility, and link to the evidence." }, { "cell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Chicago should I compare for breast augmentation?" }, { "cell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Chicago offer breast augmentation? Identify the surgeon and operating facility, and link to the evidence." }, { "cell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Miami should I compare for rhinoplasty?" }, { "cell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Miami offer rhinoplasty? Identify the surgeon and operating facility, and link to the evidence." }, { "cell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Miami should I compare for facelift surgery?" }, { "cell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Miami offer facelift surgery? Identify the surgeon and operating facility, and link to the evidence." }, { "cell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Miami should I compare for breast augmentation?" }, { "cell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "query": "Which cosmetic plastic surgery clinics in Miami offer breast augmentation? Identify the surgeon and operating facility, and link to the evidence." } ], "qualitativeSlots": [ { "slot": "Q01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "chatgpt", "queryCell": "P01", "observation": "O001", "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:14.607Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:14.607Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "professional_society_directory", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Saved main text in full (7,635 characters), directory clinician cards, certification disclaimer, and saved text footer/contact links; no filter interaction, linked profiles, images or dynamic map inspected.", "notes": [ "The captured generic directory showed clinician cards with professional designations, practice addresses and individual consultation/contact routes. Its displayed cards were in Portugal, not an NYC-specific selection.", "Rhinoplasty appeared in the procedure filter, not a substantive procedure explanation. Hospital addresses were not treated as proof of an operating facility, and certification labels were not independently verified." ], "pageTitle": "Find a Plastic Surgeon Near Me | ASPS", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:58.286Z", "pageSha256": "8da333e54f7b6c014cd314a19fe556eb81d3e0d74d641d810f335428aa1337a3", "finalUrl": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "homepage" }, { "slot": "Q02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "gemini", "queryCell": "P01", "observation": "O002", "url": "https://drkassir.com/rhinoplasty", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:08:31.581Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:08:31.581Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "first_party_procedure_page", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": true, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Saved main text characters 0–6,000, saved extraction contexts for rhinoplasty consultation, fee/financing and facility mentions, matching full-text excerpts around consultation and surgical-setting mentions, and final 1,800 text characters/contact links; no images, videos, linked pages or dynamic content inspected.", "notes": [ "The page describes rhinoplasty techniques, identifies the surgeon and training background, gives New York and New Jersey office information, and explicitly offers personal consultations at those offices. It includes fee and financing context plus a practice contact route.", "An operating-facility location was not established from the inspected practice-authored scope. A generic cost factor, a navigation label and a patient testimonial were not accepted as facility identification." ], "pageTitle": "Best Rhinoplasty New York City | Dr. Ramtin Kassir | Triple Board Certified", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:01.328Z", "pageSha256": "1d4ba30b16ecf9be7f029996c65abab202c92a93dcb6c65d3d83f23766c427f6", "finalUrl": "http://www.drkassir.com/rhinoplasty/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "treatment" }, { "slot": "Q03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "ai_overviews", "queryCell": "P01", "observation": "O003", "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/face/rhinoplasty", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:30.697Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:30.697Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "first_party_procedure_page", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": true, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Saved main text characters 0–6,000 and the inspected Personal Consultation, Procedure and Cost of Rhinoplasty sections from the saved text/extraction, plus final 1,800 full-text characters and contact links; no images, patient photos, video or linked resources inspected.", "notes": [ "The page discusses primary and revision rhinoplasty, describes the named surgeon, provides an office address/contact route and explains how a personalized cost breakdown is prepared.", "The Procedure section explicitly places surgery in the practice-operated operating room across the hall from the main office. This records a page statement, not independent accreditation verification. The exact in-person consultation site was not separately established in the bounded review." ], "pageTitle": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Dr. Jennifer Levine", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:59.724Z", "pageSha256": "6ce74387a534d2048271f032c0ff94d494f86789e41e489f26395ca21a22414f", "finalUrl": "https://www.drjenniferlevine.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/face/rhinoplasty/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "treatment" }, { "slot": "Q04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "ai_mode", "queryCell": "P01", "observation": "O004", "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:08:26.242Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:08:26.242Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "uninspectable_insufficient_static_text", "manualReview": false, "reviewAgent": null, "pageType": null, "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": null, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": null, "notes": [ "The selected appointment interface yielded only 72 static text characters. It remains uninspectable under the fixed source-review rule; no substantive replacement page was selected." ], "pageTitle": "Book an Appointment | 740 Park Plastic Surgery", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:58.609Z", "pageSha256": "13a3ecac7ebf4524d15be308cc219d7fc4c4962e08f5db1aa3a0803862568d1f", "finalUrl": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "chatgpt", "queryCell": "P03", "observation": "O011", "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:10:04.527Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:10:04.527Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "first_party_practice_homepage", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Saved main text characters 0–8,000 including the facelift procedure-guide/type descriptions and named-surgeon biography/presentation, final 1,800 full-text characters, extraction contexts and contact links; no images, videos or linked facility/financing pages inspected.", "notes": [ "The homepage contains facelift-type descriptions and surgeon-specific professional information, with New York office details and a consultation contact route.", "A surgical-center navigation label and a financing link were not treated as substantive facility or payment evidence. The precise consultation site was not established from the bounded inspected text." ], "pageTitle": "New York Facial Plastic Surgery | Best Facial Plastic Surgery NYC", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:59.337Z", "pageSha256": "781b9e8750499710651a614b288fbd9159d902e3a54b897675c2f033882eca27", "finalUrl": "https://www.newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "homepage" }, { "slot": "Q06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "gemini", "queryCell": "P03", "observation": "O012", "url": "https://drkassir.com/face/facelift", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:11:01.072Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:11:01.072Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "first_party_procedure_page", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Saved main text characters 0–4,500; targeted saved-text/extraction passages under First Step, How is a Facelift Performed and cost/financing; saved footer addresses and contact links; no images, videos or linked office/surgery-center pages inspected.", "notes": [ "The page discusses facelift techniques, identifies the surgeon and professional background, lists practice offices and a consultation contact route, and provides a fee estimate with financing qualifications.", "The described surgical settings are conditional alternatives, not an identifiable operating facility for the requested operation. No specific consultation location was assigned from a booking invitation or office address alone." ], "pageTitle": "Best Facelift New York City | Dr. Ramtin Kassir | Triple Board-Certified Surgeon", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:01.540Z", "pageSha256": "fe7190fc3896fd76c269acdb00ac4dc65c326b1a96a927840b55a73d9d235fa2", "finalUrl": "http://www.drkassir.com/face/facelift/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "treatment" }, { "slot": "Q07", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "ai_overviews", "queryCell": "P03", "observation": "O009", "url": "https://drkolker.com/face/face-lift", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:13:46.732Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:13:46.732Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "first_party_procedure_page", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": true, "operatingFacilityEvidence": true, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Saved full extracted text in full (20,727 characters) and 461-character main landmark. Substantive body sections outside the short main landmark were read, including named-surgeon discussion, procedure, recovery, planning and consultation; navigation and testimonials were not used as substantive surgeon/facility proof. No images, video or linked pages inspected.", "notes": [ "The saved body, beyond the short main landmark, explains facelift methods and the named surgeon’s approach, invites an office consultation and patient visit at the listed Park Avenue practice, and provides appointment/contact routes.", "The practice-authored procedure section explicitly identifies its office-based ambulatory surgery suite on Park Avenue. This is observed facility information, not verification of its accreditation, clinical suitability or outcomes." ], "pageTitle": "Best Facelift NYC | Top Facial Plastic Surgeon in New York City", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:01.238Z", "pageSha256": "09853fee30a1e5bf9d2eeef13c07858d32e959ee70dd9bfe7aa9d4eca6f74e6b", "finalUrl": "https://drkolker.com/face/face-lift/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "treatment" }, { "slot": "Q08", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "ai_mode", "queryCell": "P03", "observation": "O010", "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdkdGVEVnhkZxgK", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:45.477Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:45.477Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "uninspectable_navigation_or_booking_surface", "manualReview": false, "reviewAgent": null, "pageType": null, "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": null, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": null, "notes": [ "The selected URL was a Google place-viewer navigation surface with no inspectable static body. It remains a navigation capture with all page-feature values unknown." ], "pageTitle": "Place Viewer", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:02.089Z", "pageSha256": "28822ca8ff21576a26ddfbe149b823afb0463b18d0b497621146cdead077bef0", "finalUrl": "https://www.google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdkdGVEVnhkZxgK", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q09", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "chatgpt", "queryCell": "P05", "observation": "O017", "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/new-york", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:27.991Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:27.991Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "professional_society_directory", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Saved extracted text in full (12,635 characters), including the New York surgeon listing cards and ASPS verification disclaimer, plus contact links; no procedure filters, linked profiles, map or images inspected.", "notes": [ "The New York directory presents named clinician cards with professional designations, practice addresses and per-clinician contact/consultation routes. Those displayed designations are not independently verified credentials.", "Breast augmentation appears as a procedure-filter option, not substantive treatment detail in this captured directory. Consultation addresses and operating facilities were not inferred from listing addresses." ], "pageTitle": "Find a New York Plastic Surgeon Near Me | American Society of Plastic Surgeons", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:01.731Z", "pageSha256": "a9cda54f034b79f1da0f74d1f60e4144992734c2952fa99efef6f65717739bb4", "finalUrl": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/new-york", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q10", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "gemini", "queryCell": "P05", "observation": "O018", "url": "https://weillcornell.org/cosmetic-breast-surgery", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:54.251Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:54.251Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "first_party_institution_service_page", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": true, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Saved extracted text in full (6,194 characters), including the 3,569-character main content, clinical-service location blocks, breast-surgery options, in-person/video appointment discussion and named Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery doctor cards; no linked profiles, images or booking forms opened.", "notes": [ "The institutional page includes augmentation with implants among its surgery options, identifies named physicians with a plastic-surgery specialty, lists two Upper East Side care locations and describes initial consultation/in-person appointment access.", "Generic surgical-suite language does not identify a particular operating facility or map it to one of the listed consultation/care addresses. No individual surgeon’s procedure assignment or credentials were independently verified." ], "pageTitle": "Cosmetic Breast Surgery | Patient Care", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:02.102Z", "pageSha256": "c203706c025a9570ac4f345892ff83b445807fb87ae75518ec12d50711e998c1", "finalUrl": "https://weillcornell.org/cosmetic-breast-surgery", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q11", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "ai_overviews", "queryCell": "P05", "observation": "O019", "url": "https://greenbergcosmeticsurgery.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/breast/breast-implants", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:29:54.691Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:29:54.691Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "first_party_procedure_page", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": true, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Saved main text characters 0–6,500, saved consultation-location and financing/cost excerpts in full-text contexts, final 1,900 full-text characters and practice contact links; no patient images, videos, linked office or financing pages inspected.", "notes": [ "The page discusses breast-implant material, shape and size choices with the named surgeon, explicitly offers consultations at named practice offices, lists addresses/contact routes and describes financing/cost context.", "Recovery-suite or concierge language was not treated as operating-facility identification. The bounded review does not establish which surgical facility is used for a particular augmentation." ], "pageTitle": "Best Breast Implants Long Island & NYC | Greenberg Cosmetic Surgery", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:04.341Z", "pageSha256": "e303f1b1ea9842bbcf78ea29f7c7cd52bd774ae874562ac02d7fe73fe5061cec", "finalUrl": "https://www.greenbergcosmeticsurgery.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/breast/breast-implants/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "treatment" }, { "slot": "Q12", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "ai_mode", "queryCell": "P05", "observation": "O020", "url": "https://antell-md.com/breast/breast-augmentation-nyc", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:46.438Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:46.438Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "first_party_procedure_page", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": true, "operatingFacilityEvidence": true, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Saved main text characters 0–6,500, targeted full-text/extraction passages describing the operating room and final-cost components, and final 1,900 text characters containing in-office/virtual consultation and contact information; no patient photographs, videos or linked pages inspected.", "notes": [ "The page describes augmentation and implant choices, the named surgeon’s background, a New York consultation process, practice address/contact options and a qualified price range with cost components.", "The practice-authored procedure section identifies a private operating room across from Lenox Hill Hospital. It was not relabeled as surgery inside that hospital, and no accreditation or clinical-quality conclusion was independently verified." ], "pageTitle": "Breast Augmentation NYC | Breast Implants in Manhattan", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:03.680Z", "pageSha256": "0b88dfa98086fbe8482fb6570bce4a847f6a7ff43354ff20281bffd353f41996", "finalUrl": "https://antell-md.com/breast/breast-augmentation-nyc/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "treatment" }, { "slot": "Q13", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "chatgpt", "queryCell": "P07", "observation": "O027", "url": null, "status": "answer_without_sources", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:21:02.159Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:21:02.159Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "not_applicable_answer_without_sources", "manualReview": false, "reviewAgent": null, "pageType": null, "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": null, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": null, "notes": [ "No page substituted for the fixed first-reference slot." ], "pageTitle": null, "fetchedAt": null, "pageSha256": null, "finalUrl": null, "httpStatus": null, "sourcePathType": null }, { "slot": "Q14", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "gemini", "queryCell": "P07", "observation": "O028", "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Rhinoplasty", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:21:30.234Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:21:30.234Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "commercial_provider_directory", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Saved main text characters 0–10,000, final 1,500 full-text characters, extraction contexts and contact-link list. Root also inspected consultation-button HTML after independent QA. No linked profiles, pricing panels, map, images or JavaScript controls opened.", "notes": [ "The directory supplies named surgeons with specialty/experience fields and locality information. Its displayed professional labels were not independently verified. The consultation control had no static provider-contact destination; publisher support links do not establish provider contact.", "Procedure-filter labels and patient testimonials were not treated as substantive practice-authored rhinoplasty detail. Consultation-site, facility and fee values remain unknown; a generic pricing control is not a quote." ], "pageTitle": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Chicago, IL", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:08.092Z", "pageSha256": "b19bb880b032aa9d83fc81c5aeb8834eb1553aba31c33e099b7606a9f6bd293e", "finalUrl": "https://www.realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Rhinoplasty", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "directory_social" }, { "slot": "Q15", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "ai_overviews", "queryCell": "P07", "observation": "O025", "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/revision-rhinoplasty", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:55.225Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:55.225Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "unavailable_http", "manualReview": false, "reviewAgent": null, "pageType": null, "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": null, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": null, "notes": [ "The fixed selected URL returned HTTP 403 and an interstitial rather than substantive page content. All feature values remain unknown; no alternate source was substituted." ], "pageTitle": "Just a moment...", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:03.860Z", "pageSha256": "b6ec9047ddfb2d95cbe5cf419a53c67091b8a828edfd87b6e328bf316da85793", "finalUrl": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/revision-rhinoplasty", "httpStatus": 403, "sourcePathType": "treatment" }, { "slot": "Q16", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "ai_mode", "queryCell": "P07", "observation": "O026", "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:58.421Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:58.421Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "first_party_practice_homepage", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": true, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Saved main text characters 0–9,500, including the Rhinoplasty Procedural Spotlight and named-surgeon profiles; final 1,500 full-text characters, extraction contexts and practice contact links. Patient testimonials, form options and navigation were not used to prove procedure assignment. No images, video or linked pages inspected.", "notes": [ "A substantive rhinoplasty spotlight connects nose-reshaping work to the named facial plastic surgeon. The homepage also provides professional-role information, the Chicago practice address and a consultation contact route.", "The practice explicitly advertises an on-site surgical suite; this identifies a practice-operated setting, not an independently verified accreditation or a confirmed facility assignment for every rhinoplasty. No specific consultation-site assignment was inferred." ], "pageTitle": "Facial Plastic Surgeon Chicago | Facial Plastic Surgery in Chicago", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:04.862Z", "pageSha256": "fc6d1e5b7e89f6441f9ba4056462e7cff7f8089271c8da337745c560d75b872c", "finalUrl": "https://www.goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "homepage" }, { "slot": "Q17", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "chatgpt", "queryCell": "P09", "observation": "O033", "url": "https://hudsonfacialplastics.com/pricing", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:11.722Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:11.722Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "unavailable_network_or_safety", "manualReview": false, "reviewAgent": null, "pageType": null, "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": null, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": null, "notes": [ "Source retrieval stopped at the public-network safety check before any page body was saved. All page-feature values remain unknown; the selected URL was retained without replacement." ], "pageTitle": null, "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:04.429Z", "pageSha256": null, "finalUrl": null, "httpStatus": null, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q18", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "gemini", "queryCell": "P09", "observation": "O034", "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facelift", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:49.783Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:49.783Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "commercial_provider_directory", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Saved main text characters 0–10,000, final 1,500 full-text characters, extraction contexts and contact-link list. Named-surgeon listing attributes and the explicit provider-linked facelift offer were read separately from patient-review narratives. Root also inspected consultation-button HTML after independent QA. No linked profiles, pricing panels, map, images or JavaScript controls opened.", "notes": [ "The directory provides named surgeons with specialty/experience fields and locality information. A provider-linked facelift discount is visible payment/fee context, not a verified treatment quote. The consultation control had no static provider-contact destination; publisher support links do not establish provider contact.", "Patient accounts of surgery in an office and general procedure filters were not treated as practice-authored procedure or operating-facility evidence. No specific consultation site was established in this scope." ], "pageTitle": "Top Facelift Doctors in Chicago, IL", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:09.478Z", "pageSha256": "dcd3e3c3fbf81c5d48eb0ba21bee84712a8a60a8d9dc961e44d03310395b67e2", "finalUrl": "https://www.realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facelift", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "directory_social" }, { "slot": "Q19", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "ai_overviews", "queryCell": "P09", "observation": "O035", "url": null, "status": "no_answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:56.956Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:56.956Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "not_applicable_no_answer", "manualReview": false, "reviewAgent": null, "pageType": null, "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": null, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": null, "notes": [ "No page substituted for the fixed first-reference slot." ], "pageTitle": null, "fetchedAt": null, "pageSha256": null, "finalUrl": null, "httpStatus": null, "sourcePathType": null }, { "slot": "Q20", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "ai_mode", "queryCell": "P09", "observation": "O036", "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdSZmVqZzROSEk0GAo", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:21.389Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:21.389Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "uninspectable_navigation_or_booking_surface", "manualReview": false, "reviewAgent": null, "pageType": null, "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": null, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": null, "notes": [ "The selected Google navigation surface yielded no substantive static page text. All source-page feature states remain unknown; the AI answer was not substituted for the selected page." ], "pageTitle": "Place Viewer", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:05.222Z", "pageSha256": "9ab11f0ecc6d0a57e09039bdfbba113be4ac840915aafee79d93467a01d6f7ee", "finalUrl": "https://www.google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdSZmVqZzROSEk0GAo", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q21", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "chatgpt", "queryCell": "P11", "observation": "O043", "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:46.461Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:46.461Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "directory_listing", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Q21/Q22 breast-augmentation context. Saved body main text: procedure-filter heading, named doctor cards with credential/experience/locality metadata, testimonial snippets and provider-action labels; visible footer support links checked separately. Surgeon and locality positives use card metadata, not testimonials or the directory publisher's location.", "notes": [ "The directory supplies named plastic-surgeon cards with professional-role, experience and locality information. These are directory assertions, not independent credential verification or an assignment of a particular operation to every clinician.", "The requested procedure is a listing/filter context and appears in patient reviews, but no substantive breast-augmentation explanation or provider-specific procedure detail was admitted from this page. Generic pricing and consultation labels do not establish fees, a consultation site or a direct provider contact route in the saved text." ], "pageTitle": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Chicago, IL", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:10.104Z", "pageSha256": "c2dfb8b78e8a368b8af6e1ef3ff82f0edbfb14e525e2d33219d125df7ca6dc1e", "finalUrl": "https://www.realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "directory_social" }, { "slot": "Q22", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "gemini", "queryCell": "P11", "observation": "O044", "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:42.194Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:42.194Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "directory_listing", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Q21/Q22 breast-augmentation context. Saved body main text: procedure-filter heading, named doctor cards with credential/experience/locality metadata, testimonial snippets and provider-action labels; visible footer support links checked separately. Surgeon and locality positives use card metadata, not testimonials or the directory publisher's location.", "notes": [ "The directory supplies named plastic-surgeon cards with professional-role, experience and locality information. These are directory assertions, not independent credential verification or an assignment of a particular operation to every clinician.", "The requested procedure is a listing/filter context and appears in patient reviews, but no substantive breast-augmentation explanation or provider-specific procedure detail was admitted from this page. Generic pricing and consultation labels do not establish fees, a consultation site or a direct provider contact route in the saved text." ], "pageTitle": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Chicago, IL", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:10.104Z", "pageSha256": "c2dfb8b78e8a368b8af6e1ef3ff82f0edbfb14e525e2d33219d125df7ca6dc1e", "finalUrl": "https://www.realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "directory_social" }, { "slot": "Q23", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "ai_overviews", "queryCell": "P11", "observation": "O041", "url": "https://chicagoplasticsurgery.com/", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:08.153Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:08.153Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "practice_homepage", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Q23 breast-augmentation context. Entire saved main landmark: Dr. Sweis biography/training, practice philosophy, surgical-category links, testimonials and awards text. Visible CONTACT INFO address, telephone, email and patient enquiry form inspected in the full-text tail. Navigation and testimonials were not used as requested-procedure evidence.", "notes": [ "The page substantively identifies Dr. Iliana Sweis, her surgical training and role, and places the private practice in Northbrook, with a street address and patient contact options. Northbrook is the stated practice locality, not verification of a Chicago city location.", "Broad cosmetic-breast-surgery copy, award categories and navigation are not treated as substantive breast-augmentation detail. Unnamed hospital privileges do not identify an operating facility, and an appointment button plus a contact address alone does not identify the consultation site." ], "pageTitle": "Top Plastic Surgery Clinic in Northbrook, IL", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:14.657Z", "pageSha256": "ece8dc62f6654ca8a8cc54d68d75173ec6abd9572e675104f1c958dd5b80cf0d", "finalUrl": "https://chicagoplasticsurgery.com/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "homepage" }, { "slot": "Q24", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "ai_mode", "queryCell": "P11", "observation": "O042", "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdoaWVEZG1NdxgK", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:37.473Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:37.473Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "uninspectable_navigation_or_booking_surface", "manualReview": false, "reviewAgent": null, "pageType": null, "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": null, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": null, "notes": [ "The selected navigation surface did not expose substantive static page text. Source-page facts remain unknown rather than being copied from the AI answer or another practice page." ], "pageTitle": "Place Viewer", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:09.975Z", "pageSha256": "841777fba1033192d3f2e6a3cbea62d9710e9c4404e975b807d83eacedce2346", "finalUrl": "https://www.google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdoaWVEZG1NdxgK", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q25", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "chatgpt", "queryCell": "P13", "observation": "O049", "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:00.159Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:00.159Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "directory_listing", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Q25 rhinoplasty context. Entire saved main/body directory text: named surgeon cards, role/experience/locality metadata, procedure-specific promotional offers, testimonials and directory controls. Full-text publisher/support tail and actual saved provider-card hyperlinks were checked to avoid treating review links as provider consultation contact.", "notes": [ "Named surgeon cards state professional roles and practice localities across Miami and surrounding municipalities. Their credential and experience assertions were not independently verified, and listing locality is not proof of an operating or consultation site.", "The page carries a provider-specific rhinoplasty starting-price offer and another procedure-specific offer. These establish fee/offer context only, not a current binding price or substantive clinical treatment detail. Testimonial content, generic consultation buttons and directory support were not used to fill the remaining fields." ], "pageTitle": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:14.753Z", "pageSha256": "7816f50774a090375fd54202c2350c63ee467ecf927ff2b902e2ae23db6de59a", "finalUrl": "https://www.realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "directory_social" }, { "slot": "Q26", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "gemini", "queryCell": "P13", "observation": "O050", "url": "https://miamivibesmag.com/post/the-top-rated-rhinoplasty-surgeons-in-miami", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:28.695Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:28.695Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "editorial_roundup", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Q26 rhinoplasty context. Saved main article: procedure explainer, cost discussion, eight surgeon biographies, company/address lines, quoted reviews and generic preparation/recovery sections. The biographies and practice-address fields, not review praise or publisher contacts, support positive evidence. No linked practice was fetched.", "notes": [ "This third-party roundup has substantive rhinoplasty explanation, surgeon biographies with surgical-role assertions, named practice addresses and procedure-cost context. The article's rankings, credentials, medical advice and price estimates were not independently validated.", "Practice company names, addresses and general preparation language do not identify the operating facility or an actual consultation site. Publisher contact and external practice-homepage links are not treated as a provider consultation contact route." ], "pageTitle": "The Top-Rated Rhinoplasty Surgeons in Miami", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:13.190Z", "pageSha256": "e6dbd1c66977da12ed1fa8132755a91cfe0c9b3d30089a79600978031fce135e", "finalUrl": "https://www.miamivibesmag.com/post/the-top-rated-rhinoplasty-surgeons-in-miami", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "treatment" }, { "slot": "Q27", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "ai_overviews", "queryCell": "P13", "observation": "O051", "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/nose-surgery", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:09.334Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:09.334Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "practice_procedure_page", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Q27 rhinoplasty context. Entire saved procedure-page main text, including repeated legacy blocks: procedure/consultation explanations, named surgeon-role cards, out-of-town logistics, fee qualifications, FAQs and coordinator CTA. Full-text consultation/contact footer contains the practice street address, phone and email. Automated extraction candidates were not accepted without page-text context.", "notes": [ "The selected page explains rhinoplasty, identifies named plastic surgeons in non-testimonial service cards, and provides clinic contact and procedure-fee/payment context. The saved page contains repeated blocks with differing starting prices and fee-inclusion language, so no single amount is verified as a current quote.", "The procedure copy asserts use of an accredited facility but does not identify a named center, on-site surgical suite or operating location in the inspected text. Generic accreditation language and the clinic's contact address are not treated as facility identification. Initial-consultation process copy does not explicitly locate the visit at that address." ], "pageTitle": "Rhinoplasty Miami | Nose Surgery From $4,900 | Spectrum Aesthetics", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:15.463Z", "pageSha256": "e93bef37ebc3dc8ef6e9f6962ccc04ecf7e8cd53f9a9b7a7c1c34074f731e827", "finalUrl": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/nose-surgery/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q28", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "platform": "ai_mode", "queryCell": "P13", "observation": "O052", "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdaeWFHdDBlURgK", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:27.481Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:27.481Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "uninspectable_navigation_or_booking_surface", "manualReview": false, "reviewAgent": null, "pageType": null, "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": null, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": null, "notes": [ "The predetermined source is an empty static navigation surface in this capture. No alternative page or AI-answer narrative was substituted, and all source features remain unknown." ], "pageTitle": "Place Viewer", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:15.210Z", "pageSha256": "b7124feaf43cae195e1cb5d1893ef1d8e8f975faacdd5615b2f85edcee8b96ce", "finalUrl": "https://www.google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdaeWFHdDBlURgK", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q29", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "chatgpt", "queryCell": "P15", "observation": "O059", "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/documents/holidays/2024/Surgeon-Checklist.pdf", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:20.080Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:20.080Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "unavailable_network_or_safety", "manualReview": false, "reviewAgent": null, "pageType": null, "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": null, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": null, "notes": [ "The selected PDF could not be inspected within the bounded retrieval limit. No feature is coded from its filename, publisher identity or the AI answer." ], "pageTitle": null, "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:16.336Z", "pageSha256": null, "finalUrl": null, "httpStatus": null, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q30", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "gemini", "queryCell": "P15", "observation": "O060", "url": "https://thecliniccompass.com/miami/best-plastic-surgeons", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:19.229Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:19.229Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "directory_roundup", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": null, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": null, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Q30 facelift context. Saved main ranked-list text, ten practice/name/address cards, editorial vetting guidance, clinic-matching form, treatment dropdown and matching/privacy disclosures. Relevant visible footer checked to distinguish publisher services from the listed clinical practices.", "notes": [ "The inspected roundup supplies addresses for identified clinical practices in Miami and surrounding municipalities. Listed names and general credential-selection advice are not substantive biographies or proof of any individual surgeon's qualifications.", "Facelift appears in a broad form dropdown rather than substantive procedure detail. Generic facility-vetting advice does not identify where these practices operate. The publisher's unassigned clinic-matching widget is not a named provider's consultation contact route, fee quote or consultation-site identification." ], "pageTitle": "10 Best Plastic Surgeons in Miami, FL (2026) | ClinicCompass", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:16.417Z", "pageSha256": "bfcf6fbfd5f19cc4956ce4de0150e3a76f7fec9dbf9b606d9edb9009ce186185", "finalUrl": "https://thecliniccompass.com/miami/best-plastic-surgeons/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q31", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "ai_overviews", "queryCell": "P15", "observation": "O057", "url": "https://nidiadejesusmd.com/facelift-miami-cost-types", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:52.378Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:52.378Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "practice_procedure_article", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": true, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Q31 facelift context. Entire saved main article: facelift definition and techniques, named-surgeon clinical role, cost qualifications, surgery discussion, daily in-person clinic follow-up, local office/hotel context, FAQs and telephone/email consultation invitation. This is page-content coding, not medical advice or a clinical-accuracy appraisal.", "notes": [ "The article gives substantive facelift information tied to a named plastic surgeon and describes actual daily in-person clinic visits, an office-area ZIP code and local hotel logistics. These support clinic/visit-location context without establishing a street-address match or operating site.", "The article discusses cost ranges and a personalized consultation estimate, not a verified quote. Its general statement about accredited surgical facilities does not name or otherwise identify the practice's operating facility. Outpatient treatment and follow-up visits do not themselves identify where the operation takes place." ], "pageTitle": "Facelift in Miami: Types, Cost, and Recovery in 2026 - Dr. Nidia De Jesus, MD", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:25.135Z", "pageSha256": "668e917d771e52bb23621f521b7c0457c2021f9470417c1e957cfeb6a9579f71", "finalUrl": "https://nidiadejesusmd.com/facelift-miami-cost-types/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "treatment" }, { "slot": "Q32", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "platform": "ai_mode", "queryCell": "P15", "observation": "O058", "url": "https://drbustillo.com/", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:49.771Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:49.771Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "practice_homepage", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": true, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Q32 facelift context. Entire saved main landmark: named surgeon's facelift/rhinoplasty focus, professional biography and training, philosophy/safety copy, procedure links and Miami-office visit paragraph with address and phone. Full-text tail includes the named practice's consultation form. Testimonials and generic safety promises were not used as facility evidence.", "notes": [ "The practice's substantive copy associates a deep-plane facelift with Dr. Bustillo and gives facial-plastic-surgery biography/training information. The Miami-office paragraph describes patient visits and immediately supplies an address; this is office/consultation context, not an operating-facility claim.", "A phone number and consultation form support provider contact. Safety language, professional titles and the office address do not independently establish an operating facility, credential validity or clinical quality." ], "pageTitle": "Dr. Bustillo | Miami’s Leader in Facial Plastic Surgery", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:17.509Z", "pageSha256": "e528c5f1530dfdf3f760608adb4bee71e44eb8be5ff438ba02d35d9fd220862c", "finalUrl": "https://www.drbustillo.com/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "homepage" }, { "slot": "Q33", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "chatgpt", "queryCell": "P17", "observation": "O065", "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/?city=Miami&state=FL", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:41.938Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:41.938Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "professional_society_directory", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Q33 breast-augmentation context. Entire saved directory main: membership/verification disclaimer, procedure filters, named surgeon listing cards with addresses and phone numbers, Request Consult labels, and society explanation of member roles. Full-text society footer kept separate from provider cards.", "notes": [ "The directory identifies named member surgeons and supplies clinical practice addresses, provider phone numbers and consultation-request actions. Its membership and credential assertions were not independently verified; the page itself warns that current profile and licensure information is not independently checked by the directory.", "Breast augmentation appears in filters rather than substantive procedure detail. Listing addresses and Request Consult actions do not identify an actual consultation site or where surgery occurs. No operating facility or procedure fee was inferred." ], "pageTitle": "Find a Miami Plastic Surgeon Near Me | American Society of Plastic Surgeons", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:17.297Z", "pageSha256": "9f04571efb47c1ea19915869251668d21462fcbb04b9adf2e42bee99f53a35bf", "finalUrl": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/?city=Miami&state=FL", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "homepage" }, { "slot": "Q34", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "gemini", "queryCell": "P17", "observation": "O066", "url": "https://avanaplasticsurgery.com/", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:36.141Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:36.141Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "practice_homepage", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Q34 breast-augmentation context. Entire saved main and full visible-text extraction inspected: practice/service introduction, four listed locations, testimonials, financing, surgeon-team cards, consultation form, breast/body service descriptions with prices, travel/virtual-consultation copy and contact footer. Expanded full-text scope restores named surgeon-role cards omitted from the main extraction. The substantive A team of top Surgeons block, not navigation or testimonials, supplies names and professional roles.", "notes": [ "The practice page gives breast-augmentation service context, multiple actual practice addresses, a provider consultation form and payment/financing context. Locations include Miami, Hialeah Gardens and Dallas; their presence does not verify that every procedure is available at every site.", "The full saved visible text contains non-testimonial team cards naming plastic or cosmetic surgeons with those roles, including Mameniskis, McDaniel, Luster and Schusterman. This supports named-surgeon information, not independent credentials or assignment of breast augmentation to every clinician. A general surgical-suite claim is not tied to an identifiable operating location. Virtual consultation and office addresses do not establish an in-person consultation site." ], "pageTitle": "Avana Plastic Surgery | Best Cosmetic Surgery in Miami", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:18.318Z", "pageSha256": "4ba2998eebf1b2c18a959d6618cadb5e2d0c6308d609ada7b56dbff7499e76d5", "finalUrl": "https://avanaplasticsurgery.com/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "homepage" }, { "slot": "Q35", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "ai_overviews", "queryCell": "P17", "observation": "O067", "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/pricing-and-fees-overview", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:37:21.717Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:37:21.717Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "practice_pricing_page", "treatmentEvidence": null, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": true, "inspectedScope": "Q35 breast-augmentation context. Entire saved main pricing page: named surgeon's professional scope, individualized consultation/estimate process, operation price table, cost-inclusion qualifications, financing/payment methods and contact invitation. Visible footer supplies the practice address. A price row is fee context, not a treatment explanation.", "notes": [ "The page substantively identifies Dr. Hochstein's plastic-surgery role and provides qualified procedure pricing, payment options, practice address and consultation contact. The requested operation's price row is coded as fee context rather than substantive treatment detail.", "Final pricing depends on the consultation and named cost components; published ranges are not verified quotes. Facility fees, a consultation invitation and the office address do not identify an operating center or explicitly locate an actual consultation visit." ], "pageTitle": "Leonard Hochstein : Pricing and Fees Overview - Miami Plastic Surgeon", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:20.601Z", "pageSha256": "97533e6d29d9b6035b42a07bef248aa9dae755b7ab2e6945573f8470e8e5a227", "finalUrl": "https://www.lhochsteinmd.com/pricing-and-fees-overview/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "unclassified" }, { "slot": "Q36", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "platform": "ai_mode", "queryCell": "P17", "observation": "O068", "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "status": "source_selected", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "capturedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:51.428Z", "firstPassAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:51.428Z", "recoveryAt": null, "reviewStatus": "inspected_static_page", "manualReview": true, "reviewAgent": "assistant_page_text_review", "pageType": "practice_homepage", "treatmentEvidence": true, "practitionerEvidence": true, "locationEvidence": true, "consultationLocationEvidence": null, "operatingFacilityEvidence": null, "contactEvidence": true, "priceQualificationEvidence": null, "inspectedScope": "Q36 breast-augmentation context. Entire saved main landmark: named plastic surgeon's breast-procedure experience and practice scope, surgical procedure cards, virtual-consultation controls, medspa copy and media/video text. Visible named-practice footer address and telephone inspected separately. Medspa in-person consultation language was not repurposed for surgical consultation location.", "notes": [ "The main narrative associates breast augmentation and other breast operations with the named plastic surgeon's practice, beyond navigation alone. Credential and case-volume claims remain page assertions rather than independently verified qualifications or outcomes.", "The practice address and telephone support locality/contact. In-spa consultation copy concerns the nonsurgical medspa, while surgical consultation controls are virtual; neither identifies an actual surgical consultation location. No operating-facility relationship or fee context was established in this inspected homepage scope." ], "pageTitle": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D.", "fetchedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:19.433Z", "pageSha256": "bab97ab8f042a6854ec879fa809094bfdba156db89095594a5cc70562d69195c", "finalUrl": "https://www.lhochsteinmd.com/", "httpStatus": 200, "sourcePathType": "homepage" } ], "responseMetrics": [ { "observation": "O001", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:14.607Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:14.607Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O002", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:08:31.581Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:08:31.581Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O003", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:30.697Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:30.697Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O004", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:08:26.242Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:08:26.242Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O005", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:08:45.976Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:08:45.976Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O006", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:30.715Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:30.715Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O007", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:01.565Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:01.565Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 11, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:30.094Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:30.094Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O009", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:13:46.732Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:13:46.732Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O010", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:45.477Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:09:45.477Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 15, "sourceDomains": 11, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:10:04.527Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:10:04.527Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 10, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:11:01.072Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:11:01.072Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O013", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:11:31.395Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:11:31.395Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O014", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:11:52.383Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:11:52.383Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O015", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:12:10.152Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:12:10.152Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O016", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:14:12.528Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:14:12.528Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O017", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:27.991Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:27.991Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O018", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:54.251Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:54.251Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O019", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 9, "sourceDomains": 9, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:29:54.691Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:29:54.691Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O020", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:46.438Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:19:46.438Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O021", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:02.269Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:02.269Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O022", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:24.746Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:24.746Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O023", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:17.776Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:17.776Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O024", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:38.902Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:38.902Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O025", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:55.225Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:55.225Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O026", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:58.421Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:20:58.421Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O027", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:21:02.159Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:21:02.159Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O028", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:21:30.234Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:21:30.234Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O029", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:10.516Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:10.516Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O030", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:12.671Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:12.671Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O031", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:16.812Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:16.812Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O032", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:26.143Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:26.143Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 12, "sourceDomains": 10, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:11.722Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:11.722Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O034", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:49.783Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:49.783Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O035", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "no_answer", "firstPassStatus": "no_answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": false, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:56.956Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:30:56.956Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O036", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:21.389Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:21.389Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O037", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:21.670Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:21.670Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O038", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:12.613Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:12.613Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O039", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:27.927Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:27.927Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O040", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:42.237Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:31:42.237Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O041", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:08.153Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:08.153Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O042", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:37.473Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:37.473Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O043", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:46.461Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:46.461Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O044", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:42.194Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:42.194Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O045", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:52.828Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:32:52.828Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O046", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:07.521Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:07.521Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O047", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:12.262Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:12.262Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O048", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "no_answer", "firstPassStatus": "no_answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": false, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:08.180Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:08.180Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O049", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:00.159Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:00.159Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O050", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:28.695Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:28.695Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O051", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:09.334Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:09.334Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O052", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:27.481Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:33:27.481Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O053", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 9, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:21.964Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:21.964Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O054", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:55.422Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:55.422Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O055", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:40.398Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:40.398Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 11, "sourceDomains": 10, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:34.262Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:34.262Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O057", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:52.378Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:52.378Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O058", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:49.771Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:34:49.771Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O059", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:20.080Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:20.080Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 10, "sourceDomains": 10, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:19.229Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:19.229Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O061", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:22.794Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:22.794Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O062", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:17.439Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:17.439Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O063", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:46.620Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:35:46.620Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O064", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:20.022Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:20.022Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O065", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:41.938Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:41.938Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O066", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:36.141Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:36.141Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O067", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:37:21.717Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:37:21.717Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O068", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:51.428Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:51.428Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O069", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:52.986Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:36:52.986Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O070", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:37:42.794Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:37:42.794Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O071", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:37:06.664Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:37:06.664Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 24, "sourceDomains": 14, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:37:20.064Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:37:20.064Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O073", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:38:43.499Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:38:43.499Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O074", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:38:44.013Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:38:44.013Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O075", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:38:13.754Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:38:13.754Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O076", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 9, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:38:40.928Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:38:40.928Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O077", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:30.887Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:30.887Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O078", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:15.709Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:15.709Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O079", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:06.396Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:06.396Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O080", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 9, "sourceDomains": 9, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:00.385Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:00.385Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O081", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:15.798Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:15.798Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O082", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:26.077Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:26.077Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O083", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:50.010Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:50.010Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O084", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "no_answer", "firstPassStatus": "no_answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": false, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:46.489Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:46.489Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O085", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:09.792Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:09.792Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O086", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:51.058Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:39:51.058Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O087", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "no_answer", "firstPassStatus": "no_answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": false, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:01.863Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:01.863Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O088", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:20.551Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:20.551Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O089", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:40.137Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:40.137Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O090", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:07.242Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:07.242Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O091", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:52.091Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:52.091Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O092", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:40.865Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:40.865Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O093", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:10.751Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:10.751Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O094", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:56.129Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:40:56.129Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O095", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 9, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:27.125Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:27.125Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O096", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:09.190Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:09.190Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O097", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:37.722Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:37.722Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O098", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:34.970Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:34.970Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O099", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:37.746Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:41:37.746Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O100", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:42:27.989Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:42:27.989Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O101", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:42:54.109Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:42:54.109Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O102", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:42:51.271Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:42:51.271Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O103", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:42:59.437Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:42:59.437Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O104", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:42:44.224Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:42:44.224Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O105", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:16.361Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:16.361Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O106", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:21.978Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:21.978Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O107", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:24.441Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:24.441Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 10, "sourceDomains": 10, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:39.316Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:39.316Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O109", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:02.350Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:02.350Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O110", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:37.297Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:37.297Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O111", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 1, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:49.766Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:49.766Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O112", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:53.451Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:43:53.451Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O113", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:33.902Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:33.902Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 16, "sourceDomains": 10, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:28.255Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:28.255Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O115", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:26.884Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:26.884Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O116", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:04.285Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:04.285Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 13, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:55.144Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:55.144Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O118", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:46.976Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:44:46.976Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 10, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:49.966Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:49.966Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O120", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 1, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:17.564Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:17.564Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O121", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:12.975Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:12.975Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O122", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:34.988Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:34.988Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O123", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:43.608Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:43.608Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O124", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:53.020Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:45:53.020Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 10, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:39.475Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:39.475Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O126", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:24.452Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:24.452Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O127", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:20.785Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:20.785Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O128", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:21.916Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:21.916Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O129", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:52.194Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:52.194Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O130", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:42.330Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:42.330Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O131", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:41.626Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:46:41.626Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O132", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:09.887Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:09.887Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O133", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 1, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:02.596Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:02.596Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O134", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 9, "sourceDomains": 9, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:02.782Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:02.782Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 10, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:22.737Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:22.737Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O136", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:17.942Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:17.942Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O137", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:54.578Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:54.578Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O138", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 9, "sourceDomains": 9, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:54.303Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:54.303Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O139", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:54.241Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:54.241Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O140", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:46.792Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:47:46.792Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O141", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:02.474Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:02.474Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O142", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:09.778Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:09.778Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O143", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:19.411Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:19.411Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O144", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:21.848Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:21.848Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O145", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:49:23.238Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:49:23.238Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O146", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:37.645Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:37.645Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O147", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:49:35.356Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:49:35.356Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O148", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:58.938Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:48:58.938Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O149", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:49:51.893Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:49:51.893Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O150", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:37.216Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:37.216Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O151", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:00.191Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:00.191Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O152", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 9, "sourceDomains": 9, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:22.366Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:22.366Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O153", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:11.817Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:11.817Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O154", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:18.632Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:18.632Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O155", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:51:57.882Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:51:57.882Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O156", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:49.260Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:49.260Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O157", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:40.429Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:50:40.429Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O158", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:52:23.609Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:52:23.609Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O159", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:51:11.057Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:51:11.057Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O160", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:51:24.846Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:51:24.846Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O161", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:10.479Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:10.479Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O162", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:52:55.293Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:52:55.293Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O163", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:52:53.820Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:52:53.820Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O164", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:06.679Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:06.679Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O165", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:09.273Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:09.273Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O166", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:17.278Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:17.278Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O167", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:36.436Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:36.436Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O168", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:40.154Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:40.154Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 15, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:54:18.384Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:54:18.384Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O170", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:46.344Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:53:46.344Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O171", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 9, "sourceDomains": 9, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:54:52.533Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:54:52.533Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O172", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:54:10.567Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:54:10.567Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O173", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:55:22.919Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:55:22.919Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O174", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "no_answer", "firstPassStatus": "no_answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": false, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:55:54.558Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:55:54.558Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O175", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:55:39.627Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:55:39.627Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 16, "sourceDomains": 11, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:55:21.147Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:55:21.147Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O177", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:06.921Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:06.921Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O178", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:55:53.237Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:55:53.237Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 11, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:35.135Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:35.135Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O180", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:49.955Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:49.955Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O181", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:25.253Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:25.253Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 20, "sourceDomains": 12, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:29.944Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:29.944Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O183", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:52.911Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:56:52.911Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O184", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:59:17.315Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:59:17.315Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 11, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:59:45.512Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:59:45.512Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O186", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:59:41.300Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:59:41.300Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O187", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "no_answer", "firstPassStatus": "no_answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": false, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:00:19.235Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:00:19.235Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O188", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:59:34.010Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T14:59:34.010Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O189", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:00:07.990Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:00:07.990Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O190", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:02:29.841Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:02:29.841Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O191", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 1, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:00:15.901Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:00:15.901Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O192", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:00:42.967Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:00:42.967Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O193", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 9, "sourceDomains": 9, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:03:33.676Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:03:33.676Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O194", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:00:49.608Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:00:49.608Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 11, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:01:05.265Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:01:05.265Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O196", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 5, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:01:17.441Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:01:17.441Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O197", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 5, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:04:05.660Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:04:05.660Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O198", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:04:34.021Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:04:34.021Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 19, "sourceDomains": 17, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:04:34.949Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:04:34.949Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O200", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:05:51.730Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:05:51.730Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O201", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:04:28.624Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:04:28.624Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O202", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:05:25.689Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:05:25.689Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O203", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 6, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:06:36.040Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:06:36.040Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O204", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:04:50.214Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:04:50.214Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O205", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:05:21.225Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:05:21.225Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O206", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:07:07.753Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:07:07.753Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O207", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:05:56.120Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:05:56.120Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O208", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 0, "sourceDomains": 0, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:06:18.263Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:06:18.263Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O209", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 8, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:08:40.377Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:08:40.377Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O210", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:07:24.885Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:07:24.885Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O211", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 6, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:07:38.395Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:07:38.395Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O212", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 8, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:07:23.638Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:07:23.638Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O213", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 2, "sourceDomains": 2, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:07:39.056Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:07:39.056Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null }, { "observation": "O214", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 3, "sourceDomains": 3, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:08:02.524Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:08:02.524Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "gpt-6" }, { "observation": "O215", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "live", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "live", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 7, "sourceDomains": 7, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:08:51.169Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:08:51.169Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": "3.5 Flash-Lite" }, { "observation": "O216", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "status": "answer", "firstPassStatus": "answer", "recoveryAttempted": false, "recovered": false, "attemptCount": 1, "deliveryMode": "standard_queue", "firstPassDeliveryMode": "standard_queue", "recoveryDeliveryMode": null, "answerPresent": true, "sourceUrls": 4, "sourceDomains": 4, "collectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:08:25.107Z", "firstPassCollectedAt": "2026-10-30T15:08:25.107Z", "recoveryCollectedAt": null, "model": null } ], "citations": [ { "observation": "O001", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "ASPS surgeon directory" }, { "observation": "O001", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://aafprs.org/", "domain": "aafprs.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "AAFPRS surgeon directory" }, { "observation": "O002", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drkassir.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drkassir.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty New York City | Dr. Ramtin Kassir" }, { "observation": "O002", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York-City/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in New York City, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O002", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://cityfacialplastics.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "cityfacialplastics.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Best Nose Job Surgeon New York City - Dr. Linkov" }, { "observation": "O002", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/procedures/nose-surgery/rhinoplasty-nose-job", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Nose Surgery New York City - Dr. Philip Miller" }, { "observation": "O002", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in New York, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O002", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drjoshuazimm.com/rhinoplasty-nose-job-nyc", "domain": "drjoshuazimm.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty NYC | Nose Job Surgeon in New York" }, { "observation": "O002", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/about-dr-jacono/best-rhinoplasty-surgeon-america", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty Surgeon US - New York Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O003", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Dr. Jennifer Levine" }, { "observation": "O003", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://mdface.com/top-nose-surgeons-in-nyc", "domain": "mdface.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "One of NYC's Top Nose Surgeons Answers Your Questions" }, { "observation": "O003", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/procedures/nose-surgery/rhinoplasty-nose-job", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Nose Surgery New York City" }, { "observation": "O003", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drmonicatadros.com/procedures/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drmonicatadros.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC & Manhattan | Dr. Monica Tadros, MD" }, { "observation": "O003", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://mdface.com/treatments/non-surgical-nose-job-nyc", "domain": "mdface.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The Best Non-Surgical Nose Job in NYC - Pearlman Aesthetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O003", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://plasticsurgeoninnyc.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "plasticsurgeoninnyc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Palstic Surgeon NYC | Adam Schaffner, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O003", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://reddit.com/r/PlasticSurgery/comments/12yfk50/recs_for_rhinoplasty_nyc", "domain": "reddit.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Recs for rhinoplasty NYC? : r/PlasticSurgery - Reddit" }, { "observation": "O004", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O004", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-norman-j-pastorek-md-facs", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Revision Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O004", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/adam-schaffner-facs-md-16219?LocIdent=181134&entity_id=pr_9gK8I5mXWkKVkRO0o_kqwB-lo_C16pYpHusEC1V8S4KAkw4h-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Plastic Surgery Consultation" }, { "observation": "O004", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/george-lefkovits-md-129511?LocIdent=69689&entity_id=pr_bzEhhQArbkqOqpyG6OTzsh-lo_4XGyirazuUSaN1qSqT1BJB-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Plastic Surgery Consultation" }, { "observation": "O005", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/ent/services/facial-plastic-reconstructive-surgery/cosmetic/nose-surgery-rhinoplasty", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) NYC | Mount Sinai - New York" }, { "observation": "O005", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://newfaceny.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "newfaceny.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in NYC | Best Nose Surgeon in New York City" }, { "observation": "O005", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://albertplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "albertplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Albert Plastic Surgery: Facial Plastic Surgery NYC | Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O005", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "David Rosenberg, MD: Celebrity Facial Plastic Surgeon In New York" }, { "observation": "O005", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drkassir.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drkassir.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty New York City | Dr. Ramtin Kassir" }, { "observation": "O005", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/best-rhinoplasty-usa-surgeon", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty Surgeon - New York Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O005", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York-City/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in New York City, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O005", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://castleconnolly.com/expertise/rhinoplasty/new-york-ny", "domain": "castleconnolly.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Find doctors that specialize in Rhinoplasty near New York, NY" }, { "observation": "O006", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drjoshuazimm.com/rhinoplasty-nose-job-nyc", "domain": "drjoshuazimm.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty NYC | Nose Job Surgeon in New York" }, { "observation": "O006", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lipsg.com/doctors/plastic-surgeon-dr-reish-new-york-nyc", "domain": "lipsg.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Dr. Richard G. Reish Plastic Surgeon NYC New York Long Island" }, { "observation": "O006", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://longevity.haus/best/rhinoplasty/new-york-city", "domain": "longevity.haus", "type": "treatment", "title": "10 Best Rhinoplasty Clinics in New York City (2026)" }, { "observation": "O006", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://mdface.com/top-nose-surgeons-in-new-york-city", "domain": "mdface.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top Nose Surgeons in New York City" }, { "observation": "O006", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://parkavenueplasticsurgeon.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "parkavenueplasticsurgeon.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Best Nose Job Surgeon in New York" }, { "observation": "O007", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Philip Miller" }, { "observation": "O007", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drbenpaul.com/face-new-york-city/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drbenpaul.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty In New York City (NYC) | Dr. Benjamin Paul" }, { "observation": "O007", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://samanmd.com/the-surgeons/masoud-saman", "domain": "samanmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Masoud Saman, MD, Facial Plastic Surgeon NYC" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://samanmd.com/rhinoplasty-nyc", "domain": "samanmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in New York" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/facts", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Official Information About Philip J. Miller, MD, FACS | Philip J. Miller, MD" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/about-facial-plastic-surgeon", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Philip J. Miller, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drsamrizk.com/cosmetic-surgery.html", "domain": "drsamrizk.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Facial Cosmetic Surgery, NYC" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drsamrizk.com/about-dr-rizk/our-mission.html", "domain": "drsamrizk.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top Surgical Facilities NYC" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drkolker.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty NYC | Nose Job New York City" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://drkolker.com/our-practice", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Cosmetic Surgery NYC | Plastic Surgery Manhattan" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://cangelloplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "cangelloplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official practice website" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/David-Cangello-MD.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "David L. Cangello, MD" }, { "observation": "O008", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/ent/services/facial-plastic-reconstructive-surgery/cosmetic/nose-surgery-rhinoplasty", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) NYC" }, { "observation": "O009", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drkolker.com/face/face-lift", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift NYC | Top Facial Plastic Surgeon in New York City" }, { "observation": "O009", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://antell-md.com/face/facelift-nyc", "domain": "antell-md.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift In New York City, NY | Darrick E. Antell M.D., F.A.C.S." }, { "observation": "O009", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://greenbergcosmeticsurgery.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/face/facelift", "domain": "greenbergcosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift Long Island & NYC - Greenberg Cosmetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O009", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/face/facelift", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift New York City | Dr. Jennifer Levine" }, { "observation": "O009", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/plastic-surgery-results/facelift/best-facelift-usa-surgeon", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift Surgeon in New York City" }, { "observation": "O009", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/face/revision-facelift", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Revision Facelift NYC | Dr. Jennifer Levine" }, { "observation": "O010", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdkdGVEVnhkZxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Andrew Jacono" }, { "observation": "O010", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEhNemJUTjBZZxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "New York Center for Facial Plastic and Laser Surgery" }, { "observation": "O010", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Facelift" }, { "observation": "O010", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdJM05qaGZObTVvGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "740 Park Plastic Surgery: Stafford R. Broumand, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O010", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEhCdU0yZDRNQRgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Maurice M. Khosh, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://aafprs.org/profile?id=17206", "domain": "aafprs.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Profile" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/dr-jacono-named-best-facelift-surgeon", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Dr Jacono Named Best Facelift Surgeon in New York" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://pearlmanmd.com/", "domain": "pearlmanmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://longevity.haus/best/facelift/new-york-city", "domain": "longevity.haus", "type": "treatment", "title": "10 Best Facelift Clinics in New York City" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://fellowships.aafprs.org/docs/aafprs/AAFPRS%20Descriptions%20Handbook_February%202026.pdf", "domain": "fellowships.aafprs.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "AAFPRS DescriptionsHandbook_January 2026=2.pdf" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/face/facelift", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift New York City" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://cityfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "cityfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/about-facial-plastic-surgeon", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Philip J. Miller, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://drschaffner.com/", "domain": "drschaffner.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 12, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/cosmetic-procedures/facelift/surgeon", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Choosing a Plastic Surgeon for a Facelift" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 13, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/patient-safety?sub=Accredited+Facilities", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Accredited Facilities | Patient Safety" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 14, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O011", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 15, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Society of Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drkassir.com/face/facelift", "domain": "drkassir.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift New York City | Triple Board-Certified Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "New York Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Jennifer Levine: Top Plastic Surgeon NYC" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/procedures/procedures-for-women/facelift", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Top Celebrity Facelift Surgeon In New York City | Deep Plane" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drbenpaul.com/face-new-york-city/facelift", "domain": "drbenpaul.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift In New York City | Dr. Benjamin Paul" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/about-dr-jacono/dr-jacono-reviews-and-news/best-face-lift-surgeon", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Dr. Jacono: New York's Top Facelift Surgeon - Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "David Rosenberg, MD: Celebrity Facial Plastic Surgeon In New York" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York-City/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in New York City, NY" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://facialartistrymd.com/", "domain": "facialartistrymd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Konstantin Vasyukevich, MD: Facial Plastic Surgery in NYC" }, { "observation": "O012", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://albertplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "albertplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Albert Plastic Surgery: Facial Plastic Surgery NYC | Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O013", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Facelift" }, { "observation": "O013", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-norman-j-pastorek-md-facs", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Facelift" }, { "observation": "O013", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-joseph-j-rousso-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Modified Extended Deep Plane Face And Neck Lift" }, { "observation": "O013", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://tebra.com/care/provider/elliott-rose-md-1609986892?lid=510096032", "domain": "tebra.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Cosmetic Facial Surgery" }, { "observation": "O013", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/george-lefkovits-md-129511?LocIdent=69689&entity_id=pr_bzEhhQArbkqOqpyG6OTzsh-lo_4XGyirazuUSaN1qSqT1BJB-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Plastic Surgery Consultation" }, { "observation": "O015", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drkassir.com/face/facelift", "domain": "drkassir.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift New York City | Triple Board-Certified Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O015", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "New York Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O015", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/procedures/procedures-for-women/facelift", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Top Celebrity Facelift Surgeon In New York City | Deep Plane" }, { "observation": "O015", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Jennifer Levine: Top Plastic Surgeon NYC" }, { "observation": "O015", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://aestheticmatch.com/blog/new-york/best-facelift-surgeons-in-new-york-city-guide", "domain": "aestheticmatch.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Best Facelift Surgeons in New York City (2025 Guide) - AestheticMatch" }, { "observation": "O015", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/adam-schaffner-md.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Adam Schaffner, MD, FACS | American Society of Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O016", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Facelift" }, { "observation": "O016", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://tebra.com/care/provider/elliott-rose-md-1609986892?lid=510096032", "domain": "tebra.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Cosmetic Facial Surgery" }, { "observation": "O016", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://calendly.com/drkopelman", "domain": "calendly.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Virtual Plastic Surgery Consult With Dr. Joel Kopelman" }, { "observation": "O016", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/george-lefkovits-md-129511?LocIdent=69689&entity_id=pr_bzEhhQArbkqOqpyG6OTzsh-lo_4XGyirazuUSaN1qSqT1BJB-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Plastic Surgery Consultation" }, { "observation": "O017", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/new-york", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "New York surgeon directory" }, { "observation": "O017", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/cosmetic-procedures/breast-augmentation/surgeon", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Choosing a Plastic Surgeon for Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O018", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://weillcornell.org/cosmetic-breast-surgery", "domain": "weillcornell.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Cosmetic Breast Surgery | Patient Care - Weill Cornell Medicine" }, { "observation": "O018", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/care-services/plastic-surgery/breast-plastic-surgery-services", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Plastic Surgery Services | NYU Langone Health" }, { "observation": "O018", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/surgery/services/plastic-surgery/aesthetic/breast-enhancement/breast-augmentation", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Surgery NYC | Mount Sinai - New York" }, { "observation": "O018", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drkolker.com/", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation NYC | Top Plastic Surgeon New York City" }, { "observation": "O018", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drpfeifer.com/", "domain": "drpfeifer.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "New York Plastic Surgeon & NYC Breast Augmentation Specialist" }, { "observation": "O018", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://stevenlevinemd.com/best-breast-implants-plastic-surgeon-upper-east-side-nyc", "domain": "stevenlevinemd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implants Surgery NYC - STEVEN M. LEVINE, MD" }, { "observation": "O019", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://greenbergcosmeticsurgery.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/breast/breast-implants", "domain": "greenbergcosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Breast Implants Long Island & NYC | Greenberg Cosmetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O019", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://droliviahutchinson.com/plastic-surgery-nyc/breast/breast-implant-replacement", "domain": "droliviahutchinson.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implant Replacement Upper East Side | Best Implant Replacement NYC" }, { "observation": "O019", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://doctorsplasticsurgery.com/new-york/breast-augmentation-updated", "domain": "doctorsplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Boob Job NYC | Best Affordable Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O019", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://nycbreastplasticsurgeon.com/how-to-choose-a-breast-plastic-surgeon-in-new-york", "domain": "nycbreastplasticsurgeon.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "how to choose a breast plastic surgeon in New York" }, { "observation": "O019", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/new-york", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Find a New York Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O019", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://stevenlevinemd.com/best-breast-implants-plastic-surgeon-upper-east-side-nyc", "domain": "stevenlevinemd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implants Surgery NYC - STEVEN M. LEVINE, MD" }, { "observation": "O019", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://bodysculptingcenternyc.com/best-breast-implants-plastic-surgeon-manhattan-nyc-breast-augmentation", "domain": "bodysculptingcenternyc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implants / Breast Augmentation Plastic Surgeon NYC" }, { "observation": "O019", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://biancamolinamd.com/breast/breast-augmentation", "domain": "biancamolinamd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation In Manhattan | Breast Implants New York City" }, { "observation": "O019", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://psurgery.com/breast-augmentation-new-york-city/cost", "domain": "psurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Plastic Surgery Breast Enhancement Cost - Dr. Scott Newman" }, { "observation": "O020", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://antell-md.com/breast/breast-augmentation-nyc", "domain": "antell-md.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation NYC | Breast Implants in Manhattan" }, { "observation": "O020", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nyplasticsurg.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/breast/augmentation", "domain": "nyplasticsurg.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation NYC | Dr. John E. Sherman" }, { "observation": "O020", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://orenlerman.com/locations/new-york-office", "domain": "orenlerman.com", "type": "location", "title": "New York Plastic Surgeon Office | Oren Z. Lerman, MD" }, { "observation": "O020", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drumahmood.com/best-in-class-upper-east-side-nyc-plastic-surgeon-reviews", "domain": "drumahmood.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best in Class Upper East Side NYC Plastic Surgeon Reviews" }, { "observation": "O021", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drkolker.com/", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation NYC | Top Plastic Surgeon New York City" }, { "observation": "O021", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drmichaeljstein.com/", "domain": "drmichaeljstein.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Michael Stein - Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O021", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/new-york", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Find a New York Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O021", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://zuckermanplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "zuckermanplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Zuckerman Plastic Surgery NYC | Best Mommy Makeover" }, { "observation": "O021", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/locations/laura-isaac-perlmutter-cosmetic-plastic-surgery-center", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "location", "title": "Laura and Isaac Perlmutter Cosmetic Plastic Surgery Center" }, { "observation": "O021", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/surgery/services/plastic-surgery/aesthetic/breast-enhancement/breast-augmentation", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Surgery NYC | Mount Sinai - New York" }, { "observation": "O021", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://psurgery.com/breast-augmentation-new-york-city", "domain": "psurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation in New York City - Dr. Scott Newman" }, { "observation": "O021", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://meeth.northwell.edu/plastic-surgery-center", "domain": "meeth.northwell.edu", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery Center - Manhattan Eye, Ear & Throat Hospital" }, { "observation": "O022", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://weillcornell.org/cosmetic-breast-surgery", "domain": "weillcornell.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Cosmetic Breast Surgery | Patient Care" }, { "observation": "O022", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lipsg.com/about", "domain": "lipsg.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top Plastic Surgery Practice in NYC and Long Island, New York" }, { "observation": "O022", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://parkavenueplasticsurgeon.com/", "domain": "parkavenueplasticsurgeon.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Plastic Surgeon NYC | Cosmetic Surgery New York City | Rapaport Plastic Surgery & Liposuction Manhattan" }, { "observation": "O022", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/surgery/services/plastic-surgery/aesthetic/breast-enhancement/breast-augmentation", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Surgery NYC | Mount Sinai - New York" }, { "observation": "O022", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/doctors/specialty/breast-plastic-surgeon", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Plastic Surgeons | NYU Langone Health" }, { "observation": "O022", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/care-services/plastic-surgery/breast-plastic-surgery-services", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Plastic Surgery Services | NYU Langone Health" }, { "observation": "O023", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nyplasticsurg.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/breast/augmentation", "domain": "nyplasticsurg.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation NYC | Dr. John E. Sherman" }, { "observation": "O023", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/locations/laura-isaac-perlmutter-cosmetic-plastic-surgery-center", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "location", "title": "Laura & Isaac Perlmutter Cosmetic Plastic Surgery Center | NYU Langone Health" }, { "observation": "O023", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://orenlerman.com/locations/new-york-office", "domain": "orenlerman.com", "type": "location", "title": "New York Plastic Surgeon Office | Oren Z. Lerman, MD" }, { "observation": "O023", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://plasticsurgeoninnyc.com/breast-implants", "domain": "plasticsurgeoninnyc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implants Plastic Surgeon NYC | Adam Schaffner, MD" }, { "observation": "O025", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/revision-rhinoplasty", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Revision Rhinoplasty in Chicago, IL – TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O025", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/rhinoplasty-chicago", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty & Nose Plastic Surgeon In Chicago, Illinois" }, { "observation": "O025", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://pscofchicago.com/revision-rhinoplasty-chicago", "domain": "pscofchicago.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Revision Rhinoplasty | Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O025", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://wiesmancosmeticsurgery.com/nose-jobs.html", "domain": "wiesmancosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Nose Jobs Chicago, IL | Rhinoplasty | Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O025", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://reddit.com/r/PlasticSurgery/comments/14i79qk/rhinoplasty_recommendation_in_chicago", "domain": "reddit.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Rhinoplasty recommendation in Chicago : r/PlasticSurgery" }, { "observation": "O026", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Facial Plastic Surgeon Chicago | Facial Plastic Surgery in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O026", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/facial-plastic-surgery-chicago/rhinoplasty", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Chicago | Nose Job Chicago | Dr. George T. Moynihan" }, { "observation": "O026", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/6035/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Rhinoplasty Revision Consultation" }, { "observation": "O026", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://link.aestheticrecord.com/widget/booking/HbG4IlULeNKzXTuFObq4", "domain": "link.aestheticrecord.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Rhinoplasty Consultation Booking" }, { "observation": "O028", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O028", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rhinoplasty and Facial Cosmetic Surgery by Jay M. Dutton | Chicago" }, { "observation": "O028", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Chicago | Nose Job | Michael Horn Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O028", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://nmaestheticmedicine.com/plastic-surgery-chicago-il/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "nmaestheticmedicine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty Chicago, IL | Northwestern Medicine Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O028", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://shahfacialplastics.com/about/reviews", "domain": "shahfacialplastics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Patient Review in Chicago | Dr. Shah Reviews - Dr. Anil Shah" }, { "observation": "O028", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drsidle.com/procedures/revisions-rhinoplasty-nose-job", "domain": "drsidle.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Revisions Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) Chicago - Douglas Sidle MD" }, { "observation": "O029", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://m.yelp.com/biz/plastic-surgery-clinic-of-chicago-chicago-2", "domain": "m.yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "PLASTIC SURGERY CLINIC OF CHICAGO - Updated ... - Yelp" }, { "observation": "O029", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://pscofchicago.com/", "domain": "pscofchicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago | Dr. Parit Patel" }, { "observation": "O029", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/6035/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) Consultation" }, { "observation": "O031", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O031", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nmaestheticmedicine.com/plastic-surgery-chicago-il/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "nmaestheticmedicine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty Chicago, IL | Northwestern Medicine Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O031", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rhinoplasty and Facial Cosmetic Surgery by Jay M. Dutton | Chicago" }, { "observation": "O031", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://warnerplasticsurgery.com/nose/rhinoplasty", "domain": "warnerplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Chicago | Nose Job in Chicago, IL - Warner Institute" }, { "observation": "O031", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drsidle.com/procedures/rhinoplasty-nose-job", "domain": "drsidle.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) in Chicago, IL - Dr. Sidle" }, { "observation": "O031", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) in Chicago, IL - TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O031", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://doctortoriumi.com/", "domain": "doctortoriumi.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dean Toriumi | Dr. Dean Toriumi, MD | Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O032", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drsidle.com/procedures/rhinoplasty-nose-job", "domain": "drsidle.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) in Chicago, IL - Dr. Sidle" }, { "observation": "O032", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://deantoriumi.com/", "domain": "deantoriumi.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Dean Toriumi | Chicago, IL | Dr. Dean Toriumi, MD" }, { "observation": "O032", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://theartofrhinoplasty.com/", "domain": "theartofrhinoplasty.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Dr. Gary Wiesman | Cosmetic Surgery 60654" }, { "observation": "O032", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/facial-plastic-surgery-chicago/rhinoplasty", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Chicago | Nose Job Chicago | Dr. George T. Moynihan" }, { "observation": "O032", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://wiesmancosmeticsurgery.com/nose-jobs.html", "domain": "wiesmancosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Nose Jobs Chicago, IL | Rhinoplasty | Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O032", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "World-Class Plastic Surgery in Chicago – TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O032", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://nm.org/locations/plastic-and-reconstructive-surgery-practice", "domain": "nm.org", "type": "location", "title": "Northwestern Medicine Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Practice | Chicago, IL | Northwestern Medicine" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://hudsonfacialplastics.com/pricing", "domain": "hudsonfacialplastics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Facial Plastic Surgery Pricing Chicago" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "World-Class Plastic Surgery in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/facelift", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Surgery in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://impressionsfaceandbody.com/", "domain": "impressionsfaceandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Impressions Face + Body" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facial-Plastic-Surgeon", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facial Plastic Surgeons in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://thatfacechicago.com/", "domain": "thatfacechicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "That Face Chicago" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://illinoisderm.com/providers/omotara-sulyman-scott-md", "domain": "illinoisderm.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Omotara Sulyman‑Scott, MD" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://google.com/maps/place?q=place_id%3AChIJ99cEa1jTD4gRws51m1Eyf60&hl=en", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "That Face Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://drsidle.com/", "domain": "drsidle.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Douglas Sidle MD | Facial Plastic, Reconstructive Surgeon Chicago" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://johnkimmd.com/", "domain": "johnkimmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. John Kim's practice" }, { "observation": "O033", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 12, "url": "https://healthgrades.com/find-a-doctor/illinois/best-doctors-who-perform-facelift-in-chicago", "domain": "healthgrades.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Best Facelift Doctors in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O034", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O034", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Facial Plastic Surgeon Chicago | Facial Plastic Surgery in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O034", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "TLKM Plastic Surgery: World-Class Plastic Surgery in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O034", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://chicagocosmeticsurgery.com/", "domain": "chicagocosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Cosmetic Surgery & Plastic Surgeon Chicago - Dr Michael BYUN" }, { "observation": "O034", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/mustoe-facelift", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Renowned Deep Plane Facelift Surgeon in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O034", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://mygeldnercenter.com/plastic-surgery/facelift", "domain": "mygeldnercenter.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift & Mini Facelift Surgery | Chicago & Oak Brook" }, { "observation": "O036", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdSZmVqZzROSEk0GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Sammy Sinno, MD" }, { "observation": "O036", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdoaWVEZG1NdxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "John Kim, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O036", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdNMU5HUm9jRFpuGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Bloom Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O036", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdJMWQyTnplWG8wGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Paul Phelps" }, { "observation": "O037", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/mustoe-facelift", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Renowned Deep Plane Facelift Surgeon in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O037", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O037", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://hudsonfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "hudsonfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Hudson Facial Plastic Surgery - Deep Plane Facelift Chicago" }, { "observation": "O037", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://fewinstitute.com/", "domain": "fewinstitute.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery Chicago | Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Dr. Julius Few" }, { "observation": "O037", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://chicagocosmeticsurgery.com/", "domain": "chicagocosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Cosmetic Surgery & Plastic Surgeon Chicago - Dr Michael BYUN" }, { "observation": "O037", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/deep-plane-facelift", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Deep Plane Facelift Expert in Chicago, IL, Dr. Thomas Mustoe" }, { "observation": "O037", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://northwesternplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "northwesternplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgeons Chicago - Northwestern Plastic Surgery Center" }, { "observation": "O037", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://thatfacechicago.com/", "domain": "thatfacechicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Facial Plastic Surgery Chicago | Best Facial Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O038", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://celebrityplasticsurgeons.com/chicago.html", "domain": "celebrityplasticsurgeons.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Celebrity Plastic Surgeon in Chicago | Dr. George Moynihan" }, { "observation": "O038", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drkimsurgery.com/procedures/face-surgery/mini-facelift", "domain": "drkimsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Mini Facelift Chicago IL - Partial Rhytidectomy Chicago IL" }, { "observation": "O038", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://nm.org/conditions-and-care-areas/plastic-surgery", "domain": "nm.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery | Northwestern Medicine" }, { "observation": "O038", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/facial-plastic-surgery-chicago/deep-plane-facelift", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Deep Plane Facelift in Chicago | Gold Coast Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O038", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://northwesternplasticsurgery.com/facial-procedures-chicago/facelift", "domain": "northwesternplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Chicago - Rhytidectomy Chicago" }, { "observation": "O038", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/mustoe-facelift", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Renowned Deep Plane Facelift Surgeon in Chicago, IL – Dr. Thomes Mustoe – TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O038", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://instagram.com/reel/De7aW0llI6B", "domain": "instagram.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Most of my patients walk out within an hour of their facelift. How ..." }, { "observation": "O038", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://thatfacechicago.com/face/face-facelift", "domain": "thatfacechicago.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift in Chicago | That Face Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O039", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVhBd01XSTRiSE55GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "That Face Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O039", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdoaWVEZG1NdxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "John Kim, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O039", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdjemVuY3djbXBrGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O039", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdNMU5HUm9jRFpuGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Bloom Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O039", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdkd01XUXdPQRgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Northwestern Specialists in Plastic Surgery, S.C." }, { "observation": "O041", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://chicagoplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "chicagoplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Plastic Surgery Clinic in Northbrook, IL" }, { "observation": "O041", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://shifrinplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "shifrinplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgeon | David Shifrin MD" }, { "observation": "O041", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O041", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://fulcrumaesthetics.com/breast/breast-augmentation", "domain": "fulcrumaesthetics.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation in Chicago, IL | Breast Implants Chicago | Fulcrum Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O041", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://reddit.com/r/CHIbitcheswithtaste/comments/1p6jxl6/breast_augmentation_doctor_recommendations", "domain": "reddit.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast augmentation doctor recommendations? - Reddit" }, { "observation": "O041", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/breast-surgery-chicago", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Surgery | Chicago, Winnetka | Dr. John Q. Cook" }, { "observation": "O041", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://bodysculptor.com/breast-augmentation-cost-chicago-il", "domain": "bodysculptor.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Surgery Cost - Chicago - Dr. Otto Placik" }, { "observation": "O042", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdoaWVEZG1NdxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "John Kim, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O042", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdjemVuY3djbXBrGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O043", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O043", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Implants", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Implants Doctors in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O043", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Society of Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O043", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O043", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://fda.gov/medical-devices/breast-implants", "domain": "fda.gov", "type": "treatment", "title": "FDA breast implant safety information" }, { "observation": "O044", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O044", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Voted #1 Plastic Surgery Chicago | Breast & Body Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O044", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Plastic Surgery Chicago | Dr. Horn" }, { "observation": "O044", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drkimsurgery.com/procedures/breast-surgery/breast-augmentation", "domain": "drkimsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Enhancement Chicago, IL - Breast Augmentation by Dr. Kim" }, { "observation": "O044", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Implants", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Implants Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O045", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Voted #1 Plastic Surgery Chicago | Breast & Body Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O045", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/6035/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Revision Consultation" }, { "observation": "O047", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Voted #1 Plastic Surgery Chicago | Breast & Body Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O047", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://bodysculptor.com/", "domain": "bodysculptor.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgeon: Top Plastic Surgery Center in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O047", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://aestheticinstitutechicago.com/", "domain": "aestheticinstitutechicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Aesthetic Institute of Chicago: Plastic Surgery in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O047", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/breast-surgery-chicago/breast-augmentation", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation | Dr. John Q. Cook | Chicago" }, { "observation": "O047", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Plastic Surgery Chicago | Dr. Horn" }, { "observation": "O047", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/chicago", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Find a Chicago Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O049", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O049", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/?city=Miami&state=FL", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "Find a Miami Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O049", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/brandon-kallman-md-miami?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Miami | Lip fillers and Botox | Brandon E. Kallman, MD" }, { "observation": "O049", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/maps/place?q=place_id%3AChIJh_T_HYO32YgRUFHN_DpKD2c&hl=en", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Shekhar Gadkaree, MD" }, { "observation": "O049", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O049", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Society of Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O050", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamivibesmag.com/post/the-top-rated-rhinoplasty-surgeons-in-miami", "domain": "miamivibesmag.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The Top-Rated Rhinoplasty Surgeons in Miami" }, { "observation": "O050", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O050", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami FL - Voted Best Nose Surgeon - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O050", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drbustillo.com/andres-bustillo-md", "domain": "drbustillo.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Andres Bustillo | Best Facial Plastic Surgeon Miami" }, { "observation": "O050", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drjsalomon.com/", "domain": "drjsalomon.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr Jhonny Salomon - Miami Plastic Surgery & Med Spa" }, { "observation": "O050", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://springplasticsurgery.com/face-procedures/rhinoplasty-cost-in-miami", "domain": "springplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "▷Rhinoplasty Cost in Miami: Prices, Factors & Expert Insights" }, { "observation": "O050", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/South-Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in South Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O051", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/nose-surgery", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Nose Surgery Miami (Rhinoplasty) Expert Nose Surgery & Reshaping" }, { "observation": "O051", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/procedure/rhinoplasty", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Surgery - Nose Surgery | Miami, FL | Dr. Leonard Hochstein" }, { "observation": "O051", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://smartplasticsurgerymiami.com/rhinoplasty-in-miami", "domain": "smartplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Miami: Types, Recovery, and Choosing the ..." }, { "observation": "O051", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O051", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://miamivibesmag.com/post/the-top-rated-rhinoplasty-surgeons-in-miami", "domain": "miamivibesmag.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The Top-Rated Rhinoplasty Surgeons in Miami" }, { "observation": "O051", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery Miami FL - Voted Best Plastic Surgeon Miami" }, { "observation": "O051", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://facebook.com/DrRicardoCastrellon/posts/deciding-on-a-rhinoplasty-is-deeply-personal-if-you-find-yourself-constantly-che/1903560047488030", "domain": "facebook.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "How to know if rhinoplasty is right for you in Miami - Facebook" }, { "observation": "O052", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdaeWFHdDBlURgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O052", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEcxeGJXeGthZxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Jhonny A Salomon Plastic Surgery & Med Spa" }, { "observation": "O052", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://tebra.com/care/practice/digeronimo-md-advanced-plastic-surgery-204332?lid=849190020", "domain": "tebra.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O053", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/locations", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "location", "title": "Conveniently Located Cosmetic Service Centers in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O053", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://umiamihealth.org/en/treatments-and-services/plastic-surgery/facial-cosmetic-procedures", "domain": "umiamihealth.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facial Cosmetic Procedures | University of Miami Health System" }, { "observation": "O053", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O053", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drwolfrhinoplasty.com/", "domain": "drwolfrhinoplasty.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Carlos Wolf, MD - Rhinoplasty Miami / Nose Surgery" }, { "observation": "O053", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://miamivibesmag.com/post/the-top-rated-rhinoplasty-surgeons-in-miami", "domain": "miamivibesmag.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The Top-Rated Rhinoplasty Surgeons in Miami" }, { "observation": "O053", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://medcitynews.com/2025/07/where-to-find-top-rated-rhinoplasty-surgeons-in-miami-and-beyond", "domain": "medcitynews.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Where to Find Top-Rated Rhinoplasty Surgeons in Miami and Beyond" }, { "observation": "O053", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami FL - Voted Best Nose Surgeon - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O053", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://drkmiamiplasticsurgery.com/list-plastic-surgeons-in-miami", "domain": "drkmiamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "List of Top 10 Plastic Surgeons in Miami" }, { "observation": "O053", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://umiamihealth.org/en/treatments-and-services/ear,-nose,-and-throat-(ent)/facial-plastic-and-reconstructive-surgery", "domain": "umiamihealth.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery | University of Miami" }, { "observation": "O054", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/nose-surgery", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami | Nose Surgery From $4,900 | Spectrum Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O054", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Spectrum Aesthetics: Premier Plastic Surgery in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O054", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/dr-drew-kreegel", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Dr. Drew Kreegel - Plastic Surgeon Miami, Florida" }, { "observation": "O054", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://arcplasticsurgeons.com/", "domain": "arcplasticsurgeons.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Plastic Surgeon Miami | ARC Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O054", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://arcplasticsurgeons.com/about-us/press", "domain": "arcplasticsurgeons.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Press | Dr. Jeremy White | ARC Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O054", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty in Miami - Dr. Carlos Wolf" }, { "observation": "O055", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiaesthetic.com/", "domain": "miamiaesthetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Board Certified Plastic Surgeon in Miami, FL | Dr. Pat Pazmino" }, { "observation": "O055", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty in Miami - Dr. Carlos Wolf" }, { "observation": "O055", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEhnNGRGOTVhZxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Miami Center for Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/our-office/meet-dr-ary-krau", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Surgeon credentials, rhinoplasty and operating facility" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drjsalomon.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drjsalomon.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty procedure and surgical facility FAQ" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://careagaplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "careagaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Surgeons and rhinoplasty services" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://careagaplasticsurgery.com/our-practice", "domain": "careagaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Surgical center and accreditation" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://theaestheticsociety.org/select-surgeon/tal-t-roudner-md", "domain": "theaestheticsociety.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "The Aesthetic Society surgeon profile" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://talroudnerplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "talroudnerplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drwolfrhinoplasty.com/", "domain": "drwolfrhinoplasty.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Wolf's rhinoplasty website" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://andresbustillo.com/", "domain": "andresbustillo.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice information" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://drbared.com/", "domain": "drbared.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O056", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://southfloridafacialplastics.com/", "domain": "southfloridafacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice information" }, { "observation": "O057", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nidiadejesusmd.com/facelift-miami-cost-types", "domain": "nidiadejesusmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift in Miami: Types, Cost, and Recovery in 2026" }, { "observation": "O057", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/facelift-miami", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami - From $3800 (Neck Lift) - Icon Cosmetic Center" }, { "observation": "O057", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://smartplasticsurgerymiami.com/best-plastic-surgeon-for-a-facelift-in-miami", "domain": "smartplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "How to choose the best plastic surgeon for a face lift in Miami" }, { "observation": "O057", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://aestheticmatch.com/blog/general/best-mommy-makeover-surgeons-in-miami-who-to-trust-in-2", "domain": "aestheticmatch.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Best Mommy Makeover Surgeons in Miami: Who to Trust in 2025" }, { "observation": "O057", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://m.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Plastic+Surgeon+Face&find_loc=Miami%2C+FL", "domain": "m.yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "TOP 10 BEST Plastic Surgeon Face in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O057", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drcastrellon.com/top-facial-plastic-surgery-procedures-miami", "domain": "drcastrellon.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top 5 Most Popular Facial Plastic Surgery Procedures" }, { "observation": "O057", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://facebook.com/fb-answers/miami-plastic-surgery-clinics-comparison?locale=pt_PT", "domain": "facebook.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Clinics Comparison - Facebook" }, { "observation": "O057", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://facebook.com/fb-answers/miami-plastic-surgery-clinics-comparison?locale=sv_SE", "domain": "facebook.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Clinics Comparison" }, { "observation": "O058", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drbustillo.com/", "domain": "drbustillo.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Bustillo | Miami’s Leader in Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O058", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEcxeGJXeGthZxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Jhonny A Salomon Plastic Surgery & Med Spa" }, { "observation": "O058", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-stephan-baker-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Facelift" }, { "observation": "O059", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/documents/holidays/2024/Surgeon-Checklist.pdf", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "ASPS Surgeon Credentials Checklist" }, { "observation": "O059", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/?city=Miami&state=FL", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "Find a Miami Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O059", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/documents/holidays/2024/Do-It-For-You.pdf", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "ASPS Do It For You E-Book" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://thecliniccompass.com/miami/best-plastic-surgeons", "domain": "thecliniccompass.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "35 Best Plastic Surgeons in Miami, FL (2026) | ClinicCompass" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drnathan.com/", "domain": "drnathan.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Nirmal Nathan" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://aeris.co/", "domain": "aeris.co", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Plastic Surgeons Miami | Aeris" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drjsalomon.com/", "domain": "drjsalomon.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr Jhonny Salomon - Miami Plastic Surgery & Med Spa" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://umiamihealth.org/en/treatments-and-services/plastic-surgery", "domain": "umiamihealth.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Plastic Surgery | University of Miami Health System" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://themaercksinstitute.com/post/best-facelift-surgeon-miami", "domain": "themaercksinstitute.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift Surgeon in Miami | Dr. Rian Maercks" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://gallomd.com/", "domain": "gallomd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Julio Gallo: Facial Plastic Surgeon Miami" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://drbustillo.com/", "domain": "drbustillo.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Bustillo | Miami's Leader in Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://miamilifecosmetic.com/surgeon/dr-nassif-soueid-m-d", "domain": "miamilifecosmetic.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Dr. Nassif Soueid, M.D – Miami Life Cosmetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O060", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O061", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O061", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/face/facelift", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Surgery in Miami With Trusted, Board-Certified Experts" }, { "observation": "O061", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drbustillo.com/cosmetic-procedures/facelift", "domain": "drbustillo.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami | Dr. Bustillo: Expert Facelift Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O063", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://gvplasticsurgery.com/facelift-guide-from-best-facelift-plastic-surgeon", "domain": "gvplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The best facelift plastic surgeon in Miami's - Doctor George Varkarakis" }, { "observation": "O063", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O063", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drnathan.com/", "domain": "drnathan.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Nirmal Nathan" }, { "observation": "O063", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://castleconnolly.com/specialty/plastic-surgery/miami-fl", "domain": "castleconnolly.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top Plastic Surgeons near Miami, FL - Castle Connolly" }, { "observation": "O063", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/miami-facelift-surgeon", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami FL - Voted Best Facelift Surgeon - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O063", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://zuriplasticsurgery.com/face/facelift", "domain": "zuriplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift Miami | Zuri Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O063", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://themaercksinstitute.com/post/best-facelift-surgeon-miami", "domain": "themaercksinstitute.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift Surgeon in Miami | Dr. Rian Maercks" }, { "observation": "O065", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/?city=Miami&state=FL", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "Find a Miami Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O065", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/rian-maercks-37574.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Rian A. Maercks, MD" }, { "observation": "O066", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://avanaplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "avanaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Avana Plastic Surgery | Best Cosmetic Surgery in Miami" }, { "observation": "O066", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O066", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O066", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://sveltaplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "sveltaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Svelta Plastic Surgery: Leading Plastic Surgery Miami" }, { "observation": "O066", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O066", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/breast-surgery/breast-lift-miami", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Voted Best Breast Lift Surgeon Miami - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O066", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Board-Eligible-Plastic-Surgeon", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Board Eligible Plastic Surgeons in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O066", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://talroudnerplasticsurgery.com/plastic-surgeon/patient-reviews", "domain": "talroudnerplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Patient Reviews of Miami Plastic Surgeon Dr. Tal T Roudner" }, { "observation": "O067", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/pricing-and-fees-overview", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Leonard Hochstein : Pricing and Fees Overview - Miami Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O067", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://miaaesthetics.com/cosmetic-plastic-surgery/breast/augmentation-implants", "domain": "miaaesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Augmentation & Breast Implants | Mia Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O067", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://smartplasticsurgerymiami.com/breast-augmentation-cost-in-miami", "domain": "smartplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Cost in Miami: 2026 Pricing Guide and ..." }, { "observation": "O067", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://aeplasticsurgerymiami.com/plastic-surgery-guide/plastic-surgery-cost-in-miami", "domain": "aeplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic surgery cost in Miami: Complete guide to prices" }, { "observation": "O067", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://booking.pabau.com/briaplasticsurgeryllc/online-bookings?location=24076&withGoogle=true&source=google&groupCategory=16155&category=195964&services=3589218", "domain": "booking.pabau.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "S01 Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O068", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O068", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O068", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdZM05qbHpjQRgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Bal Harbour Plastic Surgery Associates" }, { "observation": "O068", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVhOelh6UXljWEpqGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Miami" }, { "observation": "O069", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/locations", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "location", "title": "Conveniently Located Cosmetic Service Centers in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O069", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O069", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://umiamihealth.org/en/treatments-and-services/plastic-surgery", "domain": "umiamihealth.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Plastic Surgery | University of Miami Health System" }, { "observation": "O069", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O069", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Icon Cosmetic Center: Best Cosmetic Surgery Center Miami" }, { "observation": "O069", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Spectrum Aesthetics: Premier Plastic Surgery in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O069", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://avanaplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "avanaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Avana Plastic Surgery | Best Cosmetic Surgery in Miami" }, { "observation": "O070", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "http://archsurg.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?doi=10.1001/jamasurg.2018.3757", "domain": "archsurg.jamanetwork.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "The Third Postmastectomy Reconstruction Option—Autologous Fat Transfer" }, { "observation": "O070", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://booking.pabau.com/briaplasticsurgeryllc/online-bookings?location=24076&withGoogle=true&source=google&groupCategory=16155&category=195964&services=3589218", "domain": "booking.pabau.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "S01 Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O070", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-michael-stefan-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O070", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/baruch-jacobs-md-51502?LocIdent=35461&entity_id=pr_8-hHadu8_k-IFXY5lEiqdx-lo_DY8jD5yvvUOFRKCQ404F8R-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O071", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/breast-chest/breast-augmentation", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Miami Breast Implants | Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O071", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://booking.pabau.com/briaplasticsurgeryllc/online-bookings?location=24076&withGoogle=true&source=google&groupCategory=16155&category=195964&services=3589218", "domain": "booking.pabau.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "S01 Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O071", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-richard-j-lung-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://careagaplasticsurgery.com/breast/breast-augmentation", "domain": "careagaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation procedure and surgeon" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://careagaplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "careagaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Surgical facility and accreditation" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "Surgeon's credentials and qualifications" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://careagaplasticsurgery.com/our-practice", "domain": "careagaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Our Plastic Surgery Practice | Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://aeris.co/", "domain": "aeris.co", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official Aeris website and surgeon profile" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://gablesplasticsurgery.com/breast/breast-augmentation", "domain": "gablesplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation and surgical process" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://gablesplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "gablesplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://zuriplasticsurgery.com/breast/breast-augmentation", "domain": "zuriplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation procedure" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://zuriplasticsurgery.com/about/meet-dr-z", "domain": "zuriplasticsurgery.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Surgeon's qualifications and experience" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://zuriplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "zuriplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Operating facility" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://zuriplasticsurgery.com/breast/preservation-breast-augmentation", "domain": "zuriplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Preservation Breast Augmentation in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 12, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/breast-augmentation-miami", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation and named surgeons" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 13, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/miami-plastic-surgeon", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Surgeon profiles" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 14, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Operating facility" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 15, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/miami-plastic-surgeon/robert-hunsaker", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Robert Hunsaker Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 16, "url": "https://alameddinemd.com/breast-surgery", "domain": "alameddinemd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast surgery and facility information" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 17, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/tal-roudner-md-facs.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "American Society of Plastic Surgeons physician profile" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 18, "url": "https://talroudnerplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "talroudnerplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice information" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 19, "url": "https://miamilifecosmetic.com/procedure/breast-augmentation", "domain": "miamilifecosmetic.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 20, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official website" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 21, "url": "https://thenathanclinic.com/", "domain": "thenathanclinic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official clinic website" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 22, "url": "https://sunsetplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "sunsetplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official website" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 23, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O072", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "sourceOrder": 24, "url": "https://mqa-internet.doh.state.fl.us/MQASearchServices/HealthCareProviders", "domain": "mqa-internet.doh.state.fl.us", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Florida Department of Health license lookup" }, { "observation": "O073", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in New York, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O073", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/procedures/procedures-for-women/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Celebrity Rhinoplasty Surgeon In New York City" }, { "observation": "O073", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drbenpaul.com/face-new-york-city/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drbenpaul.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty In New York City (NYC) | Dr. Benjamin Paul" }, { "observation": "O073", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drkassir.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drkassir.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty New York City | Dr. Ramtin Kassir" }, { "observation": "O073", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://mdface.com/top-nose-surgeons-in-new-york-city", "domain": "mdface.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top Nose Surgeons in New York City | Pearlman Aesthetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O073", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York-City/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in New York City, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O074", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Dr. Jennifer Levine" }, { "observation": "O074", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://mdface.com/top-nose-surgeons-in-nyc", "domain": "mdface.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "One of NYC's Top Nose Surgeons Answers Your Questions" }, { "observation": "O074", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://plasticsurgeoninnyc.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "plasticsurgeoninnyc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Palstic Surgeon NYC | Adam Schaffner, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O074", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://mdface.com/treatments/non-surgical-nose-job-nyc", "domain": "mdface.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The Best Non-Surgical Nose Job in NYC - Pearlman Aesthetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O074", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/procedures/nose-surgery/rhinoplasty-nose-job", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Nose Surgery New York City" }, { "observation": "O075", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O075", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-norman-j-pastorek-md-facs", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O075", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/matthew-shawl-md-mph-515?LocIdent=6840&entity_id=pr_O1AmX-LJBUGID1uS3BjzlB-lo_HPEMpWJU1EOcAZlo4EdJ4R-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Sinus Problems / Sinusitis" }, { "observation": "O075", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/michelle-zweifler-md-340754?LocIdent=159483&entity_id=pr_V0e180ae0UOBKm1chRjRuh-lo_0jYQsacnxka8gw90_rm36B-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Plastic Surgery Consultation" }, { "observation": "O076", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York-City/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in New York City, NY" }, { "observation": "O076", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/new-york", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Find a New York Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O076", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://samanmd.com/the-surgeons/masoud-saman", "domain": "samanmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Masoud Saman, MD, Facial Plastic Surgeon NYC" }, { "observation": "O076", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://healthgrades.com/physician/dr-a-joshua-zimm-ywf9n", "domain": "healthgrades.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Dr. A Joshua Zimm, MD - Plastic Surgeon in New York, NY" }, { "observation": "O076", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://aafprs.org/profile?id=17206", "domain": "aafprs.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Profile" }, { "observation": "O076", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/dr/steven-pearlman-new-york-ny", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Steven J. Pearlman, MD, FACS, Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon | Real Patient Reviews, Before & After Photos, Expert Answers" }, { "observation": "O076", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O076", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://abfprs.org/", "domain": "abfprs.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery" }, { "observation": "O076", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "ASPS surgeon directory" }, { "observation": "O077", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "http://archotol.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?doi=10.1001/jamaoto.2013.4163", "domain": "archotol.jamanetwork.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "A Patient With Nasal Valve Compromise" }, { "observation": "O077", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Celebrity Facial Plastic Surgeon In New York City | David Rosenberg, MD" }, { "observation": "O077", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://longevity.haus/best/rhinoplasty/new-york-city", "domain": "longevity.haus", "type": "treatment", "title": "10 Best Rhinoplasty Clinics in New York City (2026)" }, { "observation": "O077", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://mdface.com/top-nose-surgeons-in-new-york-city", "domain": "mdface.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top Nose Surgeons in New York City" }, { "observation": "O077", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4TWpZMGNETnNhMjAYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Edward S. Kwak MD - ESKMD Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O077", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://parkavenueplasticsurgeon.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "parkavenueplasticsurgeon.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Best Nose Job Surgeon in New York" }, { "observation": "O077", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drkolker.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty NYC | Nose Job New York City | Dr. Kolker" }, { "observation": "O078", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://lipsg.com/face/rhinoplasty-new-york-nyc", "domain": "lipsg.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC New York Long Island | Nose Job" }, { "observation": "O078", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://normanpastorekmd.com/", "domain": "normanpastorekmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Norman J. Pastorek, MD, PC, FACS" }, { "observation": "O078", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4844/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O078", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-norman-j-pastorek-md-facs", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Revision Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O080", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Jennifer Levine: Top Plastic Surgeon NYC" }, { "observation": "O080", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/ent/services/facial-plastic-reconstructive-surgery/cosmetic/nose-surgery-rhinoplasty", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) NYC | Mount Sinai - New York" }, { "observation": "O080", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://meeth.northwell.edu/plastic-surgery-center", "domain": "meeth.northwell.edu", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery Center - Manhattan Eye, Ear & Throat Hospital" }, { "observation": "O080", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://doctorlao.com/face-new-york/rhinoplasty", "domain": "doctorlao.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty In New York City (NYC) | New York Nose Specialist" }, { "observation": "O080", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drkassir.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drkassir.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty New York City | Dr. Ramtin Kassir" }, { "observation": "O080", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://cityfacialplastics.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "cityfacialplastics.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Best Nose Job Surgeon New York City - Dr. Linkov" }, { "observation": "O080", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://naturallookinstitute.com/best-nose-job-doctor-nyc", "domain": "naturallookinstitute.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Nose Job Doctor In NYC | Dr. Yoel Shahar - Natural Look Institute" }, { "observation": "O080", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/procedures/procedures-for-women/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Celebrity Rhinoplasty Surgeon In New York City" }, { "observation": "O080", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://doctormbt.com/", "domain": "doctormbt.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Michael Bassiri-Tehrani: Facial Plastic Surgeon NYC" }, { "observation": "O081", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "New York Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O081", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEhCdU0yZDRNQRgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Maurice M. Khosh, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O081", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVhGblptWnNibDh6GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Mansher Singh, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O083", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in New York, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O083", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://castleconnolly.com/expertise/facelift/new-york-ny", "domain": "castleconnolly.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Find doctors that specialize in Facelift near New York, NY" }, { "observation": "O083", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drkassir.com/face/facelift", "domain": "drkassir.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift New York City | Triple Board-Certified Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O083", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "New York Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O083", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://aestheticmatch.com/blog/new-york/best-facelift-surgeons-in-new-york-city-guide", "domain": "aestheticmatch.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Best Facelift Surgeons in New York City (2025 Guide) - AestheticMatch" }, { "observation": "O083", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://plasticsurgeonnyc.com/best-facelift-surgeon-in-midtown-nyc", "domain": "plasticsurgeonnyc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift Surgeon in NYC Dr. Richard Swift, MD" }, { "observation": "O083", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/procedures/procedures-for-women/facelift", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Top Celebrity Facelift Surgeon In New York City | Deep Plane" }, { "observation": "O086", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/procedures/procedures-for-women/facelift", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Top Celebrity Facelift Surgeon In New York City | Deep Plane" }, { "observation": "O086", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Jennifer Levine: Top Plastic Surgeon NYC" }, { "observation": "O086", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://castleconnolly.com/expertise/facelift/new-york-ny", "domain": "castleconnolly.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Find doctors that specialize in Facelift near New York, NY" }, { "observation": "O086", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "New York Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O086", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drkassir.com/face/facelift", "domain": "drkassir.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift New York City | Triple Board-Certified Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O086", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://aestheticmatch.com/blog/new-york/best-facelift-surgeons-in-new-york-city-guide", "domain": "aestheticmatch.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Best Facelift Surgeons in New York City (2025 Guide) - AestheticMatch" }, { "observation": "O086", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York-City/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in New York City, NY" }, { "observation": "O088", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://plasticsurgeonsnyc.com/", "domain": "plasticsurgeonsnyc.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery NYC New York City | Top Plastic Surgeon Manhattan NY" }, { "observation": "O088", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-norman-j-pastorek-md-facs", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Facelift" }, { "observation": "O088", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://tebra.com/care/provider/elliott-rose-md-1609986892?lid=510096032", "domain": "tebra.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Cosmetic Facial Surgery" }, { "observation": "O089", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drkolker.com/", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation NYC | Top Plastic Surgeon New York City" }, { "observation": "O089", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/care-services/plastic-surgery/breast-plastic-surgery-services", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Plastic Surgery Services | NYU Langone Health" }, { "observation": "O089", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://doctorlao.com/", "domain": "doctorlao.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery NYC | Double Board Plastic Surgeon | Willam Lao, MD" }, { "observation": "O089", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://orenlerman.com/locations/new-york-office", "domain": "orenlerman.com", "type": "location", "title": "New York Plastic Surgeon Office | Oren Z. Lerman, MD" }, { "observation": "O089", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drmichaeljstein.com/", "domain": "drmichaeljstein.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Michael Stein - Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O089", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in New York, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O089", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://aestheticmatch.com/blog/new-york/best-breast-augmentation-surgeons-in-new-york-city-guide", "domain": "aestheticmatch.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation Surgeons in New York City (2025 Guide)" }, { "observation": "O089", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://psurgery.com/breast-augmentation-new-york-city", "domain": "psurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation in New York City - Dr. Scott Newman" }, { "observation": "O090", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVhNME56UTNNWEF3GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Umbareen Mahmood, MD" }, { "observation": "O090", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdNeGNUazViSGN3GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Neinstein Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O090", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4TW5aeWJuWnlhR1EYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Aristocrat Plastic Surgery: Dr. Kevin Tehrani - NYC" }, { "observation": "O090", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4Y0hwM2VuRnVaelkYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Zuckerman Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O090", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVhOMllqaHlhalprGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Mia Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O091", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/surgery/services/plastic-surgery/aesthetic/breast-enhancement/breast-augmentation", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Surgery NYC | Mount Sinai - New York" }, { "observation": "O091", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/sachin-shridharani-md-132617?LocIdent=328332&entity_id=pr_QTEo1UCNQES6oXMczG1PfR-lo_WW3O2JJQ90iBLgC8bmYARB-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O091", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/george-lefkovits-md-129511?LocIdent=69689&entity_id=pr_bzEhhQArbkqOqpyG6OTzsh-lo_4XGyirazuUSaN1qSqT1BJB-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O091", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/elie-levine-md-251846?LocIdent=49395&entity_id=pr_y5NIcejLukShh7O4ydrdhR-lo_4J6pST2H4U-Ql_cO4SrZDx-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O092", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://darrensmithmd.com/about/manhattan-plastic-surgeon-dr-darren-smith", "domain": "darrensmithmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Manhattan Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O092", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/new-york", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "New York surgeon directory" }, { "observation": "O092", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/en-us", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Find a Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O093", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://plasticsurgeoninnyc.com/", "domain": "plasticsurgeoninnyc.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgeon NYC | Adam Schaffner, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O093", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/locations/laura-isaac-perlmutter-cosmetic-plastic-surgery-center", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "location", "title": "Laura & Isaac Perlmutter Cosmetic Plastic Surgery Center | NYU Langone Health" }, { "observation": "O093", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://plasticsurgeoninnyc.com/breast-implants", "domain": "plasticsurgeoninnyc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implants Plastic Surgeon NYC | Adam Schaffner, MD" }, { "observation": "O093", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://bodysculptingcenternyc.com/best-breast-implants-plastic-surgeon-manhattan-nyc-breast-augmentation", "domain": "bodysculptingcenternyc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implants / Breast Augmentation Plastic Surgeon NYC" }, { "observation": "O093", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/sachin-shridharani-md-132617?LocIdent=328332&entity_id=pr_QTEo1UCNQES6oXMczG1PfR-lo_WW3O2JJQ90iBLgC8bmYARB-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O093", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/care-services/plastic-surgery/breast-plastic-surgery-services", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Plastic Surgery Services | NYU Langone Health" }, { "observation": "O093", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://psurgery.com/breast-augmentation-new-york-city", "domain": "psurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation in New York City" }, { "observation": "O094", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/george-lefkovits-md-129511?LocIdent=69689&entity_id=pr_bzEhhQArbkqOqpyG6OTzsh-lo_4XGyirazuUSaN1qSqT1BJB-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O094", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/adam-schaffner-facs-md-16219?LocIdent=181134&entity_id=pr_9gK8I5mXWkKVkRO0o_kqwB-lo_C16pYpHusEC1V8S4KAkw4h-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O094", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/elie-levine-md-251846?LocIdent=49395&entity_id=pr_y5NIcejLukShh7O4ydrdhR-lo_4J6pST2H4U-Ql_cO4SrZDx-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O094", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/tracey-cook-md-624654?LocIdent=139204&entity_id=pr_gLJ7e1dAJUWsyeR1zeHr1g-lo_OQi-56gyb0qZ4rAi9mz1UR-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O095", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://darrensmithmd.com/breast/breast-augmentation-in-nyc", "domain": "darrensmithmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation procedure and operating facility" }, { "observation": "O095", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drkolker.com/breast/breast-augmentation", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation and surgical facility" }, { "observation": "O095", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://breastsurgerynyc.com/locations", "domain": "breastsurgerynyc.com", "type": "location", "title": "Locations, surgeons and operating facility" }, { "observation": "O095", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drmaman.com/breast-augmentation", "domain": "drmaman.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation and surgical facility information" }, { "observation": "O095", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/locations/laura-isaac-perlmutter-cosmetic-plastic-surgery-center", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "location", "title": "Center, surgeons, procedures and operating rooms" }, { "observation": "O095", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://nychealthandhospitals.org/metropolitan/services/surgery", "domain": "nychealthandhospitals.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Metropolitan Cosmetic Surgery Center – services and surgeons" }, { "observation": "O095", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://murrayhillplasticsurgery.com/breast/breast-augmentation", "domain": "murrayhillplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Murray Hill Plastic Surgery – breast augmentation and operating room" }, { "observation": "O095", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/dr-nadia-afridi.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Dr. Nadia Afridi – ASPS surgeon profile and facility details" }, { "observation": "O095", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/patient-safety?sub=Accredited+facilities", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "ASPS – Accredited Facilities" }, { "observation": "O096", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/surgery/services/plastic-surgery", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery NYC | Mount Sinai - New York" }, { "observation": "O096", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://orenlerman.com/locations/new-york-office", "domain": "orenlerman.com", "type": "location", "title": "New York Plastic Surgeon Office | Oren Z. Lerman, MD" }, { "observation": "O096", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://meeth.northwell.edu/plastic-surgery-center", "domain": "meeth.northwell.edu", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery Center - Manhattan Eye, Ear & Throat Hospital" }, { "observation": "O096", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://psurgery.com/breast-augmentation-new-york-city", "domain": "psurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation in New York City - Dr. Scott Newman" }, { "observation": "O096", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://aestheticmatch.com/blog/new-york/best-breast-augmentation-surgeons-in-new-york-city-guide", "domain": "aestheticmatch.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation Surgeons in New York City (2025 Guide)" }, { "observation": "O096", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://plasticsurgeoninnyc.com/breast-implants", "domain": "plasticsurgeoninnyc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implants Plastic Surgeon NYC | Adam Schaffner, MD" }, { "observation": "O096", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/new-york", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Find a New York Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O096", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/doctors/specialty/breast-plastic-surgeon", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Plastic Surgeons | NYU Langone Health" }, { "observation": "O097", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O097", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rhinoplasty and Facial Cosmetic Surgery by Jay M. Dutton | Chicago" }, { "observation": "O097", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/6035/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) Consultation" }, { "observation": "O098", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://deantoriumi.com/", "domain": "deantoriumi.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O098", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://shahfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "shahfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O098", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://nm.org/", "domain": "nm.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "Northwestern Medicine" }, { "observation": "O098", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://tlkmplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "tlkmplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O098", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://abms.org/verify-certification", "domain": "abms.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "American Board of Medical Specialties" }, { "observation": "O098", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Society of Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O099", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O099", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty in Chicago | Dr. Dutton" }, { "observation": "O099", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://shahfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "shahfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Anil Shah: Facial Plastic Surgeon | Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O099", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/about-us/meet-dr-sinno", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Dr. Sammy Sinno - Chicago - TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O099", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rhinoplasty and Facial Cosmetic Surgery by Jay M. Dutton | Chicago" }, { "observation": "O099", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Chicago | Nose Job | Michael Horn Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O100", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://us-uk.bookimed.com/clinics/country=united-states/city=chicago/procedure=rhinoplasty-nose-job/best", "domain": "us-uk.bookimed.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "6 Best Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) Clinics in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O100", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/face-surgery-chicago/rhinoplasty-chicago", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty | Dr. John Q. Cook | Chicago, Winnetka" }, { "observation": "O100", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://shahfacialplastics.com/nose/rhinoplasty", "domain": "shahfacialplastics.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Chicago, IL | Nose Job Expert | Dr. Anil Shah" }, { "observation": "O100", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/blog/the-top-plastic-surgeons-in-chicago-discuss-rhinoplasty-will-a-you-still-look-like-yourself-after-a-nose-job", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "The Top Plastic Surgeons in Chicago Discuss Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O100", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://bodysculptor.com/face/rhinoplasty-chicago", "domain": "bodysculptor.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Chicago: Leading Surgeon for Nose Job Surgery in Illinois" }, { "observation": "O100", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/blog/how-to-choose-the-best-rhinoplasty-surgeon", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "How To Choose the Best Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Chicago (Updated 2025) – TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O100", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Chicago | Nose Job | Michael Horn Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O102", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/about-us/meet-dr-sinno", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Dr. Sammy Sinno - Chicago - TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O102", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Chicago | Nose Job | Michael Horn Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O102", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://shahfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "shahfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Anil Shah: Facial Plastic Surgeon | Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O102", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rhinoplasty and Facial Cosmetic Surgery by Jay M. Dutton | Chicago" }, { "observation": "O102", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://warnerplasticsurgery.com/nose/rhinoplasty", "domain": "warnerplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Chicago | Nose Job in Chicago, IL - Warner Institute" }, { "observation": "O102", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) in Chicago, IL - TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O102", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://rush.edu/treatments/rhinoplasty-surgery", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Surgery | Nose Job - Rush University Medical Center" }, { "observation": "O102", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/facial-plastic-surgery-chicago/rhinoplasty", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Chicago | Dr. George T. Moynihan" }, { "observation": "O103", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://deantoriumi.com/", "domain": "deantoriumi.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Dean Toriumi | Chicago, IL | Dr. Dean Toriumi, MD" }, { "observation": "O103", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://rush.edu/services/plastic-surgery-services", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Plastic Surgery Services | Rush" }, { "observation": "O103", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://theartofrhinoplasty.com/", "domain": "theartofrhinoplasty.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Dr. Gary Wiesman | Cosmetic Surgery 60654" }, { "observation": "O103", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/facial-plastic-surgery-chicago/rhinoplasty", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Chicago | Nose Job Chicago | Dr. George T. Moynihan" }, { "observation": "O103", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/about-us/meet-dr-sinno", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Dr. Sammy Sinno - Chicago" }, { "observation": "O103", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "TLKM Plastic Surgery: World-Class Plastic Surgery in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O103", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drsidle.com/procedures/rhinoplasty-nose-job", "domain": "drsidle.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O103", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://rush.edu/services/rhinoplasty/rhinoplasty-providers", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Providers | Rush" }, { "observation": "O104", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rhinoplasty and Facial Cosmetic Surgery by Jay M. Dutton ..." }, { "observation": "O104", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/about/dr-dutton", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Dr. Jay M. Dutton - Rhinoplasty Institute of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O105", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://us-uk.bookimed.com/clinics/country=united-states/city=chicago/procedure=tightening-of-facial-skin-facelift/best", "domain": "us-uk.bookimed.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "TOP 10+ Best Facelift Clinics in Chicago 2026 - Bookimed" }, { "observation": "O105", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Facial Plastic Surgery in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O105", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O105", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drbuccalfat.com/top-9-chicago-plastic-surgeons", "domain": "drbuccalfat.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top-Rated Chicago Facial Plastic Surgeons | 2026 Expert Aesthetic" }, { "observation": "O105", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/mustoe-facelift", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Renowned Deep Plane Facelift Surgeon in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O105", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://northwesternplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "northwesternplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgeons Chicago - Northwestern Plastic Surgery Center" }, { "observation": "O106", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Facial Plastic Surgery in Chicago, IL – TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O106", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://chicagoplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "chicagoplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Plastic Surgery Clinic in Northbrook, IL" }, { "observation": "O106", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/face-surgery-chicago/facelift-chicago", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift | Chicago, Winnetka | Dr. John Q. Cook" }, { "observation": "O106", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://thatfacechicago.com/face/face-facelift", "domain": "thatfacechicago.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift in Chicago | That Face Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O106", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O107", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Facial Plastic Surgeon Chicago | Facial Plastic Surgery in ..." }, { "observation": "O107", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdSZmVqZzROSEk0GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Sammy Sinno, MD" }, { "observation": "O107", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdoaWVEZG1NdxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "John Kim, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://longevity.haus/best/facelift/chicago", "domain": "longevity.haus", "type": "treatment", "title": "10 Best Facelift Clinics in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://tlkmdocs.com/", "domain": "tlkmdocs.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://hudsonfacialplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "hudsonfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://thatface.com/", "domain": "thatface.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://impressionsfaceandbody.com/", "domain": "impressionsfaceandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/parit-patel-md.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Parit A. Patel, MD" }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://plasticsurgeryclinicofchicago.com/", "domain": "plasticsurgeryclinicofchicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://nm.org/", "domain": "nm.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "Northwestern Medicine" }, { "observation": "O109", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://northwesternplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "northwesternplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgeons Chicago - Northwestern Plastic Surgery Center" }, { "observation": "O109", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://fewinstitute.com/", "domain": "fewinstitute.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery Chicago | Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Dr. Julius Few" }, { "observation": "O109", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/facial-plastic-surgery-chicago/deep-plane-facelift", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Deep Plane Facelift in Chicago | Gold Coast Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O109", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/mustoe-facelift", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Renowned Deep Plane Facelift Surgeon in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O109", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nm.org/conditions-and-care-areas/plastic-surgery", "domain": "nm.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery | Northwestern Medicine" }, { "observation": "O110", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdjemVuY3djbXBrGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O110", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVhBd01XSTRiSE55GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "That Face Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O110", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdoaWVEZG1NdxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "John Kim, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O110", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdSZmVqZzROSEk0GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Sammy Sinno, MD" }, { "observation": "O111", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://fewinstitute.com/", "domain": "fewinstitute.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "The Few Institute's website" }, { "observation": "O112", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://us-uk.bookimed.com/clinics/country=united-states/city=chicago/procedure=tightening-of-facial-skin-facelift/best", "domain": "us-uk.bookimed.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "TOP 10+ Best Facelift Clinics in Chicago 2026 - Bookimed" }, { "observation": "O112", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/face-surgery-chicago/facelift-chicago", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift | Chicago, Winnetka | Dr. John Q. Cook" }, { "observation": "O112", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://bodysculptor.com/", "domain": "bodysculptor.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgeon: Top Plastic Surgery Center in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O112", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://hudsonfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "hudsonfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Hudson Facial Plastic Surgery - Deep Plane Facelift Chicago" }, { "observation": "O112", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://enhance-face.com/", "domain": "enhance-face.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgery Center, LLC | Stacie D. McClane, M.D." }, { "observation": "O112", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://cscchicago.com/", "domain": "cscchicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Cosmetic Surgery Center of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O112", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://fulcrumaesthetics.com/face/deep-plane-facelift", "domain": "fulcrumaesthetics.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Deep Plane Facelift in Chicago, IL - Fulcrum Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O112", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://nm.org/conditions-and-care-areas/plastic-surgery", "domain": "nm.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery | Northwestern Medicine" }, { "observation": "O113", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Plastic Surgery Chicago | Dr. Horn" }, { "observation": "O113", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdJMWR6RjJiakZxGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Chicago Breast & Body Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O113", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdNMU5HUm9jRFpuGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Bloom Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://geldnercenter.com/", "domain": "geldnercenter.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "The Geldner Center" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/Peter-Geldner-MD.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Peter D. Geldner, MD" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/lawrence-iteld-md-chicago?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Iteld Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/thomas-a-mustoe-md-facs-chicago-5?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Thomas A. Mustoe, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/tlkm-plastic-surgery-chicago?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Sammy Sinno, MD" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://northwesternplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "northwesternplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Northwestern Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/chicago-breast-augmentation.html?section=testimonials", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Clark F. Schierle, MD, PhD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://iteld.com/", "domain": "iteld.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Iteld Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://rosettplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "rosettplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rosett Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://tlkmdocs.com/", "domain": "tlkmdocs.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 12, "url": "https://plasticsurgeryclinicofchicago.com/", "domain": "plasticsurgeryclinicofchicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 13, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/parit-patel-md.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Parit A. Patel, MD" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 14, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/plastic-surgery-clinic-of-chicago-chicago-2?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 15, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O114", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 16, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/find-a-surgeon", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "American Society of Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O115", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Voted #1 Plastic Surgery Chicago | Breast & Body Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O115", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O115", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://bodysculptor.com/", "domain": "bodysculptor.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgeon: Top Plastic Surgery Center in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O115", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Plastic Surgery Chicago | Dr. Horn" }, { "observation": "O115", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nikichristopoulosmd.com/aesthetic-surgery-procedures/breast-surgery", "domain": "nikichristopoulosmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Breast Surgery In Chicago | Niki Christopoulos, MD FACS" }, { "observation": "O115", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/breast-surgery-chicago", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Surgery | Chicago, Winnetka | Dr. John Q. Cook" }, { "observation": "O116", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Plastic Surgery Chicago | Dr. Horn" }, { "observation": "O116", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drkimsurgery.com/procedures/breast-surgery/breast-augmentation", "domain": "drkimsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Enhancement Chicago, IL - Breast Augmentation by Dr. Kim" }, { "observation": "O116", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Voted #1 Plastic Surgery Chicago | Breast & Body Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O116", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://us-uk.bookimed.com/clinics/country=united-states/city=chicago/procedure=breast-augmentation", "domain": "us-uk.bookimed.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation Clinics in Chicago 2026" }, { "observation": "O116", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://bloomplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "bloomplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Bloom Plastic Surgery - Chicago Plastic & Cosmetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O116", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O116", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://reddit.com/r/CHIbitcheswithtaste/comments/1p6jxl6/breast_augmentation_doctor_recommendations", "domain": "reddit.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast augmentation doctor recommendations? - Reddit" }, { "observation": "O116", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://prplastic.com/", "domain": "prplastic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Plastic Surgery Chicago IL | Dr Speron Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://aestheticinstitutechicago.com/breast/augmentation", "domain": "aestheticinstitutechicago.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast augmentation services and surgeons" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://aestheticinstitutechicago.com/our-practice/our-quad-a-accredited-surgical-facility", "domain": "aestheticinstitutechicago.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Operating facility and accreditation" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://aestheticinstitutechicago.com/our-practice", "domain": "aestheticinstitutechicago.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Surgeon credentials" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://mygeldnercenter.com/breast-augmentation", "domain": "mygeldnercenter.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation procedure" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://mygeldnercenter.com/about/ambulatory-surgical-centers", "domain": "mygeldnercenter.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Chicago surgical center and facility details" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://mygeldnercenter.com/about", "domain": "mygeldnercenter.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Geldner's practice" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/chicago-breast-augmentation.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Dr. Schierle's ASPS profile and operating facilities" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://northwesternplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "northwesternplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Northwestern Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/parit-patel-md.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Patel's American Society of Plastic Surgeons profile" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://wiesmancosmeticsurgery.com/breast-augmentation.html", "domain": "wiesmancosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast augmentation procedure" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://wiesmancosmeticsurgery.com/breast-implants.html", "domain": "wiesmancosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast implant services" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 12, "url": "https://drgikas.com/", "domain": "drgikas.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Gikas's official practice website" }, { "observation": "O117", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 13, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O118", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Voted #1 Plastic Surgery Chicago | Breast & Body Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O118", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/breast-surgery-chicago/breast-augmentation", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation | Dr. John Q. Cook | Chicago" }, { "observation": "O118", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drkimsurgery.com/procedures/breast-surgery/breast-augmentation", "domain": "drkimsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Enhancement Chicago, IL - Breast Augmentation by Dr. Kim" }, { "observation": "O118", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O118", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://northwesternplasticsurgery.com/breast-procedures-chicago/breast-augmentation", "domain": "northwesternplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Chicago - Northwestern Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O118", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://aestheticinstitutechicago.com/", "domain": "aestheticinstitutechicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Aesthetic Institute of Chicago: Plastic Surgery in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O118", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://krochmalplasticsurgery.com/procedures/breast-procedures/breast-augmentation-chicago", "domain": "krochmalplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Chicago | Krochmal Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O118", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://rush.edu/treatments/breast-augmentation", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation - Rush University Medical Center" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://bloomplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "bloomplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Bloom Plastic Surgery - Chicago Plastic & Cosmetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drkimsurgery.com/procedures/breast-surgery/breast-augmentation", "domain": "drkimsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Enhancement Chicago, IL - Breast Augmentation by Dr. Kim" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://prplastic.com/", "domain": "prplastic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Plastic Surgery Chicago IL | Dr Speron Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://pscofchicago.com/", "domain": "pscofchicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago | Dr. Parit Patel" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://stcharlesplasticsurgery.com/chicago-breast-augmentation", "domain": "stcharlesplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Chicago IL | St Charles Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdJMWR6RjJiakZxGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Chicago Breast & Body Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdjemVuY3djbXBrGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdNMU5HUm9jRFpuGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Bloom Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdZeWVXUTJiZxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "John Q. Cook M.D. | Whole Beauty® Institute" }, { "observation": "O119", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://bodysculptor.com/breast-augmentation-cost-chicago-il", "domain": "bodysculptor.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Surgery Cost - Chicago - Dr. Otto Placik" }, { "observation": "O120", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/niki-christopoulos-md.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Niki A. Christopoulos, MD, FACS | American Society of Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O121", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O121", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://miamivibesmag.com/post/the-top-rated-rhinoplasty-surgeons-in-miami", "domain": "miamivibesmag.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The Top-Rated Rhinoplasty Surgeons in Miami" }, { "observation": "O121", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami FL - Voted Best Nose Surgeon - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O121", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://facemiami.com/", "domain": "facemiami.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Kallman: Best Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Miami" }, { "observation": "O121", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami-Beach/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami Beach, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O122", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/nose-surgery", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Nose Surgery Miami (Rhinoplasty) Expert Nose Surgery & Reshaping" }, { "observation": "O122", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/procedure/rhinoplasty", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Surgery - Nose Surgery | Miami, FL | Dr. Leonard Hochstein" }, { "observation": "O122", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O122", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://aeris.co/how-to-pick-the-best-rhinoplasty-surgeon-in-miami-2026-guide", "domain": "aeris.co", "type": "treatment", "title": "How To Pick the Best Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Miami (2026 ..." }, { "observation": "O122", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://smartplasticsurgerymiami.com/rhinoplasty-in-miami", "domain": "smartplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Miami: Types, Recovery, and Choosing the ..." }, { "observation": "O122", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://miamivibesmag.com/post/the-top-rated-rhinoplasty-surgeons-in-miami", "domain": "miamivibesmag.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The Top-Rated Rhinoplasty Surgeons in Miami" }, { "observation": "O122", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://facebook.com/DrRicardoCastrellon/posts/deciding-on-a-rhinoplasty-is-deeply-personal-if-you-find-yourself-constantly-che/1903560047488030", "domain": "facebook.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "How to know if rhinoplasty is right for you in Miami - Facebook" }, { "observation": "O123", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4YUdNeVptUjVjRFkYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami: Dr. Marcelo Ghersi" }, { "observation": "O123", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdaeWFHdDBlURgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O124", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://facialplasticsurgerymiami.com/", "domain": "facialplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O124", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://abfprs.org/", "domain": "abfprs.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "ABFPRS" }, { "observation": "O124", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "ABPS" }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/nose-surgery", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami | Nose Surgery From $4,900 | Spectrum Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Spectrum Aesthetics: Premier Plastic Surgery in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://instagram.com/reel/CM4yDqGg9E9", "domain": "instagram.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Spectrum Aesthetics on Instagram: \"Rhinoplasty surgery, or ..." }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/doctors", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Doctors - Spectrum Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/about-us", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "About Spectrum Aesthetics - Plastic Surgery Clinic in Miami, Florida" }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://digeronimomd.com/services/rhinoplasty", "domain": "digeronimomd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty - Doral, FL: Ernest M. DiGeronimo, MD: Plastic Surgeon: DiGeronimo MD Advanced Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://305plasticsurgery.com/plastic-surgeon-dr-digeronimo", "domain": "305plasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. DiGeronimo | Best Plastic Surgeons in 305 Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://facebook.com/digeronimomd", "domain": "facebook.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Dr. Ernest DiGeronimo Aventura Plastic Surgeon | Aventura FL" }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://tebra.com/care/provider/ernest-digeronimo-md-1346450392", "domain": "tebra.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Dr. Ernest Digeronimo, MD, Doral, FL | Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O125", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://digeronimomd.com/", "domain": "digeronimomd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Ernest M. DiGeronimo, MD: Plastic Surgeon Doral, FL: DiGeronimo MD Advanced Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O126", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O126", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lampertmd.com/about/our-facility", "domain": "lampertmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Our Facility | Dr. Joshua Lampert" }, { "observation": "O126", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty in Miami - Dr. Carlos Wolf" }, { "observation": "O126", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/locations", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "location", "title": "Conveniently Located Cosmetic Service Centers in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O127", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://baptisthealth.net/doctors/andres-bustillo-lopez/869066", "domain": "baptisthealth.net", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Andres Bustillo Lopez, MD" }, { "observation": "O127", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://mqa-internet.doh.state.fl.us/MQASearchServices/HealthcareProviders/Details?LicInd=88067&ProCde=1501", "domain": "mqa-internet.doh.state.fl.us", "type": "unclassified", "title": "FL DOH MQA Search Portal" }, { "observation": "O128", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O128", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami FL - Voted Best Nose Surgeon - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O128", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://zfaceplasticsurgery.com/facial-plastic-surgery-miami/rhinoplasty", "domain": "zfaceplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty In Miami | Dr. Z Is A Miami Nose Specialist" }, { "observation": "O128", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://umiamihealth.org/en/treatments-and-services/ear,-nose,-and-throat-(ent)/facial-plastic-and-reconstructive-surgery", "domain": "umiamihealth.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery | University of Miami" }, { "observation": "O128", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drwolfrhinoplasty.com/", "domain": "drwolfrhinoplasty.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Carlos Wolf, MD - Rhinoplasty Miami / Nose Surgery" }, { "observation": "O128", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty in Miami - Dr. Carlos Wolf" }, { "observation": "O128", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://facemiami.com/", "domain": "facemiami.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Kallman: Best Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Miami" }, { "observation": "O129", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/miami-facelift-surgeon", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami FL - Voted Best Facelift Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O129", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-stephan-baker-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Facelift" }, { "observation": "O129", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/3350/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Facial Rejuvenation" }, { "observation": "O129", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-silvia-c-rotemberg-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Consultation" }, { "observation": "O129", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-jose-rodr%C3%83%C2%ADguez-feliz-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Radiesse" }, { "observation": "O131", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://edenplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "edenplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Facelift Plastic Surgery | Fort Lauderdale Facelift Specialist" }, { "observation": "O131", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Icon Cosmetic Center: Best Cosmetic Surgery Center Miami" }, { "observation": "O131", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/miami-facelift-surgeon", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami FL - Voted Best Facelift Surgeon - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O131", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O131", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Deep-Plane-Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Deep Plane Facelift Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O131", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O131", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drbustillo.com/", "domain": "drbustillo.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Bustillo | Miami's Leader in Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O131", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://drpaulafrooz.com/face/facelift-miami", "domain": "drpaulafrooz.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami, FL | Expert Facelift Surgeon Dr. Paul Afrooz" }, { "observation": "O132", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://smartplasticsurgerymiami.com/best-plastic-surgeon-for-a-facelift-in-miami", "domain": "smartplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "How to choose the best plastic surgeon for a face lift in Miami" }, { "observation": "O132", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nidiadejesusmd.com/facelift-miami-cost-types", "domain": "nidiadejesusmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift in Miami: Types, Cost, and Recovery in 2026" }, { "observation": "O132", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/facelift-miami", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami - From $3800 (Neck Lift) - Icon Cosmetic Center" }, { "observation": "O132", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/3351/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Facial Rejuvenation" }, { "observation": "O132", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/3352/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Facial Rejuvenation" }, { "observation": "O132", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://aestheticmatch.ghost.io/best-plastic-surgeons-in-miami-2025-guide-city-wide", "domain": "aestheticmatch.ghost.io", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Plastic Surgeons in Miami (2025 Guide) (city" }, { "observation": "O132", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://community.realself.com/forum/face-lift-miami", "domain": "community.realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Face Lift Miami - Facelift forum" }, { "observation": "O133", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O134", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://edenplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "edenplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Facelift Plastic Surgery | Fort Lauderdale Facelift Specialist" }, { "observation": "O134", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://floridacentercosmetic.com/miami/face/face-lift", "domain": "floridacentercosmetic.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift in Miami, FL | Surgical Facial Rejuvenation" }, { "observation": "O134", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://miamilifecosmetic.com/", "domain": "miamilifecosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Life Cosmetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O134", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Icon Cosmetic Center: Best Cosmetic Surgery Center Miami" }, { "observation": "O134", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O134", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drnathan.com/", "domain": "drnathan.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Nirmal Nathan" }, { "observation": "O134", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O134", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://drhanabergh.com/", "domain": "drhanabergh.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Enrique Hanabergh, MD - Board Certified Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O134", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://therealdrmiami.com/surgeons", "domain": "therealdrmiami.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Michael Salzhauer, MD | Meet Dr. Miami" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/facelift-miami", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami - From $3800 (Neck Lift) - Icon Cosmetic Center" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Cosmetic Surgery Center Miami | Icon Cosmetic Center" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/about", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "About us - Our Practice | Icon Cosmetic Center" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/scott-moradian", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Scott Moradian" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://theaestheticsociety.org/select-surgeon/stephan-baker-md-facs", "domain": "theaestheticsociety.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Stephan Baker, MD, FACS | The Aesthetic Society" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drbaker.com/face/facelift", "domain": "drbaker.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami, FL | Dr. Stephan Baker" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://healthgrades.com/physician/dr-ernest-digeronimo-2r6mn", "domain": "healthgrades.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Dr. Ernest Digeronimo, MD - Plastic Surgeon in Miami, FL | Healthgrades" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://digeronimomd.com/services/facelift", "domain": "digeronimomd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift - Doral, FL: Ernest M. DiGeronimo, MD: Plastic Surgeon: DiGeronimo MD Advanced Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://digeronimomd.com/contents/about/our-mission", "domain": "digeronimomd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Our Mission - Doral, FL: DiGeronimo MD Advanced Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O135", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://tebra.com/care/practice/digeronimo-md-advanced-plastic-surgery-204332", "domain": "tebra.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "DiGeronimo MD Advanced Plastic Surgery, Doral, FL" }, { "observation": "O136", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Expert Plastic Surgery in Miami, FL | Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O136", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drbaker.com/", "domain": "drbaker.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Stephan Baker MD" }, { "observation": "O136", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-stephan-baker-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Facelift" }, { "observation": "O137", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery Miami FL - Voted Best Plastic Surgeon Miami" }, { "observation": "O137", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://sveltaplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "sveltaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Svelta Plastic Surgery: Leading Plastic Surgery Miami" }, { "observation": "O137", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O137", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O137", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://avanaplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "avanaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Avana Plastic Surgery | Best Cosmetic Surgery in Miami" }, { "observation": "O137", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drllorente.com/", "domain": "drllorente.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Orlando Llorente | Top Rated Plastic Surgeon in Miami Florida" }, { "observation": "O137", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drjsalomon.com/the-best-breast-augmentation-miami", "domain": "drjsalomon.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The Best Breast Augmentation in Miami - Dr Jhonny Salomon" }, { "observation": "O138", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://theplasticsurgeonmiami.com/choosing-the-best-augmentation-for-me-from-plastic-surgeons-miami", "domain": "theplasticsurgeonmiami.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgeons Miami Breast Augmentation Types for You" }, { "observation": "O138", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/pricing-and-fees-overview", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Leonard Hochstein : Pricing and Fees Overview - Miami Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O138", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://edenplasticsurgery.com/breast-augmentation", "domain": "edenplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Miami Best Breast Augmentation, Implants" }, { "observation": "O138", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://booking.pabau.com/briaplasticsurgeryllc/online-bookings?location=24076&withGoogle=true&source=google&groupCategory=16155&category=195964&services=3589218", "domain": "booking.pabau.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "S01 Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O138", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://aestheticmatch.com/blog/miami/best-plastic-surgeons-in-miami-guide-city-wide", "domain": "aestheticmatch.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Best Plastic Surgeons in Miami (2025 Guide) (city-wide)" }, { "observation": "O138", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://beautylandplasticsurgery.com/cost-plastic-surgery-in-miami-compared-other-major-cities", "domain": "beautylandplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Cost of Plastic Surgery in Miami Compared to Other Major Cities" }, { "observation": "O138", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://smartplasticsurgerymiami.com/breast-augmentation-cost-in-miami", "domain": "smartplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Cost in Miami: 2026 Pricing Guide and ..." }, { "observation": "O138", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://aeplasticsurgerymiami.com/plastic-surgery-guide/plastic-surgery-cost-in-miami", "domain": "aeplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic surgery cost in Miami: Complete guide to prices" }, { "observation": "O138", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Breast-Implants", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Implants Doctors in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O139", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O139", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O139", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://booking.pabau.com/briaplasticsurgeryllc/online-bookings?location=24076&withGoogle=true&source=google&groupCategory=16155&category=195964&services=3589218", "domain": "booking.pabau.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "S01 Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O139", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/3352/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Moxi / Bbl Consultation" }, { "observation": "O139", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/3350/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Coolsculpting Consultation" }, { "observation": "O140", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/cosmetic-procedures/breast-augmentation/surgeon", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Choosing a Plastic Surgeon for Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O140", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/patient-safety?sub=Choose+a+Plastic+Surgeon+You+Can+Trust", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Choose a Plastic Surgeon You Can Trust | Patient Safety" }, { "observation": "O140", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/documents/holidays/2024/Surgeon-Checklist.pdf", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "ASPS Surgeon Credentials Checklist" }, { "observation": "O141", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://m.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Breast+Augmentation&find_loc=Miami+Beach%2C+FL", "domain": "m.yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "TOP 10 BEST Breast Augmentation in Miami Beach, FL - Yelp" }, { "observation": "O141", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery Miami FL - Voted Best Plastic Surgeon Miami" }, { "observation": "O141", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://booking.pabau.com/briaplasticsurgeryllc/online-bookings?location=24076&withGoogle=true&source=google&groupCategory=16155&category=195964&services=3589218", "domain": "booking.pabau.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "S01 Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O141", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-michael-stefan-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O142", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Expert Plastic Surgery in Miami, FL | Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O142", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/breast-chest/breast-augmentation", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Miami Breast Implants | Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O142", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://sveltaplasticsurgery.com/about-us", "domain": "sveltaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Beauty & Emotional Empowerment - Svelta Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O142", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdOdGVuQXdjMkl5GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O142", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEhnNGRGOTVhZxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Miami Center for Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O143", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O143", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://jointcommission.org/", "domain": "jointcommission.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "The Joint Commission" }, { "observation": "O143", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://quada.org/", "domain": "quada.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "QUAD A" }, { "observation": "O144", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/locations", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "location", "title": "Conveniently Located Cosmetic Service Centers in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O144", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O144", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://umiamihealth.org/en/treatments-and-services/plastic-surgery", "domain": "umiamihealth.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Plastic Surgery | University of Miami Health System" }, { "observation": "O144", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O144", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/breast-surgery/miami-breast-augmentation", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Miami FL - Breast Implant Surgeon Miami" }, { "observation": "O144", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Breast-Implants", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Implants Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O144", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/miami/for-medical-professionals", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Find a Miami Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O145", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://doctorsplasticsurgery.com/new-york/rhinoplasty", "domain": "doctorsplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty NYC | Affordable Cost Nose Jobs New York" }, { "observation": "O145", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/procedures/nose-surgery/non-surgical-rhinoplasty", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Non-Surgical Rhinoplasty New York City - Dr. Philip Miller" }, { "observation": "O145", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York/Revision-Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Revision Rhinoplasty Doctors in New York, NY" }, { "observation": "O145", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-norman-j-pastorek-md-facs", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Revision Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O145", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/2871/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Liquid Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O145", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/george-lefkovits-md-129511?LocIdent=69689&entity_id=pr_bzEhhQArbkqOqpyG6OTzsh-lo_4XGyirazuUSaN1qSqT1BJB-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Plastic Surgery Consultation" }, { "observation": "O146", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEhCdU0yZDRNQRgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Maurice M. Khosh, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O146", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4TWpZMGNETnNhMjAYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Edward S. Kwak MD - ESKMD Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O146", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdNemN6azFkbmxxGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Benjamin Paul" }, { "observation": "O146", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O147", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://weillcornell.org/", "domain": "weillcornell.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "Weill Cornell Medicine" }, { "observation": "O147", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://samanmd.com/", "domain": "samanmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official practice website" }, { "observation": "O147", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official practice website" }, { "observation": "O147", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://nycfacedoc.com/", "domain": "nycfacedoc.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official practice website" }, { "observation": "O147", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/cosmetic-procedures/rhinoplasty/surgeon", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Choosing a Plastic Surgeon for Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O147", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/documents/holidays/2024/Surgeon-Checklist.pdf", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "ASPS Surgeon Credentials Checklist" }, { "observation": "O148", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York-City/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in New York City, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O148", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drbenpaul.com/face-new-york-city/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drbenpaul.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty In New York City (NYC) | Dr. Benjamin Paul" }, { "observation": "O148", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/procedures/procedures-for-women/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Celebrity Rhinoplasty Surgeon In New York City" }, { "observation": "O148", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://naturallookinstitute.com/best-nose-job-doctor-nyc", "domain": "naturallookinstitute.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Nose Job Doctor In NYC | Dr. Yoel Shahar - Natural Look Institute" }, { "observation": "O148", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drjoshuazimm.com/rhinoplasty-nose-job-nyc", "domain": "drjoshuazimm.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty NYC | Nose Job Surgeon in New York" }, { "observation": "O148", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in New York, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O148", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://hauteliving.com/hautemd/best-doctors-for-rhinoplasty-new-york", "domain": "hauteliving.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty Surgeons in New York — Haute MD Network" }, { "observation": "O148", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://cityfacialplastics.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "cityfacialplastics.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Best Nose Job Surgeon New York City - Dr. Linkov" }, { "observation": "O149", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEhCdU0yZDRNQRgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Maurice M. Khosh, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O149", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4TWpZMGNETnNhMjAYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Edward S. Kwak MD - ESKMD Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O150", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drsamrizk.com/", "domain": "drsamrizk.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official practice website" }, { "observation": "O150", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://eskmd.com/", "domain": "eskmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official practice website" }, { "observation": "O150", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drjoshzimm.com/", "domain": "drjoshzimm.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official practice website" }, { "observation": "O150", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://nychealthandhospitals.org/metropolitan/services/surgery", "domain": "nychealthandhospitals.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Surgical Specialties" }, { "observation": "O150", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nychealthandhospitals.org/doctors/kressel-aron-z", "domain": "nychealthandhospitals.org", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Kressel Aron Z., MD" }, { "observation": "O151", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://labrunamd.com/facilities", "domain": "labrunamd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Facilities - Manhattan Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O151", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://meeth.northwell.edu/plastic-surgery-center", "domain": "meeth.northwell.edu", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery Center - Manhattan Eye, Ear & Throat Hospital" }, { "observation": "O151", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/ent/services/facial-plastic-reconstructive-surgery/cosmetic/nose-surgery-rhinoplasty", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) NYC | Mount Sinai - New York" }, { "observation": "O151", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://castleconnolly.com/expertise/rhinoplasty/new-york-ny", "domain": "castleconnolly.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Find doctors that specialize in Rhinoplasty near New York, NY" }, { "observation": "O151", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York-City/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in New York City, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O151", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drkassir.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drkassir.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty New York City | Dr. Ramtin Kassir" }, { "observation": "O151", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://newfaceny.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "newfaceny.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in NYC | Best Nose Surgeon in New York City" }, { "observation": "O151", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/procedures/procedures-for-women/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Celebrity Rhinoplasty Surgeon In New York City" }, { "observation": "O152", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "http://archotol.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?doi=10.1001/jamaoto.2013.4163", "domain": "archotol.jamanetwork.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "A Patient With Nasal Valve Compromise" }, { "observation": "O152", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://doctormbt.com/", "domain": "doctormbt.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Dr. Michael Bassiri-Tehrani | Dr. Bassiri-Tehrani" }, { "observation": "O152", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drkolker.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty NYC | Nose Job New York City | Dr. Kolker" }, { "observation": "O152", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://parkavenueplasticsurgeon.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "parkavenueplasticsurgeon.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Best Nose Job Surgeon in New York" }, { "observation": "O152", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O152", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://longevity.haus/best/rhinoplasty/new-york-city", "domain": "longevity.haus", "type": "treatment", "title": "10 Best Rhinoplasty Clinics in New York City (2026)" }, { "observation": "O152", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://mdface.com/nose-job-surgeons-in-nyc", "domain": "mdface.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "One of the Top Nose Job Surgeons in NYC | Pearlman Aesthetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O152", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://doctorsplasticsurgery.com/new-york/rhinoplasty-nyc-1-1", "domain": "doctorsplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Top Nose Job Surgery New York | Doctors Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O152", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty NYC | Dr. Jennifer Levine" }, { "observation": "O153", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York-City/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in New York City, NY" }, { "observation": "O153", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/Manhattan/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Manhattan, NY" }, { "observation": "O153", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://longevity.haus/best/facelift/new-york-city", "domain": "longevity.haus", "type": "treatment", "title": "10 Best Facelift Clinics in New York City" }, { "observation": "O153", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "ABPS" }, { "observation": "O153", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://abfprs.org/", "domain": "abfprs.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "ABFPRS" }, { "observation": "O154", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drkassir.com/face/facelift", "domain": "drkassir.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift New York City | Triple Board-Certified Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O154", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in New York, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O154", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://albertplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "albertplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Albert Plastic Surgery: Facial Plastic Surgery NYC | Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O154", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://castleconnolly.com/expertise/facelift/new-york-ny", "domain": "castleconnolly.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Find doctors that specialize in Facelift near New York, NY" }, { "observation": "O154", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/about-dr-jacono/best-facelift-surgeon-america", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "dr jacono americas best facelift surgeon - Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O154", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/about-dr-jacono/dr-jacono-reviews-and-news/best-facelift-surgeon-nyc", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift Surgeon NYC | Dr. Andrew Jacono M.D. FACS" }, { "observation": "O155", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drjenniferlevine.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/face/facelift", "domain": "drjenniferlevine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift New York City | Dr. Jennifer Levine" }, { "observation": "O155", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drkolker.com/face/face-lift", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift NYC | Top Facial Plastic Surgeon in New York City" }, { "observation": "O155", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://plasticsurgerygroupnyc.com/", "domain": "plasticsurgerygroupnyc.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Plastic Surgeon NYC | Board Certified Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O155", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://doctorsplasticsurgery.com/new-york/facelift-nyc-1-1", "domain": "doctorsplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift NYC | Affordable Mini & Deep Plane Facelift Surgery | Top Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O155", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/plastic-surgery-results/facelift/best-facelift-usa-surgeon", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift Surgeon in New York City" }, { "observation": "O155", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://parkavenueplasticsurgeon.com/face/facelift", "domain": "parkavenueplasticsurgeon.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift Surgeon in New York | Dr. David P. Rapaport" }, { "observation": "O155", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drphilipmiller.com/2020/05/22/top-new-york-facial-plastic-surgeon-reveals-difference-between-surgical-and-liquid-face-lifts", "domain": "drphilipmiller.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Top New York Facial Plastic Surgeon Reveals Difference ..." }, { "observation": "O155", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/plastic-surgeons/new-york-46063pm", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Best Plastic Surgeons Near Me in New York, NY" }, { "observation": "O156", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Facelift" }, { "observation": "O156", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-norman-j-pastorek-md-facs", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Facelift" }, { "observation": "O156", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-joseph-j-rousso-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Modified Extended Deep Plane Face And Neck Lift" }, { "observation": "O156", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/2868/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Facelift/Necklift" }, { "observation": "O157", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "newyorkfacialplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "New York Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O157", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://castleconnolly.com/expertise/facelift/new-york-ny", "domain": "castleconnolly.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Find doctors that specialize in Facelift near New York, NY" }, { "observation": "O157", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://realself.com/find/New-York/New-York/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in New York, NY - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O157", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "David Rosenberg, MD: Celebrity Facial Plastic Surgeon In New York" }, { "observation": "O157", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drdavidrosenberg.com/surgery-center", "domain": "drdavidrosenberg.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Manhattan Facial Surgery Suites | David Rosenberg, MD" }, { "observation": "O157", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://lipsg.com/about", "domain": "lipsg.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top Plastic Surgery Practice in NYC and Long Island, New York" }, { "observation": "O157", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://nycfacedoc.com/face/facelift-nyc", "domain": "nycfacedoc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift NYC | Deep Plane Face & Neck Lift - Dr. Moustafa Mourad" }, { "observation": "O157", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/surgery/services/plastic-surgery", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery NYC | Mount Sinai - New York" }, { "observation": "O158", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Facelift" }, { "observation": "O158", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://tebra.com/care/provider/elliott-rose-md-1609986892?lid=510096032", "domain": "tebra.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Cosmetic Facial Surgery" }, { "observation": "O158", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/george-lefkovits-md-129511?LocIdent=69689&entity_id=pr_bzEhhQArbkqOqpyG6OTzsh-lo_4XGyirazuUSaN1qSqT1BJB-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Plastic Surgery Consultation" }, { "observation": "O158", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://calendly.com/drkopelman", "domain": "calendly.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Virtual Plastic Surgery Consult With Dr. Joel Kopelman" }, { "observation": "O159", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://normanpastorekmd.com/location/new-york-ny", "domain": "normanpastorekmd.com", "type": "location", "title": "New York, NY 10128 | Facial Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O159", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nextpatient.co/p/4432/providers", "domain": "nextpatient.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Face: Facelift" }, { "observation": "O159", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-norman-j-pastorek-md-facs", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Facelift" }, { "observation": "O159", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-joseph-j-rousso-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Modified Extended Deep Plane Face And Neck Lift" }, { "observation": "O161", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drkolker.com/", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Adam Kolker, MD" }, { "observation": "O161", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://droliviahutchinson.com/", "domain": "droliviahutchinson.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery Upper East Side | Female Plastic Surgeon New York" }, { "observation": "O161", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://premingermd.com/", "domain": "premingermd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Aviva™ Preminger MD Aesthetic Plastic Surgery | Top Female ..." }, { "observation": "O161", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://mountsinai.org/care/surgery/services/plastic-surgery/aesthetic/breast-enhancement/breast-augmentation", "domain": "mountsinai.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Surgery NYC | Mount Sinai - New York" }, { "observation": "O161", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nyplasticsurg.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/breast/augmentation", "domain": "nyplasticsurg.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation NYC | Dr. John E. Sherman" }, { "observation": "O161", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/new-york", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Find a New York Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O161", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://neinsteinplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "neinsteinplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "NYC Liposuction Specialist | Upper East Side | Neinstein Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O162", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drkolker.com/", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Adam Kolker, MD" }, { "observation": "O162", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/adam-schaffner-facs-md-16219?LocIdent=181134&entity_id=pr_9gK8I5mXWkKVkRO0o_kqwB-lo_C16pYpHusEC1V8S4KAkw4h-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O163", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://darrensmithmd.com/", "domain": "darrensmithmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O163", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://kiwanukaplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "kiwanukaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O163", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drmaman.com/", "domain": "drmaman.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O163", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://thenycplasticsurgeon.com/", "domain": "thenycplasticsurgeon.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O163", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://traceycookmd.com/", "domain": "traceycookmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O163", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drkolker.com/", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O164", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://psurgery.com/breast-augmentation-new-york-city", "domain": "psurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation in New York City - Dr. Scott Newman" }, { "observation": "O164", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nyplasticsurg.com/plastic-surgery-new-york/breast/augmentation", "domain": "nyplasticsurg.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation NYC | Dr. John E. Sherman" }, { "observation": "O164", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drkolker.com/", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation NYC | Top Plastic Surgeon New York City" }, { "observation": "O164", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drmichaeljstein.com/", "domain": "drmichaeljstein.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Michael Stein - Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O164", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://stevenlevinemd.com/best-breast-implants-plastic-surgeon-upper-east-side-nyc", "domain": "stevenlevinemd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implants Surgery NYC - STEVEN M. LEVINE, MD" }, { "observation": "O164", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://plasticsurgeoninnyc.com/", "domain": "plasticsurgeoninnyc.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Adam Schaffner, MD, FACS: Plastic Surgeon NYC" }, { "observation": "O165", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4ZVdkc2NUQXlYM1EYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Keith M. Blechman, MD - Blechman Plastic Surgery Group" }, { "observation": "O165", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdRek9UUnhadxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Adam R. Kolker, M.D., FACS" }, { "observation": "O165", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/adam-schaffner-facs-md-16219?LocIdent=181134&entity_id=pr_9gK8I5mXWkKVkRO0o_kqwB-lo_C16pYpHusEC1V8S4KAkw4h-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O167", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://psurgery.com/breast-augmentation-new-york-city", "domain": "psurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation in New York City - Dr. Scott Newman" }, { "observation": "O167", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drkolker.com/", "domain": "drkolker.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation NYC | Top Plastic Surgeon New York City" }, { "observation": "O167", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://orenlerman.com/locations/new-york-office", "domain": "orenlerman.com", "type": "location", "title": "New York Plastic Surgeon Office | Oren Z. Lerman, MD" }, { "observation": "O167", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/locations/laura-isaac-perlmutter-cosmetic-plastic-surgery-center", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "location", "title": "Laura and Isaac Perlmutter Cosmetic Plastic Surgery Center" }, { "observation": "O167", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://castleconnolly.com/specialty/plastic-surgery/new-york-ny", "domain": "castleconnolly.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top Plastic Surgeons near New York, NY" }, { "observation": "O167", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://plasticsurgeoninnyc.com/breast-implants", "domain": "plasticsurgeoninnyc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implants Plastic Surgeon NYC | Adam Schaffner, MD" }, { "observation": "O167", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://aestheticmatch.com/blog/new-york/best-breast-augmentation-surgeons-in-new-york-city-guide", "domain": "aestheticmatch.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation Surgeons in New York City (2025 Guide)" }, { "observation": "O168", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/care-services/plastic-surgery", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery | NYU Langone Health" }, { "observation": "O168", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nyulangone.org/locations/laura-isaac-perlmutter-cosmetic-plastic-surgery-center", "domain": "nyulangone.org", "type": "location", "title": "Laura & Isaac Perlmutter Cosmetic Plastic Surgery Center | NYU Langone Health" }, { "observation": "O168", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://plasticsandderm.com/about/surgical-suite", "domain": "plasticsandderm.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Our Surgical Suite NYC | Plastic Surgery & Dermatology of NYC" }, { "observation": "O168", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://shaferplasticsurgery.com/services/breast-augmentation", "domain": "shaferplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Surgical Breast Enhancement Procedure NYC - Shafer Clinic" }, { "observation": "O168", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://plasticsurgeoninnyc.com/breast-implants", "domain": "plasticsurgeoninnyc.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Implants Plastic Surgeon NYC | Adam Schaffner, MD" }, { "observation": "O168", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4TW5aeWJuWnlhR1EYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Aristocrat Plastic Surgery: Dr. Kevin Tehrani - NYC" }, { "observation": "O168", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4Y0hwM2VuRnVaelkYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Zuckerman Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rhinoplasty Institute of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/about/dr-dutton", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Facial Specialist" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/contact/locations-and-directions", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "location", "title": "Directions to Rhinoplasty Institute of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://rush.edu/services/rhinoplasty", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rush Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://rush.edu/services/rhinoplasty/rhinoplasty-providers", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Providers" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://rush.edu/referring-physicians-rush-rhinoplasty-services", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Referring Physicians: Rush Rhinoplasty Services" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://rushfacialplastics.com/facial-plastic-surgeon-chicago/our-doctors", "domain": "rushfacialplastics.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Meet Our Doctors | Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://uchicagomedicine.org/", "domain": "uchicagomedicine.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "UChicago Medicine" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://uchicagomedicine.org/find-a-physician/physician/joseph-meleca", "domain": "uchicagomedicine.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Joseph B. Meleca, MD" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://uchicagomedicine.org/find-a-physician/physician/anil-r-shah", "domain": "uchicagomedicine.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Anil R. Shah, MD" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://chicagoaesthetics.com/cosmetic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "chicagoaesthetics.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Chicago Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 12, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 13, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/about-us/meet-dr-sinno", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Nationally Recognized Board-Certified Plastic Surgeon in Chicago – Dr. Sammy Sinno" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 14, "url": "https://fellowships.aafprs.org/docs/aafprs/AAFPRS%20Descriptions%20Handbook_February%202026.pdf", "domain": "fellowships.aafprs.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "AAFPRS DescriptionsHandbook_January 2026=2.pdf" }, { "observation": "O169", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 15, "url": "https://fellowships.aafprs.org/docs/aafprs/Descriptions%20Handbook%20July%202024.pdf", "domain": "fellowships.aafprs.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "AAFPRS Fellowship Programs Description Handbook" }, { "observation": "O170", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) in Chicago, IL - TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O170", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O170", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://shahfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "shahfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Anil Shah: Facial Plastic Surgeon | Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O170", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://bloomplasticsurgery.com/choose-best-rhinoplasty-nose-surgery-plastic-surgeon-chicago", "domain": "bloomplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty (Nose Surgery) Plastic Surgeon in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O170", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://rush.edu/services/rhinoplasty/rhinoplasty-providers", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Providers - Rush University Medical Center" }, { "observation": "O170", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://warnerplasticsurgery.com/nose/rhinoplasty", "domain": "warnerplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Chicago | Nose Job in Chicago, IL - Warner Institute" }, { "observation": "O170", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://nmaestheticmedicine.com/plastic-surgery-chicago-il/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "nmaestheticmedicine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty Chicago, IL | Northwestern Medicine Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O170", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Chicago | Nose Job | Michael Horn Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O171", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://northwesternplasticsurgery.com/facial-procedures-chicago/rhinoplasty", "domain": "northwesternplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Surgery) in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O171", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://us-uk.bookimed.com/clinics/country=united-states/city=chicago/procedure=revision-rhinoplasty", "domain": "us-uk.bookimed.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "TOP-5 Best Revision rhinoplasty Clinics in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O171", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://theartofrhinoplasty.com/", "domain": "theartofrhinoplasty.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Dr. Gary Wiesman | Cosmetic Surgery 60654" }, { "observation": "O171", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://deantoriumi.com/", "domain": "deantoriumi.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Dean Toriumi | Chicago, IL | Dr. Dean Toriumi, MD" }, { "observation": "O171", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/blog/rhinoplasty-in-chicago-the-perils-of-cost-comparison", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Chicago: The Perils of Cost Comparison" }, { "observation": "O171", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drsidle.com/procedures/rhinoplasty-nose-job", "domain": "drsidle.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) in Chicago, IL - Dr. Sidle" }, { "observation": "O171", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/blog/chicago-rhinoplasty-surgeon-dr-george-t-moynihan-open-and-closed-rhinoplasty", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Chicago Rhinoplasty Surgeon | Dr. George T. Moynihan, M.D." }, { "observation": "O171", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://rush.edu/treatments/rhinoplasty-surgery", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Surgery | Nose Job | Rush" }, { "observation": "O171", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://ejyfacialplastics.com/why-have-a-rhinoplasty-performed-by-an-ent-specialist-instead-of-a-general-plastic-surgeon", "domain": "ejyfacialplastics.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Performed by an ENT Specialist & Facial Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O172", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/about-us/meet-dr-sinno", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Nationally Recognized Board-Certified Plastic Surgeon in Chicago – Dr. Sammy Sinno – TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O172", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://nmaestheticmedicine.com/plastic-surgery-chicago-il/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "nmaestheticmedicine.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty Chicago, IL | Northwestern Medicine Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O172", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdSZmVqZzROSEk0GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Sammy Sinno, MD" }, { "observation": "O172", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEd4a01ITmpkZxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Elias Gikas, MD" }, { "observation": "O173", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://mygeldnercenter.com/plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "mygeldnercenter.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Chicago & Oak Brook | Expert Nose Surgery" }, { "observation": "O173", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O173", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://shahfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "shahfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Anil Shah: Facial Plastic Surgeon | Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O175", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rhinoplasty and Facial Cosmetic Surgery by Jay M. Dutton | Chicago" }, { "observation": "O175", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://shahfacialplastics.com/nose/rhinoplasty", "domain": "shahfacialplastics.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Chicago, IL | Nose Job Expert | Dr. Anil Shah" }, { "observation": "O175", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://enhance-face.com/", "domain": "enhance-face.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgery Center, LLC | Stacie D. McClane, M.D." }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://tlkmplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "tlkmplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice and rhinoplasty information" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://toriumiimd.com/", "domain": "toriumiimd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Toriumi Facial Plastics" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://fellowships.aafprs.org/docs/aafprs/AAFPRS%20Descriptions%20Handbook_February%202026.pdf", "domain": "fellowships.aafprs.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery fellowship information" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://theartofrhinoplasty.com/", "domain": "theartofrhinoplasty.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official practice website and rhinoplasty information" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drgikas.com/", "domain": "drgikas.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Rhinoplasty and surgeon information" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drgikas.com/contact-plastic-surgeon-chicago", "domain": "drgikas.com", "type": "location", "title": "Surgical locations" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Official practice and surgeon website" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://rhinochicago.com/contact/locations-and-directions", "domain": "rhinochicago.com", "type": "location", "title": "Office locations" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://rush.edu/treatments/rhinoplasty-surgery", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rush rhinoplasty procedure and treatment information" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://rush.edu/services/rhinoplasty/rhinoplasty-providers", "domain": "rush.edu", "type": "treatment", "title": "Official list of rhinoplasty surgeons" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://uchicagomedicine.org/find-a-physician/physician/joseph-meleca", "domain": "uchicagomedicine.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Joseph Meleca" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 12, "url": "https://uchicagomedicine.org/find-a-physician/physician/antonios-varelas", "domain": "uchicagomedicine.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Antonios Varelas" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 13, "url": "https://uchicagomedicine.org/find-a-physician/physician/anil-r-shah", "domain": "uchicagomedicine.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Anil Shah" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 14, "url": "https://nm.org/doctors/1730179482/douglas-m-sidle-md", "domain": "nm.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Sidle's official Northwestern Medicine profile" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 15, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/about-us", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "TLKM facility information" }, { "observation": "O176", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 16, "url": "https://maeplasticsurgery.com/about-us/our-facilities", "domain": "maeplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "MAE facility information" }, { "observation": "O177", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://chicagofaceliftsurgeon.com/", "domain": "chicagofaceliftsurgeon.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Facelift Surgery | Chicago Facelift Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O177", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://maeplasticsurgery.com/face/facelift", "domain": "maeplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "North Shore Chicago Facelift | Northbrook Rhytidectomy" }, { "observation": "O177", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/facelift-chicago-aesthetics", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Chicago | Chicago Breast And Body Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O177", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/chicago", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Find a Chicago Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O178", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdaemNUQndOREo2GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Warner Aesthetic & Reconstructive Institute" }, { "observation": "O178", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdoaWVEZG1NdxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "John Kim, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O178", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdjemVuY3djbXBrGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O178", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdNMU5HUm9jRFpuGAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Bloom Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O178", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHRIbCgNwdnESFENnMHZaeTh4TVdSZmVqZzROSEk0GAo", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Sammy Sinno, MD" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/facelift", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Surgery in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/thomas-a-mustoe-md-facs-chicago-5?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Thomas A. Mustoe, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/hudson-facial-plastic-surgery-chicago?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Hudson Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/maps/place?q=place_id%3AChIJ99cEa1jTD4gRws51m1Eyf60&hl=en", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "That Face Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://google.com/maps/place?q=place_id%3AChIJ5VhjpaUsDogRnQNgv4y3YPM&hl=en", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Benjamin Caughlin, MD, FACS: Double Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/parit-patel-md.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Parit A. Patel, MD" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://pscofchicago.com/facelift-plastic-surgery-chicago", "domain": "pscofchicago.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift (Rhytidectomy)" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/douglas-sidle-md-northwestern-medicine-chicago-2?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Dr. Douglas M. Sidle, MD" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://certificationmatters.org/", "domain": "certificationmatters.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Medical Specialties" }, { "observation": "O179", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Society of Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O180", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://us-uk.bookimed.com/clinics/country=united-states/city=chicago/procedure=tightening-of-facial-skin-facelift/best", "domain": "us-uk.bookimed.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "TOP 10+ Best Facelift Clinics in Chicago 2026 - Bookimed" }, { "observation": "O180", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/mustoe-facelift", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Renowned Deep Plane Facelift Surgeon in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O180", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://hudsonfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "hudsonfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Hudson Facial Plastic Surgery - Deep Plane Facelift Chicago" }, { "observation": "O180", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O180", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drbuccalfat.com/top-9-chicago-plastic-surgeons", "domain": "drbuccalfat.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top-Rated Chicago Facial Plastic Surgeons | 2026 Expert Aesthetic" }, { "observation": "O180", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://chicagocosmeticsurgery.com/", "domain": "chicagocosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Cosmetic Surgery & Plastic Surgeon Chicago - Dr Michael BYUN" }, { "observation": "O181", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Facial Plastic Surgeon Chicago | Facial Plastic Surgery in ..." }, { "observation": "O181", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://pscofchicago.com/facelift-plastic-surgery-chicago", "domain": "pscofchicago.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift (Rhytidectomy) | Plastic Surgery Clinic of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O181", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/facial-plastic-surgery-chicago/buccal-fat-removal", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Buccal Fat Removal Chicago | Gold Coast Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O181", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/non-surgical/injectables/radiesse", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Radiesse Injections Chicago" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://pscofchicago.com/facelift-plastic-surgery-chicago", "domain": "pscofchicago.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift procedure and surgical information" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/parit-patel-md.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Patel's American Society of Plastic Surgeons profile" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://maeplasticsurgery.com/face/facelift", "domain": "maeplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift surgery and facility details" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://chicagoaesthetics.com/cosmetic-surgery/facelift", "domain": "chicagoaesthetics.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift surgery and operating facility" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://chicagofaceliftsurgeon.com/", "domain": "chicagofaceliftsurgeon.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Facelift surgery and practice information" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://hfsrb.illinois.gov/content/dam/soi/en/web/hfsrb/projects/projectdocuments/2025-/25-028-sozo-surgery-center%2C-llc/2025-07-29%2025-028%20Sozo%20SC%20CON%20Application.pdf", "domain": "hfsrb.illinois.gov", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Illinois Health Facilities and Services Review Board documentation" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/face-surgery-chicago/facelift-chicago", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift surgery details" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/about", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Surgical facility and hospital information" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Whole Beauty® Institute | Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://aestheticinstitutechicago.com/face/lift", "domain": "aestheticinstitutechicago.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Facelift procedure" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://aestheticinstitutechicago.com/our-practice/our-quad-a-accredited-surgical-facility", "domain": "aestheticinstitutechicago.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Quad A-accredited operating facility" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 12, "url": "https://drgutowski.com/procedures/face/facelift-chicago-il", "domain": "drgutowski.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift procedure and surgical details" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 13, "url": "https://theaestheticsociety.org/select-surgeon/karol-gutowski-md", "domain": "theaestheticsociety.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "The Aesthetic Society surgeon profile" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 14, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/hudson-facial-plastic-surgery-chicago?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Hudson Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 15, "url": "https://google.com/maps/place?q=place_id%3AChIJ99cEa1jTD4gRws51m1Eyf60&hl=en", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "That Face Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 16, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/michael-byun-md-chicago-cosmetic-surgery-chicago-2?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Michael Byun MD" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 17, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/douglas-sidle-md-northwestern-medicine-chicago-2?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Dr. Douglas M. Sidle, MD" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 18, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/john-kim-md-facs-northwestern-memorial-hospital-chicago?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "John Kim, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 19, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/cosmetic-procedures/facelift/surgeon", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "ASPS – Choosing a facelift surgeon" }, { "observation": "O182", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 20, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/patient-safety?sub=Accredited+Facilities", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "ASPS – Accredited surgical facilities and patient safety" }, { "observation": "O183", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://chicagoaesthetics.com/about/our-facility", "domain": "chicagoaesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Our Facility | Chicago Aesthetics Surgery & Med Spa" }, { "observation": "O183", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://enhance-face.com/", "domain": "enhance-face.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgery Center, LLC | Stacie D. McClane, M.D." }, { "observation": "O183", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://hudsonfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "hudsonfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Hudson Facial Plastic Surgery - Deep Plane Facelift Chicago" }, { "observation": "O183", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://cscchicago.com/", "domain": "cscchicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Cosmetic Surgery Center of Chicago" }, { "observation": "O183", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Facial-Plastic-Surgeon", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facial Plastic Surgeons in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O183", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://aestheticinstitutechicago.com/", "domain": "aestheticinstitutechicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Aesthetic Institute of Chicago: Plastic Surgery in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O183", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Voted #1 Plastic Surgery Chicago | Breast & Body Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O184", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://northwesternplasticsurgery.com/facial-procedures-chicago/facelift", "domain": "northwesternplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Chicago - Rhytidectomy Chicago" }, { "observation": "O184", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://goldcoastplasticsurgery.com/facelift", "domain": "goldcoastplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift in Chicago | Gold Coast Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O184", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://thatfacechicago.com/face/face-facelift", "domain": "thatfacechicago.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift in Chicago | That Face Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O184", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://hudsonfacialplastics.com/", "domain": "hudsonfacialplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Hudson Facial Plastic Surgery - Deep Plane Facelift Chicago" }, { "observation": "O184", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://chicagoaesthetics.com/about/our-facility", "domain": "chicagoaesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Our Facility | Chicago Aesthetics Surgery & Med Spa" }, { "observation": "O184", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drthomasmustoe.com/facial-plastic-surgery/facelift", "domain": "drthomasmustoe.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Surgery in Chicago, IL – TLKM Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/John-Kim.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "John Y.S. Kim, MD" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/maps/place?q=place_id%3AChIJ8yaYSKssDogRRsycqS-R0m0&hl=en", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Northwestern Medicine Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Practice" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://northwesternplastics.com/", "domain": "northwesternplastics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/chicago-breast-augmentation.html?section=specials", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Clark F. Schierle MD PhD FACS, MD, PhD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/Peter-Geldner-MD.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Peter D. Geldner, MD" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/city/chicago/www1.plasticsurgery.org/psmatch/fileapi/for-medical-professionals", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Find a Chicago Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/md/gregory-wiener-md.html", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Gregory A. Wiener, MD" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/cosmetic-procedures/breast-augmentation/surgeon", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Choosing a Plastic Surgeon for Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/documents/holidays/2024/Surgeon-Checklist.pdf", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "ASPS Surgeon Credentials Checklist" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Board of Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O185", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "ASPS surgeon directory" }, { "observation": "O186", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Voted #1 Plastic Surgery Chicago | Breast & Body Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O186", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Illinois/Chicago/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Chicago, IL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O186", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://bodysculptor.com/", "domain": "bodysculptor.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgeon: Top Plastic Surgery Center in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O186", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/breast-surgery-chicago", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Surgery | Chicago, Winnetka | Dr. John Q. Cook" }, { "observation": "O186", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Plastic Surgery Chicago | Dr. Horn" }, { "observation": "O186", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/breast-surgery-chicago/breast-augmentation", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation | Dr. John Q. Cook | Chicago" }, { "observation": "O188", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Plastic Surgery Chicago | Dr. Horn" }, { "observation": "O188", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://m.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Breast+Augmentation&find_loc=Chicago%2C+IL", "domain": "m.yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "TOP 10 BEST Breast Augmentation in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O189", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/breast-surgery-chicago/breast-augmentation", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation | Dr. John Q. Cook | Chicago" }, { "observation": "O189", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://chicagobreastandbody.com/", "domain": "chicagobreastandbody.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Voted #1 Plastic Surgery Chicago | Breast & Body Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O189", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drkimsurgery.com/procedures/breast-surgery/breast-augmentation", "domain": "drkimsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Enhancement Chicago, IL - Breast Augmentation by Dr. Kim" }, { "observation": "O189", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://bodysculptor.com/", "domain": "bodysculptor.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Chicago Plastic Surgeon: Top Plastic Surgery Center in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O189", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Plastic Surgery Chicago | Dr. Horn" }, { "observation": "O189", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://northwesternplasticsurgery.com/breast-procedures-chicago/breast-augmentation", "domain": "northwesternplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Chicago - Northwestern Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O189", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://aestheticinstitutechicago.com/", "domain": "aestheticinstitutechicago.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Aesthetic Institute of Chicago: Plastic Surgery in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O189", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://johnqcookmd.com/surgery/breast-surgery-chicago", "domain": "johnqcookmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Breast Surgery | Chicago, Winnetka | Dr. John Q. Cook" }, { "observation": "O190", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://m.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Cosmetic+Surgery&find_loc=Chicago%2C+IL", "domain": "m.yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "TOP 10 BEST Cosmetic Surgery in Chicago, IL" }, { "observation": "O190", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://alphasophia.com/directory/top/top-plastic-surgery-clinics-and-practices-in-chicago", "domain": "alphasophia.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top Plastic Surgery Centers and Practices in Chicago" }, { "observation": "O190", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdoaWVEZG1NdxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "John Kim, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O190", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdkM2MzYzBiURgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Otto Placik | Chicago Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O190", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4Y0hBeWQxOXJhbXcYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "The Art of Plastic Surgery: Gregory A. Wiener, MD FACS" }, { "observation": "O190", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4Y0hkbVpEZzFlV3cYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Shifrin Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O191", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Chicago Plastic Surgeon | Plastic Surgery Chicago | Dr. Horn" }, { "observation": "O191", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com/blog/how-much-do-motiva-breast-implants-cost-in-chicago", "domain": "lakeshoreplasticsurgery.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Motiva Breast Implant Cost in Chicago | Dr. Horn" }, { "observation": "O192", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nikichristopoulosmd.com/aesthetic-surgery-procedures/breast-surgery/breast-augmentation", "domain": "nikichristopoulosmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Procedure and facility evidence" }, { "observation": "O192", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://drgikas.com/", "domain": "drgikas.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice and procedure information" }, { "observation": "O192", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://cclscosmetic.com/breast/breast-augmentation/procedure", "domain": "cclscosmetic.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facility and procedure evidence" }, { "observation": "O192", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Society of Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O193", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/nose-surgery", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Nose Surgery Miami (Rhinoplasty) Expert Nose Surgery & Reshaping" }, { "observation": "O193", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://gallomd.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "gallomd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Nose Job in Miami | Nose Surgery Expert" }, { "observation": "O193", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty in Miami - Dr. Carlos Wolf" }, { "observation": "O193", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drbustillo.com/cosmetic-procedures/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drbustillo.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami, FL | Nose Surgery | Andres Bustillo, MD, FACS" }, { "observation": "O193", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O193", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://facialplasticsurgerymiami.com/plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "facialplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Miami, FL | Nose Surgery - Dr. Anthony Bared" }, { "observation": "O193", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://thesecretplasticsurgery.com/face-plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty-miami", "domain": "thesecretplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami - The Secret Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O193", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://lampertmd.com/about/joshua-lampert-md", "domain": "lampertmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Plastic Surgeon Miami | Dr. Joshua Lampert" }, { "observation": "O193", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://aestheticmatch.com/blog/miami/rhinoplasty-nose-job-cost-in-miami-guide", "domain": "aestheticmatch.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Rhinoplasty (Nose Job) Cost in Miami (2025 Guide)" }, { "observation": "O194", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty in Miami - Dr. Carlos Wolf" }, { "observation": "O194", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSHBIaCgNwdnESE0Nnd3ZaeTh4YUdNeVptUjVjRFkYCg", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami: Dr. Marcelo Ghersi" }, { "observation": "O194", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-jennifer-l-harb-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/dr/anthony-bared-miami-fl", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Anthony Bared, MD, FACS, Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon | Real Patient Reviews, Before & After Photos, Expert Answers" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/anthony-bared-m-d-facial-plastic-surgery-miami?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Dr. Anthony Bared, MD, FACS - Hair Restoration & Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://aafprs.org/profile?id=18626", "domain": "aafprs.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Profile" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://google.com/maps/place?q=place_id%3AChIJLW1J2WOs2YgRBMf6mBYzx0g&hl=en", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Dr. Kim Patrick Murray, MD" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/?city=Miami&state=FL", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "Find a Miami Plastic Surgeon Near Me" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://yelp.com/biz/carlos-l-wolf-md-miami?adjust_creative=openai", "domain": "yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Dr. Carlos L. Wolf, MD" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://google.com/maps/place/Z+Face+Plastic+Surgery:+Dr.+Ruslan+Zhuravsky/@25.9615003,-80.143328,17z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m6!3m5!1s0x89c3d56b83954a31:0x4bb2ba22c74dff4e!8m2!3d25.9615003!4d-80.143328!16s%2Fg%2F11h2fj1vx2?hl=en&entry=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI2MTAxOS4wIKXMDSoASAFQAw%3D%3D", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Z Face Plastic Surgery: Dr. Ruslan Zhuravsky" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://beautyvetted.com/cities/miami", "domain": "beautyvetted.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic surgeons in Miami, FL: compare credentials" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS)" }, { "observation": "O195", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://aafprs.org/", "domain": "aafprs.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery" }, { "observation": "O196", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O196", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://miamivibesmag.com/post/the-top-rated-rhinoplasty-surgeons-in-miami", "domain": "miamivibesmag.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The Top-Rated Rhinoplasty Surgeons in Miami" }, { "observation": "O196", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami FL - Voted Best Nose Surgeon - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O196", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://ensoplasticsurgery.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "ensoplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami, FL | Nose Plastic Surgery Miami" }, { "observation": "O196", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://aeris.co/reviews", "domain": "aeris.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Reviews Miami, FL | Marcelo Ghersi, MD" }, { "observation": "O196", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/South-Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in South Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O197", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://lampertmd.com/about/our-facility", "domain": "lampertmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Our Facility | Dr. Joshua Lampert" }, { "observation": "O197", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Rhinoplasty in Miami - Dr. Carlos Wolf" }, { "observation": "O197", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/locations", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "location", "title": "Conveniently Located Cosmetic Service Centers in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O197", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-stephan-baker-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Free Consultation" }, { "observation": "O197", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://google.com/searchviewer/10?svid=CAwSGxIZCgNwdnESEkNnc3ZaeTh4ZEdRMFptSjVhdxgK", "domain": "google.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Stephan Baker MD FACS" }, { "observation": "O198", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drgcosmeticsurgery.com/rhinoplasty-nose", "domain": "drgcosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty and surgical facility details" }, { "observation": "O198", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/our-office/meet-dr-ary-krau", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Meet Dr. Krau and practice information" }, { "observation": "O198", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://drbaker.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drbaker.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Miami" }, { "observation": "O198", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://ensoplasticsurgery.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "ensoplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Enso rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O198", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://gablesplasticsurgery.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "gablesplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Gables Plastic Surgery – Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O198", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drzaydon.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "drzaydon.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty and participating hospitals" }, { "observation": "O198", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://theaestheticsociety.org/select-surgeon/tal-t-roudner-md", "domain": "theaestheticsociety.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "The Aesthetic Society – Dr. Tal Roudner" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/locations", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "location", "title": "Conveniently Located Cosmetic Service Centers in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://umiamihealth.org/en/treatments-and-services/plastic-surgery/facial-cosmetic-procedures", "domain": "umiamihealth.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facial Cosmetic Procedures | University of Miami Health System" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://drwolfrhinoplasty.com/", "domain": "drwolfrhinoplasty.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Carlos Wolf, MD - Rhinoplasty Miami / Nose Surgery" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://miamisurgicalcenter.com/", "domain": "miamisurgicalcenter.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Surgical Center Cosmetic" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://aeris.co/", "domain": "aeris.co", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Plastic Surgeons Miami | Aeris" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://lampertmd.com/about/our-facility", "domain": "lampertmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Our Facility | Dr. Joshua Lampert" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 9, "url": "https://thesecretplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "thesecretplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "The Secret Plastic Surgery: Miami Plastic Surgery Center" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 10, "url": "https://hmsplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "hmsplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami FL Plastic Surgery | Fort Lauderdale Facelift, Rhinoplasty" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 11, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Rhinoplasty", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Rhinoplasty Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 12, "url": "https://ensoplasticsurgery.com/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "ensoplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami, FL | Nose Plastic Surgery Miami" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 13, "url": "https://drkmiamiplasticsurgery.com/list-plastic-surgeons-in-miami", "domain": "drkmiamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "List of Top 10 Plastic Surgeons in Miami" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 14, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/rhinoplasty", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami FL - Voted Best Nose Surgeon - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 15, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgeons/dr-carlos-wolf", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Miami Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon | Dr. Carlos Wolf" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 16, "url": "https://zfaceplasticsurgery.com/facial-plastic-surgery-miami/rhinoplasty", "domain": "zfaceplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty In Miami | Dr. Z Is A Miami Nose Specialist" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 17, "url": "https://miamirhinoplastyspecialist.com/", "domain": "miamirhinoplastyspecialist.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Kim Patrick Murray, MD - Rhinoplasty / Nose Job/ Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 18, "url": "https://dranthonybared.com/rhinoplasty", "domain": "dranthonybared.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty in Miami | Rinoplastia - Dr. Anthony Bared, M.D., F.A.C.S." }, { "observation": "O199", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 19, "url": "https://lampertmd.com/about/joshua-lampert-md", "domain": "lampertmd.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Best Plastic Surgeon Miami | Dr. Joshua Lampert" }, { "observation": "O200", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Spectrum Aesthetics: Premier Plastic Surgery in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O200", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://aeris.co/", "domain": "aeris.co", "type": "homepage", "title": "Top Plastic Surgeons Miami | Aeris" }, { "observation": "O200", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://aeris.co/about/jacob-carlson-md", "domain": "aeris.co", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Jacob Carlson, MD" }, { "observation": "O200", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://aeris.co/about/meet-our-fellow", "domain": "aeris.co", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Meet Our Fellow Miami, FL | Aeris" }, { "observation": "O200", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://aeris.co/plastic-surgeons-miami-fl/face/rhinoplasty", "domain": "aeris.co", "type": "treatment", "title": "Rhinoplasty Miami, FL | Dr. Marcelo Ghersi" }, { "observation": "O200", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/dr-oliver-chang", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Dr. Oliver Chang, MD Double Board-Certified Miami Plastic ..." }, { "observation": "O200", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://spectrum-aesthetics.com/about-us", "domain": "spectrum-aesthetics.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Plastic Surgery Clinic in Miami ... - About Spectrum Aesthetics" }, { "observation": "O201", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://find.plasticsurgery.org/?city=Miami&state=FL", "domain": "find.plasticsurgery.org", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami surgeon directory" }, { "observation": "O201", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/documents/holidays/2024/Do-It-For-You.pdf", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "ASPS Do It For You E-Book" }, { "observation": "O202", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://gvplasticsurgery.com/facelift-guide-from-best-facelift-plastic-surgeon", "domain": "gvplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "The best facelift plastic surgeon in Miami's - Doctor George Varkarakis" }, { "observation": "O202", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/miami-facelift-surgeon", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami FL - Voted Best Facelift Surgeon - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O202", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://edenplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "edenplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Facelift Plastic Surgery | Fort Lauderdale Facelift Specialist" }, { "observation": "O202", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Facelift", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O202", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Facelift-Revision", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Facelift Revision Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O202", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drbustillo.com/", "domain": "drbustillo.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Bustillo | Miami's Leader in Facial Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O202", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://zuriplasticsurgery.com/face/facelift", "domain": "zuriplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Facelift Miami | Zuri Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O202", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://drpaulafrooz.com/face/facelift-miami", "domain": "drpaulafrooz.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami, FL | Expert Facelift Surgeon Dr. Paul Afrooz" }, { "observation": "O203", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://drcastrellon.com/top-facial-plastic-surgery-procedures-miami", "domain": "drcastrellon.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Top 5 Most Popular Facial Plastic Surgery Procedures" }, { "observation": "O203", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://m.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Plastic+Surgeon+Face&find_loc=Miami%2C+FL", "domain": "m.yelp.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "TOP 10 BEST Plastic Surgeon Face in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O203", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://smartplasticsurgerymiami.com/best-plastic-surgeon-for-a-facelift-in-miami", "domain": "smartplasticsurgerymiami.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "How to choose the best plastic surgeon for a face lift in Miami" }, { "observation": "O203", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://community.realself.com/forum/face-lift-miami", "domain": "community.realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Face Lift Miami - Facelift forum" }, { "observation": "O203", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://nidiadejesusmd.com/facelift-miami-cost-types", "domain": "nidiadejesusmd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift in Miami: Types, Cost, and Recovery in 2026" }, { "observation": "O203", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/facelift-miami", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami - From $3800 (Neck Lift) - Icon Cosmetic Center" }, { "observation": "O205", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://zionmiami.com/", "domain": "zionmiami.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Zion Plastic Surgery: Plastic Surgery in Kendall, Miami" }, { "observation": "O205", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Icon Cosmetic Center: Best Cosmetic Surgery Center Miami" }, { "observation": "O205", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://edenplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "edenplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Facelift Plastic Surgery | Fort Lauderdale Facelift Specialist" }, { "observation": "O205", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://drkmiamiplasticsurgery.com/list-plastic-surgeons-in-miami", "domain": "drkmiamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "List of Top 10 Plastic Surgeons in Miami" }, { "observation": "O205", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://miamilifecosmetic.com/surgeon/dr-nassif-soueid-m-d", "domain": "miamilifecosmetic.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Dr. Nassif Soueid, M.D – Miami Life Cosmetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O205", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://umiamihealth.org/en/treatments-and-services/ear,-nose,-and-throat-(ent)/facial-plastic-and-reconstructive-surgery", "domain": "umiamihealth.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery | University of Miami" }, { "observation": "O205", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://drhanabergh.com/", "domain": "drhanabergh.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Enrique Hanabergh, MD - Board Certified Plastic Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O205", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/miami-facelift-surgeon", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami FL - Voted Best Facelift Surgeon - Dr. Ary Krau, MD" }, { "observation": "O206", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "CG Cosmetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O206", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-stephan-baker-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Facelift" }, { "observation": "O206", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/facelift-miami", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami - From $3800 (Neck Lift) - Icon Cosmetic Center" }, { "observation": "O207", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/facial-plastic-surgery/miami-facelift-surgeon", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Facelift Miami FL" }, { "observation": "O207", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/face/facelift/deep-plane-facelifts", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Deep Plane Facelifts" }, { "observation": "O207", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Expert Plastic Surgery in Miami, FL | Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O207", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/locations", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "location", "title": "Conveniently Located Cosmetic Service Centers in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O207", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://tebra.com/care/provider/ernest-digeronimo-md-1346450392?lid=849190020", "domain": "tebra.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Facelift" }, { "observation": "O207", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://tebra.com/care/practice/digeronimo-md-advanced-plastic-surgery-204332?lid=849190020", "domain": "tebra.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Facelift" }, { "observation": "O209", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "CG Cosmetic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O209", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://arykraumd.com/", "domain": "arykraumd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Plastic Surgery Miami FL - Voted Best Plastic Surgeon Miami" }, { "observation": "O209", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O209", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://gablesplasticsurgery.com/breast/breast-augmentation", "domain": "gablesplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Best Breast Augmentation in Miami, FL | Gables Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O209", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://iconcosmeticcenter.com/breast-augmentation-miami", "domain": "iconcosmeticcenter.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Miami with Implants $2,699 | Icon Cosmetic Center" }, { "observation": "O209", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://therealdrmiami.com/", "domain": "therealdrmiami.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Dr. Miami | Plastic Surgery in Miami" }, { "observation": "O209", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://facebook.com/therealdrmiami/videos/dr-miami-testimonialmeet-our-wonderful-patient-ashley-she-wanted-more-volume-in-/1018429607940158", "domain": "facebook.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Why Ashley Chose Dr. Miami for Breast Augmentation and Lift" }, { "observation": "O209", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://booking.pabau.com/briaplasticsurgeryllc/online-bookings?location=24076&withGoogle=true&source=google&groupCategory=16155&category=195964&services=3589218", "domain": "booking.pabau.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "S01 Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O210", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O210", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/jeremy-white-md-559210?LocIdent=300669&entity_id=pr_n-hhs-ZljEiJYHIjSm5i6Q-lo_igAN4N3WwUCQwIrJSwJqNx-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O210", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://booking.pabau.com/briaplasticsurgeryllc/online-bookings?location=24076&withGoogle=true&source=google&groupCategory=16155&category=195964&services=3589218", "domain": "booking.pabau.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "S01 Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O210", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://booking.pabau.com/briaplasticsurgeryllc/online-bookings?location=24076&withGoogle=true&source=google&groupCategory=16155&category=195965&services=3591702", "domain": "booking.pabau.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "D14:Breast Augmentation + Bbl" }, { "observation": "O211", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/public/verify-certification/VerifyCert?section=SurgeonSearch", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "ABPS certification directory" }, { "observation": "O211", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://plasticsurgery.org/cosmetic-procedures/breast-augmentation/surgeon", "domain": "plasticsurgery.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Choosing a Plastic Surgeon for Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O211", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://abplasticsurgery.org/ModDefault.aspx?section=PubFind", "domain": "abplasticsurgery.org", "type": "unclassified", "title": "ABPlasticSurgery.org" }, { "observation": "O211", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://fda.gov/medical-devices/breast-implants/risks-and-complications-breast-implants", "domain": "fda.gov", "type": "treatment", "title": "Risks and Complications of Breast Implants" }, { "observation": "O211", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/what-know-about-breast-implants", "domain": "fda.gov", "type": "treatment", "title": "What to Know About Breast Implants" }, { "observation": "O211", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://fda.gov/medical-devices/breast-implants/things-consider-getting-breast-implants", "domain": "fda.gov", "type": "treatment", "title": "Things to Consider Before Getting Breast Implants" }, { "observation": "O212", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://avanaplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "avanaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Avana Plastic Surgery | Best Cosmetic Surgery in Miami" }, { "observation": "O212", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O212", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O212", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://sveltaplasticsurgery.com/", "domain": "sveltaplasticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Svelta Plastic Surgery: Leading Plastic Surgery Miami" }, { "observation": "O212", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Breast-Implants", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Implants Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O212", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://realself.com/find/Florida/Miami/Breast-Augmentation", "domain": "realself.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Top Breast Augmentation Doctors in Miami, FL - RealSelf.com" }, { "observation": "O212", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://garyrosenbaummd.com/testimonials/plastic-surgeon/dr-gary-j-rosenbaum", "domain": "garyrosenbaummd.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Reviews for Miami Beach, FL Plastic Surgeon Dr. Gary J. Rosenbaum" }, { "observation": "O212", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 8, "url": "https://drgcosmeticsurgery.com/patient-reviews", "domain": "drgcosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "Patient Reviews – Plastic Surgery - Miami" }, { "observation": "O213", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/surgical-services/breast-chest/breast-augmentation", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Miami Breast Implants | Miami Plastic Surgery" }, { "observation": "O213", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://alluringplasticsurgery.com/blog/board-certified-plastic-surgeon-miami", "domain": "alluringplasticsurgery.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Board Certified Plastic Surgeon Miami: Choose Safely" }, { "observation": "O214", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://nathanclinic.com/", "domain": "nathanclinic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O214", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://roudnermd.com/", "domain": "roudnermd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O214", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://craftcosmeticsurgery.com/", "domain": "craftcosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Practice website" }, { "observation": "O215", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://miamiplasticsurgery.com/locations", "domain": "miamiplasticsurgery.com", "type": "location", "title": "Conveniently Located Cosmetic Service Centers in Miami, FL" }, { "observation": "O215", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://umiamihealth.org/en/treatments-and-services/plastic-surgery", "domain": "umiamihealth.org", "type": "treatment", "title": "Plastic Surgery | University of Miami Health System" }, { "observation": "O215", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Plastic Surgery Center, Top Plastic Surgeons" }, { "observation": "O215", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://xiluetaestheticsurgery.com/breast-augmentation", "domain": "xiluetaestheticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Top-Rated Breast Augmentation Miami | 10+ Years Experience" }, { "observation": "O215", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 5, "url": "https://lhochsteinmd.com/", "domain": "lhochsteinmd.com", "type": "homepage", "title": "Miami Florida Plastic Surgeon | Leonard M. Hochstein M.D." }, { "observation": "O215", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 6, "url": "https://drgcosmeticsurgery.com/breast-implants-augmentation", "domain": "drgcosmeticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation Miami - Top Breast Implant Surgeon" }, { "observation": "O215", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 7, "url": "https://chriscraftplasticsurgery.com/breast-augmentation", "domain": "chriscraftplasticsurgery.com", "type": "treatment", "title": "Breast Augmentation & Implants in Miami" }, { "observation": "O216", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 1, "url": "https://cgcosmetic.com/blog/2017/09/26/plastic-surgery-and-breast-augmentation-miami", "domain": "cgcosmetic.com", "type": "editorial", "title": "Plastic Surgery and Breast Augmentation in Miami" }, { "observation": "O216", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 2, "url": "https://booking.pabau.com/briaplasticsurgeryllc/online-bookings?location=24076&withGoogle=true&source=google&groupCategory=16155&category=195964&services=3589218", "domain": "booking.pabau.com", "type": "unclassified", "title": "S01 Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O216", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 3, "url": "https://navmds.com/doctor/dr-michael-stefan-md", "domain": "navmds.com", "type": "practitioner_team", "title": "Breast Augmentation" }, { "observation": "O216", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "sourceOrder": 4, "url": "https://zocdoc.com/doctor/baruch-jacobs-md-51502?LocIdent=35461&entity_id=pr_8-hHadu8_k-IFXY5lEiqdx-lo_DY8jD5yvvUOFRKCQ404F8R-entity", "domain": "zocdoc.com", "type": "directory_social", "title": "Breast Augmentation" } ], "withinPairs": [ { "pair": "W001", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O001", "observationB": "O076", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1, "domainJaccard": 0.2857142857142857, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W002", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O001", "observationB": "O147", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W003", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O076", "observationB": "O147", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W004", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O002", "observationB": "O073", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3, "domainJaccard": 0.2222222222222222, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W005", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O002", "observationB": "O148", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.36363636363636365, "domainJaccard": 0.3, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W006", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O073", "observationB": "O148", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.4, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W007", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O003", "observationB": "O074", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.7142857142857143, "domainJaccard": 0.6666666666666666, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W008", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O003", "observationB": "O145", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W009", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O074", "observationB": "O145", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W010", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O004", "observationB": "O075", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 1, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W011", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O004", "observationB": "O146", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W012", "queryCell": "P01", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O075", "observationB": "O146", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W013", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O008", "observationB": "O079", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W014", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O008", "observationB": "O150", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W015", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O079", "observationB": "O150", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W016", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O005", "observationB": "O080", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.13333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.21428571428571427, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "W017", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O005", "observationB": "O151", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.45454545454545453, "domainJaccard": 0.6, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W018", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O080", "observationB": "O151", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3076923076923077, "domainJaccard": 0.3076923076923077, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W019", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O006", "observationB": "O077", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W020", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O006", "observationB": "O152", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "W021", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O077", "observationB": "O152", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.45454545454545453, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "W022", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O007", "observationB": "O078", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W023", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O007", "observationB": "O149", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W024", "queryCell": "P02", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O078", "observationB": "O149", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W025", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O011", "observationB": "O082", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 15, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 11, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W026", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O011", "observationB": "O153", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "domainJaccard": 0.15384615384615385, "urlsA": 15, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 11, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W027", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O082", "observationB": "O153", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W028", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O012", "observationB": "O083", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.21428571428571427, "domainJaccard": 0.36363636363636365, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W029", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O012", "observationB": "O154", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.4444444444444444, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W030", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O083", "observationB": "O154", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W031", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O009", "observationB": "O084", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W032", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O009", "observationB": "O155", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "domainJaccard": 0.3, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W033", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O084", "observationB": "O155", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W034", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O010", "observationB": "O081", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W035", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O010", "observationB": "O156", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W036", "queryCell": "P03", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O081", "observationB": "O156", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W037", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O014", "observationB": "O085", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 2, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W038", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O014", "observationB": "O160", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 2, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W039", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O085", "observationB": "O160", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 2, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W040", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O015", "observationB": "O086", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.625, "domainJaccard": 0.625, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W041", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O015", "observationB": "O157", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07692307692307693, "domainJaccard": 0.18181818181818182, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W042", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O086", "observationB": "O157", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.15384615384615385, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W043", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O016", "observationB": "O087", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W044", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O016", "observationB": "O158", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 1, "domainJaccard": 1, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W045", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O087", "observationB": "O158", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W046", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O013", "observationB": "O088", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W047", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O013", "observationB": "O159", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.5, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W048", "queryCell": "P04", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O088", "observationB": "O159", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W049", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O017", "observationB": "O092", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W050", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O017", "observationB": "O163", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W051", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O092", "observationB": "O163", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W052", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O018", "observationB": "O089", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W053", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O018", "observationB": "O164", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W054", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O089", "observationB": "O164", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "domainJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W055", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O019", "observationB": "O090", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W056", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O019", "observationB": "O161", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W057", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O090", "observationB": "O161", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W058", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O020", "observationB": "O091", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W059", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O020", "observationB": "O162", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W060", "queryCell": "P05", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O091", "observationB": "O162", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W061", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O024", "observationB": "O095", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W062", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O024", "observationB": "O166", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 2, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W063", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O095", "observationB": "O166", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W064", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O021", "observationB": "O096", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.23076923076923078, "domainJaccard": 0.45454545454545453, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W065", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O021", "observationB": "O167", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W066", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "gemini", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O096", "observationB": "O167", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.36363636363636365, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W067", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O022", "observationB": "O093", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W068", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O022", "observationB": "O168", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W069", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O093", "observationB": "O168", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W070", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O023", "observationB": "O094", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W071", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O023", "observationB": "O165", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W072", "queryCell": "P06", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O094", "observationB": "O165", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W073", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O027", "observationB": "O098", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W074", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O027", "observationB": "O169", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 15, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W075", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O098", "observationB": "O169", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 15, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W076", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O028", "observationB": "O099", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.5714285714285714, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W077", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O028", "observationB": "O170", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W078", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O099", "observationB": "O170", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "domainJaccard": 0.4444444444444444, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W079", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O025", "observationB": "O100", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W080", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O025", "observationB": "O171", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.07692307692307693, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "W081", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O100", "observationB": "O171", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.23076923076923078, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "W082", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O026", "observationB": "O097", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W083", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O026", "observationB": "O172", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W084", "queryCell": "P07", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O097", "observationB": "O172", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W085", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O030", "observationB": "O101", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 2, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W086", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O030", "observationB": "O176", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 16, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 11 }, { "pair": "W087", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O101", "observationB": "O176", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 16, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 11 }, { "pair": "W088", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O031", "observationB": "O102", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W089", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O031", "observationB": "O173", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W090", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O102", "observationB": "O173", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W091", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O032", "observationB": "O103", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.5, "domainJaccard": 0.625, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W092", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O032", "observationB": "O174", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W093", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O103", "observationB": "O174", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W094", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O029", "observationB": "O104", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W095", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O029", "observationB": "O175", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W096", "queryCell": "P08", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O104", "observationB": "O175", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W097", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O033", "observationB": "O108", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 12, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 10 }, { "pair": "W098", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O033", "observationB": "O179", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.15, "domainJaccard": 0.21428571428571427, "urlsA": 12, "urlsB": 11, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W099", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O108", "observationB": "O179", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.10526315789473684, "domainJaccard": 0.13333333333333333, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 11, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W100", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O034", "observationB": "O105", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W101", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O034", "observationB": "O180", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.375, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W102", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O105", "observationB": "O180", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.5, "domainJaccard": 0.5714285714285714, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W103", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O035", "observationB": "O106", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W104", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O035", "observationB": "O177", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W105", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O106", "observationB": "O177", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W106", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O036", "observationB": "O107", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.4, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W107", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O036", "observationB": "O178", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.5, "domainJaccard": 1, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W108", "queryCell": "P09", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O107", "observationB": "O178", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W109", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O040", "observationB": "O111", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 1, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W110", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O040", "observationB": "O182", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 20, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 12 }, { "pair": "W111", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O111", "observationB": "O182", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 1, "urlsB": 20, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 12 }, { "pair": "W112", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O037", "observationB": "O112", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "domainJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W113", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O037", "observationB": "O183", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "domainJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W114", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O112", "observationB": "O183", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W115", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O038", "observationB": "O109", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3, "domainJaccard": 0.4444444444444444, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W116", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O038", "observationB": "O184", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W117", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O109", "observationB": "O184", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.375, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W118", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O039", "observationB": "O110", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.5, "domainJaccard": 1, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W119", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O039", "observationB": "O181", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W120", "queryCell": "P10", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O110", "observationB": "O181", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W121", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O043", "observationB": "O114", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.10526315789473684, "domainJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 16, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 10 }, { "pair": "W122", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O043", "observationB": "O185", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "domainJaccard": 0.2857142857142857, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 11, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W123", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O114", "observationB": "O185", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08, "domainJaccard": 0.15384615384615385, "urlsA": 16, "urlsB": 11, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W124", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O044", "observationB": "O115", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.375, "domainJaccard": 0.42857142857142855, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W125", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O044", "observationB": "O186", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.375, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W126", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O115", "observationB": "O186", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.7142857142857143, "domainJaccard": 0.8333333333333334, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W127", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O041", "observationB": "O116", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.15384615384615385, "domainJaccard": 0.15384615384615385, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W128", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O041", "observationB": "O187", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W129", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O116", "observationB": "O187", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W130", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O042", "observationB": "O113", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W131", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O042", "observationB": "O188", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W132", "queryCell": "P11", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O113", "observationB": "O188", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W133", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O046", "observationB": "O117", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 13, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W134", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O046", "observationB": "O192", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W135", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O117", "observationB": "O192", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.0625, "domainJaccard": 0.2222222222222222, "urlsA": 13, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W136", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O047", "observationB": "O118", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "domainJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W137", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O047", "observationB": "O189", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.5555555555555556, "domainJaccard": 0.625, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W138", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O118", "observationB": "O189", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.45454545454545453, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W139", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O048", "observationB": "O119", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W140", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O048", "observationB": "O190", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W141", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O119", "observationB": "O190", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W142", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O045", "observationB": "O120", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 1, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W143", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O045", "observationB": "O191", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W144", "queryCell": "P12", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O120", "observationB": "O191", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 1, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W145", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O049", "observationB": "O124", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W146", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O049", "observationB": "O195", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.13333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 11, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W147", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O124", "observationB": "O195", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 11, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W148", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O050", "observationB": "O121", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.42857142857142855, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W149", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O050", "observationB": "O196", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.4444444444444444, "domainJaccard": 0.375, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W150", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O121", "observationB": "O196", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.375, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "W151", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O051", "observationB": "O122", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.75, "domainJaccard": 0.75, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W152", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O051", "observationB": "O193", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "W153", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O122", "observationB": "O193", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "W154", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O052", "observationB": "O123", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W155", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O052", "observationB": "O194", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W156", "queryCell": "P13", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O123", "observationB": "O194", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W157", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O056", "observationB": "O127", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W158", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O056", "observationB": "O198", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.13333333333333333, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W159", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O127", "observationB": "O198", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W160", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O053", "observationB": "O128", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.23076923076923078, "domainJaccard": 0.36363636363636365, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W161", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O053", "observationB": "O199", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "domainJaccard": 0.3157894736842105, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 19, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 17 }, { "pair": "W162", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O128", "observationB": "O199", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.18181818181818182, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 19, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 17 }, { "pair": "W163", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O054", "observationB": "O125", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.125, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W164", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O054", "observationB": "O200", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W165", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O125", "observationB": "O200", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.13333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W166", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O055", "observationB": "O126", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W167", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O055", "observationB": "O197", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W168", "queryCell": "P14", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O126", "observationB": "O197", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.5, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W169", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O059", "observationB": "O130", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W170", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O059", "observationB": "O201", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.6666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 1, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W171", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O130", "observationB": "O201", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W172", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O060", "observationB": "O131", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.13333333333333333, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W173", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O060", "observationB": "O202", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.13333333333333333, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W174", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O131", "observationB": "O202", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.45454545454545453, "domainJaccard": 0.5555555555555556, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W175", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O057", "observationB": "O132", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.3, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W176", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O057", "observationB": "O203", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.5555555555555556, "domainJaccard": 0.625, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W177", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O132", "observationB": "O203", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.4444444444444444, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W178", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O058", "observationB": "O129", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W179", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O058", "observationB": "O204", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W180", "queryCell": "P15", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O129", "observationB": "O204", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W181", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O062", "observationB": "O133", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 1, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W182", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O062", "observationB": "O208", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 2, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W183", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O133", "observationB": "O208", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 1, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "W184", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O063", "observationB": "O134", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "W185", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O063", "observationB": "O205", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "domainJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W186", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O134", "observationB": "O205", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.21428571428571427, "domainJaccard": 0.3076923076923077, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W187", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O064", "observationB": "O135", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "W188", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O064", "observationB": "O206", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W189", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O135", "observationB": "O206", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.125, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W190", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O061", "observationB": "O136", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W191", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O061", "observationB": "O207", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W192", "queryCell": "P16", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O136", "observationB": "O207", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W193", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O065", "observationB": "O140", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.5, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "W194", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O065", "observationB": "O211", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W195", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O140", "observationB": "O211", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W196", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O066", "observationB": "O137", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.36363636363636365, "domainJaccard": 0.5555555555555556, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W197", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O066", "observationB": "O212", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.45454545454545453, "domainJaccard": 0.5555555555555556, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W198", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O137", "observationB": "O212", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.36363636363636365, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W199", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O067", "observationB": "O138", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.4, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "W200", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O067", "observationB": "O209", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.18181818181818182, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W201", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O138", "observationB": "O209", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.0625, "domainJaccard": 0.13333333333333333, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "W202", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O068", "observationB": "O139", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W203", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O068", "observationB": "O210", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W204", "queryCell": "P17", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O139", "observationB": "O210", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W205", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O072", "observationB": "O143", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.038461538461538464, "domainJaccard": 0.0625, "urlsA": 24, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 14, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W206", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O072", "observationB": "O214", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 24, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 14, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W207", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "chatgpt", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O143", "observationB": "O214", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W208", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O069", "observationB": "O144", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.4, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W209", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O069", "observationB": "O215", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.4, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W210", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "gemini", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O144", "observationB": "O215", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.4, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "W211", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O070", "observationB": "O141", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W212", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O070", "observationB": "O216", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.6, "domainJaccard": 0.6, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W213", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_overviews", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O141", "observationB": "O216", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "W214", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 2, "observationA": "O071", "observationB": "O142", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "W215", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 1, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O071", "observationB": "O213", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "W216", "queryCell": "P18", "platform": "ai_mode", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "waveA": 2, "waveB": 3, "observationA": "O142", "observationB": "O213", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 2 } ], "crossPairs": [ { "pair": "X001", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O001", "observationB": "O002", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X002", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O001", "observationB": "O003", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X003", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O001", "observationB": "O004", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X004", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O002", "observationB": "O003", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07692307692307693, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X005", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O002", "observationB": "O004", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X006", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O003", "observationB": "O004", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X007", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O076", "observationB": "O073", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X008", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O076", "observationB": "O074", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X009", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O076", "observationB": "O075", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X010", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O073", "observationB": "O074", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.125, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X011", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O073", "observationB": "O075", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X012", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O074", "observationB": "O075", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X013", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O147", "observationB": "O148", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X014", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O147", "observationB": "O145", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X015", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O147", "observationB": "O146", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X016", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O148", "observationB": "O145", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X017", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O148", "observationB": "O146", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X018", "queryCell": "P01", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O145", "observationB": "O146", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X019", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O008", "observationB": "O005", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.05555555555555555, "domainJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X020", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O008", "observationB": "O006", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X021", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O008", "observationB": "O007", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X022", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O005", "observationB": "O006", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X023", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O005", "observationB": "O007", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X024", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O006", "observationB": "O007", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X025", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O079", "observationB": "O080", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X026", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O079", "observationB": "O077", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X027", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O079", "observationB": "O078", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X028", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O080", "observationB": "O077", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X029", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O080", "observationB": "O078", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X030", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O077", "observationB": "O078", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X031", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O150", "observationB": "O151", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X032", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O150", "observationB": "O152", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X033", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O150", "observationB": "O149", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X034", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O151", "observationB": "O152", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X035", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O151", "observationB": "O149", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X036", "queryCell": "P02", "city": "New York City", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O152", "observationB": "O149", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X037", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O011", "observationB": "O012", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.041666666666666664, "domainJaccard": 0.11764705882352941, "urlsA": 15, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 11, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X038", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O011", "observationB": "O009", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.05, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 15, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 11, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X039", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O011", "observationB": "O010", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 15, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 11, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X040", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O012", "observationB": "O009", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.18181818181818182, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X041", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O012", "observationB": "O010", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X042", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O009", "observationB": "O010", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X043", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O082", "observationB": "O083", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X044", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O082", "observationB": "O084", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X045", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O082", "observationB": "O081", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X046", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O083", "observationB": "O084", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X047", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O083", "observationB": "O081", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "domainJaccard": 0.125, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X048", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O084", "observationB": "O081", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X049", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O153", "observationB": "O154", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.125, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X050", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O153", "observationB": "O155", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X051", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O153", "observationB": "O156", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X052", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O154", "observationB": "O155", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X053", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O154", "observationB": "O156", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X054", "queryCell": "P03", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O155", "observationB": "O156", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X055", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O014", "observationB": "O015", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X056", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O014", "observationB": "O016", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X057", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O014", "observationB": "O013", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X058", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O015", "observationB": "O016", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X059", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O015", "observationB": "O013", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X060", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O016", "observationB": "O013", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.5, "domainJaccard": 0.6, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X061", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O085", "observationB": "O086", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X062", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O085", "observationB": "O087", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X063", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O085", "observationB": "O088", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X064", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O086", "observationB": "O087", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X065", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O086", "observationB": "O088", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X066", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O087", "observationB": "O088", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X067", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O160", "observationB": "O157", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X068", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O160", "observationB": "O158", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X069", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O160", "observationB": "O159", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X070", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O157", "observationB": "O158", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X071", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O157", "observationB": "O159", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X072", "queryCell": "P04", "city": "New York City", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O158", "observationB": "O159", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X073", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O017", "observationB": "O018", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X074", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O017", "observationB": "O019", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X075", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O017", "observationB": "O020", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X076", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O018", "observationB": "O019", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "domainJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X077", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O018", "observationB": "O020", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X078", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O019", "observationB": "O020", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X079", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O092", "observationB": "O089", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X080", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O092", "observationB": "O090", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X081", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O092", "observationB": "O091", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X082", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O089", "observationB": "O090", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X083", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O089", "observationB": "O091", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X084", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O090", "observationB": "O091", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X085", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O163", "observationB": "O164", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X086", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O163", "observationB": "O161", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X087", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O163", "observationB": "O162", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X088", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O164", "observationB": "O161", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.18181818181818182, "domainJaccard": 0.18181818181818182, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X089", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O164", "observationB": "O162", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X090", "queryCell": "P05", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O161", "observationB": "O162", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.125, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X091", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O024", "observationB": "O021", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X092", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O024", "observationB": "O022", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X093", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O024", "observationB": "O023", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X094", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O021", "observationB": "O022", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07692307692307693, "domainJaccard": 0.18181818181818182, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X095", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O021", "observationB": "O023", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X096", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O022", "observationB": "O023", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.125, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X097", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O095", "observationB": "O096", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X098", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O095", "observationB": "O093", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "domainJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X099", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O095", "observationB": "O094", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X100", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O096", "observationB": "O093", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.15384615384615385, "domainJaccard": 0.3, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X101", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O096", "observationB": "O094", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X102", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O093", "observationB": "O094", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X103", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O166", "observationB": "O167", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X104", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O166", "observationB": "O168", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X105", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O166", "observationB": "O165", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X106", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O167", "observationB": "O168", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X107", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O167", "observationB": "O165", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X108", "queryCell": "P06", "city": "New York City", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O168", "observationB": "O165", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X109", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O027", "observationB": "O028", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X110", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O027", "observationB": "O025", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X111", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O027", "observationB": "O026", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X112", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O028", "observationB": "O025", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X113", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O028", "observationB": "O026", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X114", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O025", "observationB": "O026", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X115", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O098", "observationB": "O099", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X116", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O098", "observationB": "O100", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X117", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O098", "observationB": "O097", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X118", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O099", "observationB": "O100", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X119", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O099", "observationB": "O097", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2857142857142857, "domainJaccard": 0.3333333333333333, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X120", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O100", "observationB": "O097", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X121", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O169", "observationB": "O170", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.045454545454545456, "domainJaccard": 0.15384615384615385, "urlsA": 15, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X122", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O169", "observationB": "O171", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 15, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X123", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O169", "observationB": "O172", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.05555555555555555, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 15, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X124", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O170", "observationB": "O171", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.13333333333333333, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X125", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O170", "observationB": "O172", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "domainJaccard": 0.2222222222222222, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X126", "queryCell": "P07", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O171", "observationB": "O172", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X127", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O030", "observationB": "O031", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X128", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O030", "observationB": "O032", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X129", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O030", "observationB": "O029", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X130", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O031", "observationB": "O032", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07692307692307693, "domainJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X131", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O031", "observationB": "O029", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X132", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O032", "observationB": "O029", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X133", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O101", "observationB": "O102", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X134", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O101", "observationB": "O103", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X135", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O101", "observationB": "O104", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X136", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O102", "observationB": "O103", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.3, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X137", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O102", "observationB": "O104", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X138", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O103", "observationB": "O104", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X139", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O176", "observationB": "O173", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 16, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 11, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X140", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O176", "observationB": "O174", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 16, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 11, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X141", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O176", "observationB": "O175", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.05555555555555555, "domainJaccard": 0.07692307692307693, "urlsA": 16, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 11, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X142", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O173", "observationB": "O174", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X143", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O173", "observationB": "O175", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X144", "queryCell": "P08", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O174", "observationB": "O175", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X145", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O033", "observationB": "O034", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.15384615384615385, "urlsA": 12, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X146", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O033", "observationB": "O035", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 12, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X147", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O033", "observationB": "O036", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 12, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X148", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O034", "observationB": "O035", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X149", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O034", "observationB": "O036", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X150", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O035", "observationB": "O036", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X151", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O108", "observationB": "O105", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "domainJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X152", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O108", "observationB": "O106", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "domainJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X153", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O108", "observationB": "O107", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X154", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O105", "observationB": "O106", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2222222222222222, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X155", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O105", "observationB": "O107", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X156", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O106", "observationB": "O107", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X157", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O179", "observationB": "O180", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.0625, "domainJaccard": 0.18181818181818182, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X158", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O179", "observationB": "O177", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X159", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O179", "observationB": "O178", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X160", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O180", "observationB": "O177", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X161", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O180", "observationB": "O178", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X162", "queryCell": "P09", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O177", "observationB": "O178", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X163", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O040", "observationB": "O037", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X164", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O040", "observationB": "O038", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X165", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O040", "observationB": "O039", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X166", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O037", "observationB": "O038", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X167", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O037", "observationB": "O039", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X168", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O038", "observationB": "O039", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X169", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O111", "observationB": "O112", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 1, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X170", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O111", "observationB": "O109", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 1, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X171", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O111", "observationB": "O110", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 1, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X172", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O112", "observationB": "O109", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X173", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O112", "observationB": "O110", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X174", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O109", "observationB": "O110", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X175", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O182", "observationB": "O183", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.11764705882352941, "urlsA": 20, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 12, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X176", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O182", "observationB": "O184", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.058823529411764705, "urlsA": 20, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 12, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X177", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O182", "observationB": "O181", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.043478260869565216, "domainJaccard": 0.07692307692307693, "urlsA": 20, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 12, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X178", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O183", "observationB": "O184", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.18181818181818182, "domainJaccard": 0.18181818181818182, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X179", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O183", "observationB": "O181", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X180", "queryCell": "P10", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O184", "observationB": "O181", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X181", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O043", "observationB": "O044", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.25, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X182", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O043", "observationB": "O041", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X183", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O043", "observationB": "O042", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X184", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O044", "observationB": "O041", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X185", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O044", "observationB": "O042", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X186", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O041", "observationB": "O042", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X187", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O114", "observationB": "O115", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.047619047619047616, "domainJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "urlsA": 16, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X188", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O114", "observationB": "O116", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.043478260869565216, "domainJaccard": 0.058823529411764705, "urlsA": 16, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X189", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O114", "observationB": "O113", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 16, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X190", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O115", "observationB": "O116", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "domainJaccard": 0.2727272727272727, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X191", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O115", "observationB": "O113", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X192", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O116", "observationB": "O113", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X193", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O185", "observationB": "O186", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X194", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O185", "observationB": "O187", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X195", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O185", "observationB": "O188", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X196", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O186", "observationB": "O187", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X197", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O186", "observationB": "O188", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X198", "queryCell": "P11", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O187", "observationB": "O188", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X199", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O046", "observationB": "O047", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X200", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O046", "observationB": "O048", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X201", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O046", "observationB": "O045", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X202", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O047", "observationB": "O048", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "no_answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X203", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O047", "observationB": "O045", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X204", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O048", "observationB": "O045", "statusA": "no_answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": false, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": null, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X205", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O117", "observationB": "O118", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.15384615384615385, "urlsA": 13, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X206", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O117", "observationB": "O119", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 13, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X207", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O117", "observationB": "O120", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 13, "urlsB": 1, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X208", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O118", "observationB": "O119", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.058823529411764705, "domainJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X209", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O118", "observationB": "O120", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 1, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X210", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O119", "observationB": "O120", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 1, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X211", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O192", "observationB": "O189", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X212", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O192", "observationB": "O190", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X213", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O192", "observationB": "O191", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X214", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O189", "observationB": "O190", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X215", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O189", "observationB": "O191", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X216", "queryCell": "P12", "city": "Chicago", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O190", "observationB": "O191", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X217", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O049", "observationB": "O050", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X218", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O049", "observationB": "O051", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X219", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O049", "observationB": "O052", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X220", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O050", "observationB": "O051", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.3, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X221", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O050", "observationB": "O052", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X222", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O051", "observationB": "O052", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X223", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O124", "observationB": "O121", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X224", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O124", "observationB": "O122", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X225", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O124", "observationB": "O123", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X226", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O121", "observationB": "O122", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2, "domainJaccard": 0.2222222222222222, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X227", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O121", "observationB": "O123", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X228", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O122", "observationB": "O123", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 1 }, { "pair": "X229", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O195", "observationB": "O196", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.0625, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X230", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O195", "observationB": "O193", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.05263157894736842, "domainJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X231", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O195", "observationB": "O194", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X232", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O196", "observationB": "O193", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "domainJaccard": 0.07692307692307693, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X233", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O196", "observationB": "O194", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X234", "queryCell": "P13", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O193", "observationB": "O194", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X235", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O056", "observationB": "O053", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.05263157894736842, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X236", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O056", "observationB": "O054", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X237", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O056", "observationB": "O055", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "urlsA": 11, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X238", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O053", "observationB": "O054", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X239", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O053", "observationB": "O055", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X240", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O054", "observationB": "O055", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.125, "domainJaccard": 0.2, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X241", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O127", "observationB": "O128", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X242", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O127", "observationB": "O125", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X243", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O127", "observationB": "O126", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X244", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O128", "observationB": "O125", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X245", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O128", "observationB": "O126", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.1, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X246", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O125", "observationB": "O126", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X247", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O198", "observationB": "O199", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.04, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 19, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 17 }, { "pair": "X248", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O198", "observationB": "O200", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X249", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O198", "observationB": "O197", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X250", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O199", "observationB": "O200", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.04, "domainJaccard": 0.05555555555555555, "urlsA": 19, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 17, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X251", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O199", "observationB": "O197", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "domainJaccard": 0.10526315789473684, "urlsA": 19, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 17, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X252", "queryCell": "P14", "city": "Miami", "intent": "rhinoplasty", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O200", "observationB": "O197", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X253", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O059", "observationB": "O060", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 10 }, { "pair": "X254", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O059", "observationB": "O057", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X255", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O059", "observationB": "O058", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X256", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O060", "observationB": "O057", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X257", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O060", "observationB": "O058", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 10, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X258", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O057", "observationB": "O058", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X259", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O130", "observationB": "O131", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X260", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O130", "observationB": "O132", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X261", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O130", "observationB": "O129", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X262", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O131", "observationB": "O132", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X263", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O131", "observationB": "O129", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.08333333333333333, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X264", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O132", "observationB": "O129", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.125, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X265", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O201", "observationB": "O202", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X266", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O201", "observationB": "O203", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X267", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O201", "observationB": "O204", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X268", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O202", "observationB": "O203", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X269", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O202", "observationB": "O204", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X270", "queryCell": "P15", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O203", "observationB": "O204", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X271", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O062", "observationB": "O063", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X272", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O062", "observationB": "O064", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 2, "urlJaccard": null, "domainJaccard": null, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X273", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O062", "observationB": "O061", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X274", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O063", "observationB": "O064", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 0, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 0 }, { "pair": "X275", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O063", "observationB": "O061", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X276", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O064", "observationB": "O061", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X277", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O133", "observationB": "O134", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 1, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X278", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O133", "observationB": "O135", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 1, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X279", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O133", "observationB": "O136", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 1, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X280", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O134", "observationB": "O135", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.05555555555555555, "domainJaccard": 0.07142857142857142, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 10, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 6 }, { "pair": "X281", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O134", "observationB": "O136", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X282", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O135", "observationB": "O136", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.125, "urlsA": 10, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 6, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X283", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O208", "observationB": "O205", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X284", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O208", "observationB": "O206", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X285", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O208", "observationB": "O207", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": false, "emptySourceSides": 1, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 0, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 0, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X286", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O205", "observationB": "O206", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X287", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O205", "observationB": "O207", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07692307692307693, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X288", "queryCell": "P16", "city": "Miami", "intent": "facelift", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O206", "observationB": "O207", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 6, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X289", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O065", "observationB": "O066", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X290", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O065", "observationB": "O067", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X291", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O065", "observationB": "O068", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 2, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 2, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X292", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O066", "observationB": "O067", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 5 }, { "pair": "X293", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O066", "observationB": "O068", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2, "domainJaccard": 0.25, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X294", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O067", "observationB": "O068", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "urlsA": 5, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 5, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X295", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O140", "observationB": "O137", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X296", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O140", "observationB": "O138", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X297", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O140", "observationB": "O139", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 1, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X298", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O137", "observationB": "O138", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.06666666666666667, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 9, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 9 }, { "pair": "X299", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O137", "observationB": "O139", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X300", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O138", "observationB": "O139", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.07692307692307693, "domainJaccard": 0.3, "urlsA": 9, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 9, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X301", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O211", "observationB": "O212", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X302", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O211", "observationB": "O209", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X303", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O211", "observationB": "O210", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 6, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X304", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O212", "observationB": "O209", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.14285714285714285, "domainJaccard": 0.15384615384615385, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 8, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 8 }, { "pair": "X305", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O212", "observationB": "O210", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.09090909090909091, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X306", "queryCell": "P17", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "selection", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O209", "observationB": "O210", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.2, "domainJaccard": 0.2222222222222222, "urlsA": 8, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 8, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X307", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O072", "observationB": "O069", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.06896551724137931, "domainJaccard": 0.10526315789473684, "urlsA": 24, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 14, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X308", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O072", "observationB": "O070", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 24, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 14, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X309", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O072", "observationB": "O071", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 24, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 14, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X310", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O069", "observationB": "O070", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X311", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O069", "observationB": "O071", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X312", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 1, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O070", "observationB": "O071", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0.16666666666666666, "domainJaccard": 0.4, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 3, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X313", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O143", "observationB": "O144", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X314", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O143", "observationB": "O141", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X315", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O143", "observationB": "O142", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X316", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O144", "observationB": "O141", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X317", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O144", "observationB": "O142", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1111111111111111, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X318", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 2, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O141", "observationB": "O142", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 5, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 3 }, { "pair": "X319", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "gemini", "observationA": "O214", "observationB": "O215", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 7, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 7 }, { "pair": "X320", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O214", "observationB": "O216", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X321", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "chatgpt", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O214", "observationB": "O213", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 3, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 3, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X322", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_overviews", "observationA": "O215", "observationB": "O216", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.1, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 4, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 4 }, { "pair": "X323", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "gemini", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O215", "observationB": "O213", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0.125, "urlsA": 7, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 7, "domainsB": 2 }, { "pair": "X324", "queryCell": "P18", "city": "Miami", "intent": "breast_augmentation", "variant": "surgeon_facility_evidence", "wave": 3, "platformA": "ai_overviews", "platformB": "ai_mode", "observationA": "O216", "observationB": "O213", "statusA": "answer", "statusB": "answer", "answerPair": true, "bothSourceNonempty": true, "emptySourceSides": 0, "urlJaccard": 0, "domainJaccard": 0, "urlsA": 4, "urlsB": 2, "domainsA": 4, "domainsB": 2 } ], "downloads": [], "qualitativeReviewStatus": "PASS", "qualitativeReviewNotes": [ "The denominator is this fixed 36-slot source-page follow-up, not all 216 planned core responses or all cosmetic-surgery websites.", "True means positive evidence on the inspected page, not independently verified credentials, availability, prices or clinical quality.", "Null means not established from this inspected scope. Static extraction alone cannot establish that a fact is absent from dynamic or image content.", "Null means not inspectable or no selected page. Inaccessible, navigation, booking, no-answer and collection-failure states are kept separate.", "Treatment and named-practitioner evidence uses substantive page content; location/contact evidence may also use the inspected footer or contact links.", "Consultation-location evidence is separate from operating-facility evidence. An office address, appointment link or generic accreditation statement does not prove where a named surgeon performs a procedure.", "Practitioner evidence requires substantive clinician information, excluding navigation-only names and patient-testimonial names alone. Clinic contact evidence excludes directory-publisher support contacts.", "Price qualification evidence means visible fees, payment/insurance/financing context or a relevant price limitation, not a verified treatment quote.", "Private HTML/text snapshots are retained locally by SHA-256 and are not redistributed in the public dataset. Positive evidence is not a verified license or confirmation of clinical quality." ], "qualitativeReviewMethod": "Assistant inspection of saved static page text and contact links, with explicit per-page scope; regex contexts are private review aids, not the final feature decisions. No human or clinical review is claimed.", "qualitativeReviewSha256": "89f5814e242b5e4920d879755139d647bd124c771f36c9a35b8faed83971aa46", "qualitativeReviewCounts": { "slots": 36, "selectedSources": 34, "uniqueSelectedSources": 33, "inspectedSlots": 26, "inspectedPages": 25, "answerNarrativesReviewed": 0, "treatment": 15, "practitioner": 24, "location": 25, "consultationLocation": 7, "operatingFacility": 4, "contact": 19, "priceQualification": 12 } }